BC's Arkham City - Page 3

On February 09 2012 05:17 Palmar wrote:
we're masoned (ie: we know each other's alignment, confirmed by host).

On February 09 2012 16:24 Adam4167 wrote:
If he was an insane DT, I think that might have come up by now.

So we're left with him being an 'alignment cop' with a correct read on you, or hes just lying and trying to drag you down as he dies.

On February 09 2012 17:49 Tunkeg wrote:
Well, then it is easy, then one of you are lieing, okidoki. Carry on then.

On February 09 2012 17:53 Toadesstern wrote:
he claimed nothing and won't claim. now. stop fishing.

On February 09 2012 17:53 Toadesstern wrote:
btw here's what DocH posted earlier when I claimed Two-Face:

He KNOWS, that some powers have a second aspect to it, therefore he believes my claim. I still think he just understood what I was doing from the very beginning because I lied as little as possible and got a shitload of breadcrumbs in my fakeclaim to make sure the guy who knows my role is knowing what I'm doing. Apparently that guy is DocH.

On February 09 2012 17:54 Toadesstern wrote:
stop giving Schworz excuses. I want him to get his ass in this thread and explain what the fuck is going on and why he is lying to us.

On February 09 2012 18:02 DoctorHelvetica wrote:
Revealing the category of my power role would put me and the town at a disadvantage so I won't do it. Like I said, if it's necessary to avoid getting lynched then that's fine. Otherwise it's best for medics to protect me, which will keep both myself and Toades alive indefinitely.

I was going to make my case on both you and Radfield today, but I'd like to wait for rG to explain himself a little. If he doesn't claim insanity then either he is scum or BC is a bastard mod. I'm willing to take my chances on the former. It's a crazy situation but that doesn't matter, an outright lie like that is about the scummiest thing you can do. Considering the mafias hit on me failed they might just want me lynched.

On February 09 2012 18:08 DoctorHelvetica wrote:

Please explain to me how that would work? It's impossible that both me and rG are telling the truth unless he is insane.

I ask BC "Is there any possibility that our role PMs are not completely true? Can somebody get a result other than "ROLE" by DT checking me?" and he says No. I ask BC "Are there roles roles that have a mechanic that is not known to the player possessing that role?" and he says that is not the case. Meaning if rGTheSchworz has any chances of getting an unreliable check, he would know about it.

So all that's left to figure out is if rG is insane or BC is withholding some other information from me. If he is sane then one of us is a liar.

On February 09 2012 18:22 Adam4167 wrote:


What makes you 100% certain of this?

On February 09 2012 18:24 Toadesstern wrote:
vote Schworz, force him to explain the shit he is doing. There is no other possibility than one of those 2 lying. Not a single one.

Also remember that EVERYONE was telling Schworz his move yesterday was retarded. I was trying to catch some bullets and maybe make catwoman DT me instead.
There was not a single reason why he should have claimed as Two-face. Just imagine you're a blue role that's only once in this game and about 8 players in this game (mafia + Catwoman) need to kill you outright.
You think the real Two-face would step in and Counterclaim? Hell no he'd be sitting in his chair, laughing being happy and shutting the fuck up. So what he did was retarded if he really is Two-Face.

What if it was not retarded? What if he is Catwoman and was calling bullshit on the duel-claim Palmar did? What if he was trying to get the liar to figure out which of actually is Two-Face and didn't think both of us are lying?
Remember that everyone told him that his first claim (DT) was bullshit as well because now Catwoman would simply shoot him in the dark? Yes it wasn't the brightest move either. However, as Catwoman it makes perfect sense because he's not afraid to be shot by Catwoman if he's that role himself.

Unless Schworz stepps in this thread and gives the best explanation ever this guy has to die right now.

On February 09 2012 18:28 Tunkeg wrote:


I find it very amusing that you of all want rgTS to come in and explain himself, knowing that was him that pushed you off your Two-Face claim. You are as of now the only confirmed liar in this thread, maybe we should just lynch you.

On February 09 2012 18:30 Toadesstern wrote:

nah Palmar is a liar as well and I don't know what he's up to. And I barly lied. Pretty much everything I said was true.

On February 09 2012 18:08 Adam4167 wrote:
I also spotted another Blueslip out of DrH earlier:



Unless he heard it in the phone-booth of manloving.


I am far more suspicious of rGtheSchworz at this point, as every description in the OP that includes a DT or being DT'd seems to heavily indicate that it will be a role-reveal, not alignment reveal.

Answers will come in 6 hours, otherwise, start taking his neck measurements.

On February 09 2012 18:40 Toadesstern wrote:

what was going on yesterday. What do you think about the fact that a claimed DT is telling us a blue role of ours is in fact red?
Could you think of a plausible reason for a townie to tell us a blue is actually a red role?

On February 09 2012 18:42 Palmar wrote:


I do not recall anything like that.

On February 09 2012 18:49 DoctorHelvetica wrote:

Because the language I used in my posts refers to Toadessterns role PM specifically. I checked with BC a great deal to make sure that we would have enough similarities in our PM for me to be able to confirm myself to him as well.




See the above. Toades also pointed out the specific post in which I was able to confirm my named role to him. I know who Toadesstern is and vice-versa. I will reveal my named role only if it is necessary to save myself but I will not elaborate on who toadesstern is or what my hidden power is.

@Palmer










etc

On February 09 2012 19:01 DoctorHelvetica wrote:
If there is still serious doubt later in the day cycle I will claim my name. It is a minor disadvantage to town because it gives the mafia some information I'd rather they not have but if this continues to be a major distraction then it's for the best.

The language I used was specific enough I think that I couldn't have picked it up off of Toades' own breadcrumbs. I thought you made up the immortality power actually as well as the Two-Face claim, it was the fact that you were still claiming to be immortal that made me realize who you were.

On February 09 2012 18:45 wherebugsgo wrote:


wtf LOGIC?

gtfo noob you're not supposed to use logic in here

On February 09 2012 20:26 DoctorHelvetica wrote:

he fucked up. he can't actually go back and redo everything to make the best possible move so what exactly do you want?