|
So, here are some of my opinions:
Bluelightz - leaning scum
If you read his filter, you'll see that he only goes for Sinani and doesn't really focus on anyone else. Then he attacks ghost by simply posting his filter and asserting vague scumminess.
Paperscraps - scum
I've been talking about this in IRC and in thread. If he isn't lynched today then I'll probably go more in-depth tomorrow.
ghost_403 - null
I sort of understand the case against him but I don't think its strong enough.
Sentinel - null
I was leaning scum on him earlier, but seeing him push Paperscraps is making me change my opinion. As stated in IRC, I will definitely go after him tomorrow if Paper ends up flipping town.
Palmar - leaning scum
D1 all he did was tunnel Sinani. Then he makes this post:
On February 18 2012 08:41 Palmar wrote:
So, this game is weird. It's nice playing with new people because they actually bother to post in the thread and establish their innocence.
Paperscraps is in my eyes basically confirmed town.
Probulous is playing the most pro-town game of anyone here.
froggynoddy is almost definitely town given his play in both thread and IRC on day one.
bluelightz responded completely incorrectly to my pressure in the thread, but he seems to have done it in a very towny way.
rgTS is a troll, but meh, he's probably town
grackaroni is very towny based on his reactions to my pressure on day one.
prplhz seems to be putting the effort into this game now that I'd expect him to. I'm least certain on him on this list.
So, what is left is to find the scum in the following.
phagga, sentinel, nisani, ghost, lanaia, mderg
And I mean... we have probably at least 4-6 scum left, so fuck it. Just lynch into this list. If we have vigis, might as well shoot into it too, because why not. Chances of hitting scum are ridiculously high.
gg no re
Palmar makes a lot of bold assertions in this post. The fact that he has no reasoning is bad, but the main part is that they are all town reads, which don't do anything to help town. The list at the end is also very scummy. Limiting scum suspects is anti-town.
|
On February 18 2012 12:56 Nisani201 wrote:So, here are some of my opinions: Palmar - leaning scum D1 all he did was tunnel Sinani. Then he makes this post: Show nested quote +On February 18 2012 08:41 Palmar wrote:
So, this game is weird. It's nice playing with new people because they actually bother to post in the thread and establish their innocence.
Paperscraps is in my eyes basically confirmed town.
Probulous is playing the most pro-town game of anyone here.
froggynoddy is almost definitely town given his play in both thread and IRC on day one.
bluelightz responded completely incorrectly to my pressure in the thread, but he seems to have done it in a very towny way.
rgTS is a troll, but meh, he's probably town
grackaroni is very towny based on his reactions to my pressure on day one.
prplhz seems to be putting the effort into this game now that I'd expect him to. I'm least certain on him on this list.
So, what is left is to find the scum in the following.
phagga, sentinel, nisani, ghost, lanaia, mderg
And I mean... we have probably at least 4-6 scum left, so fuck it. Just lynch into this list. If we have vigis, might as well shoot into it too, because why not. Chances of hitting scum are ridiculously high.
gg no re Palmar makes a lot of bold assertions in this post. The fact that he has no reasoning is bad, but the main part is that they are all town reads, which don't do anything to help town. The list at the end is also very scummy. Limiting scum suspects is anti-town.
This is probably the worst thing you could have ever done. LOL
|
It's scummy to think that Palmar is scum?
|
Palmar is a good player.
If paperscraps was scum as you believe it would leave little doubt in my mind that palmar is also scum. He is a good enough town player to not call people you consider obv scum confirmed town.
I don't think I can write a case on my phone but nisani is scum and Needs to be lynched. I'm waking up early tomorrow anyways will write a case then. (my school shuts off my Internet at 11)
|
Grackaroni, you fail to consider the possibility that Palmar is scum. Do you have information that I don't?
|
Can you update the OP with who has been modkilled/replaced? Thanks
|
On February 18 2012 13:15 Nisani201 wrote:
Grackaroni, you fail to consider the possibility that Palmar is scum. Do you have information that I don't?
Of course not. There's 2 scum teams and the idea of me and palmar being scum together is extremely unlikely.
No way I could know if palmar is scum I just think his scum reads are pretty accurate and he seems less lazy compared to purgatory. Bluelightz could be scum don't understand his wrong in a townie way opinion.
|
I’m impressed, ghost. I’ll remove my vote on you for today.
So it appears a bunch of stuff happened while I was at work.
I very much agree about sentinel. I thought it yesterday and would have lynched him.
So, here are my reads, ignoring our friend ghost.
Grackaroni:
I want to lean scum on him. Unfortunately, this is pretty much only gut. There’s nothing I can really pinpoint, but the entirety of him is rubbing me the wrong way. An issue I had was with him saying his biggest scum read was blue. I mean, sure, blue is scummy, but not worthy of the title of biggest scum read.
On February 18 2012 13:29 Grackaroni wrote:Show nested quote +On February 18 2012 13:15 Nisani201 wrote:
Grackaroni, you fail to consider the possibility that Palmar is scum. Do you have information that I don't? Of course not. There's 2 scum teams and the idea of me and palmar being scum together is extremely unlikely. No way I could know if palmar is scum I just think his scum reads are pretty accurate and he seems less lazy compared to purgatory. Bluelightz could be scum don't understand his wrong in a townie way opinion.
This post here feels very… suspect. It just feels like something's off with it.
[UoN]Sentinel:
Not really much I can say, other than his overreaction to the pressure has really sealed it for me. That was a MASSIVE OMGUS if I’ve ever seen one.
On February 18 2012 10:14 [UoN]Sentinel wrote:
The support to lynch me is gathering, so once again you post not only your intentions of lynching me, but also a weak justification to make it look like you're not a bandwagon. Everything you've said about me has already been said, Paperscraps.
I’m sure it’s fairly difficult to make a case on someone who hasn’t been uber prominent without repeating what others have said.
For now, I don’t think Palmar is scum, but I will never be sure. I know that I cannot read him worth a damn, so I don’t know. He’s definitely not high on my list.
I do have other reads, they’re just not nearly as prominent.
|
OH RIGHT.
I'm voting sentinel because I shouldn't've let you guys switch to spirit yesterday. Also because I think he's scum because of his overreaction to the case made on him. I don't care that it was horrible, I care how overboard he went.
|
Hey lanai, how do you feel about Somali?
|
|
|
Sinani is dead so i assume you mean Nisani. Nisani is null for me at best now, but he's degrading now that I see where paper came from in regards to him.
|
Lanaia do you think Paperscraps is OMGUSing me?
|
It's just odd. You seemed defensive about Nisani earlier and as soon as I call him out you call me scum based off your gut and because I called somebody scummy my best scum read.
|
On February 18 2012 14:04 Grackaroni wrote:
It's just odd. You seemed defensive about Nisani earlier and as soon as I call him out you call me scum based off your gut and because I called somebody scummy my best scum read.
It wasn't that. It was because of how you worded it.
Also I don't know if he's omgusing you, nisani. did he even see that you'd done it before he called you scum?
|
On February 18 2012 14:08 Lanaia wrote:Show nested quote +On February 18 2012 14:04 Grackaroni wrote:
It's just odd. You seemed defensive about Nisani earlier and as soon as I call him out you call me scum based off your gut and because I called somebody scummy my best scum read. It wasn't that. It was because of how you worded it. Also I don't know if he's omgusing you, nisani. did he even see that you'd done it before he called you scum?
Huh? You said my wording was weird too but those were the reasons you gave. If you want to you can elaborate on the wording but it's a very weak case.
|
Of course it's a weak case when it mostly relies on gut, hun. I dunno, just the way you referred to Palmar in that post bothered me. I dunno, I don't understand why blue was your biggest scumread, I guess.
|
As of explaining by Probulous and ghost's defense I am unvoting ghost_403.
P.S: Might take a long time since my internet is going on and off, on and off...
|
You admit that this is a weak case and that your other reads are less prominent? From my perspective the best explanation for you posting a weak case on me was you trying to defend a team mate by attacking me. I don't know what your other motivation could be the timing is suspect.
|
I leave you guys alone for a few hours, and come back to wat.
|
|
|
|
|
|
EPT
