It was not BAD town play, sure there were some players whose activity and posting were very bad, but more than anything it was poor BLUE play that lost town the game. Sure the scum team did ok, but after day 1 all lynches were the best possible lynches for town.

Tunkeg

Norway1235 Posts

February 23 2012 12:43 GMT

#4149

On February 23 2012 19:00 Palmar wrote:
GG everyone.

Short explanation of my strategy. Seeing as batman was a very pro-town role in the game for the most part I was not really afraid of being lynched UNLESS I shot Hugo early. Town "giving" me joker after I find hugo would've been retarded, so my mission was to kill the joker as early as possible.

But it's so hard to blue-hunt...

So I decided to shoot some scum night 1, could even hit hugo and then try to look like I'm not batman. I shot radfield, but of course he was talia.

Toad being the joker didn't click until about the time I posted this

The reason for all the trolling and spamming is that I wanted to make the thread as useless for scumhunting as possible. The reason being that my theory was that if I made actually playing mafia impossible, the town would turn to their blue roles for support, thus allowing me to better identify them.

I think it kinda worked, we got a load of claims early in the game and they helped me tremendously. I mean... figuring out the exact identity of one person out of 30-ish on day 2 is not something that normally happens, but given the chaotic thread it was much easier.

After finally killing toad night 3 (fuck you scum for rb-ing me night 2) it was basically just a game of "who among the scummy people could be Hugo". VisceraEyes fit the bill, so I murdered him and left the game on night 4.

So yeah, those are my thoughts on my own game. If I have time I might write something about the other factions.

Also, Kurumi is hilarious for choosing to appear as ras al gul

So where you at no point afraid of town lynching you?

I mean all your claims followed up by the "I never claimed" and "never been in the Phone Booth" posts had me wanting to lynch you until I understood you were Batman.

Tunkeg

Norway1235 Posts

February 23 2012 12:51 GMT

#4151

Yeah, I see that, but Palmar doing these bad claims would be more scummy then some newbie doing it. Therefor more chance he get voted off.

So even though it was the amount of claims and confusion that gave away that he was Batman in the end Ihe could have been lynched off before we realised this.

Scum tried this somewhat on day 3, but had they gone for it earlier I would have joined the wagon easily.

Tunkeg

Norway1235 Posts

February 23 2012 13:33 GMT

#4166

On February 23 2012 22:22 Jackal58 wrote:

Show nested quote +

Ya some vig shot him night one. Some medic let the only confirmed townie die night one.

Did you have to claim in the Phone Booth or did you chose to?

Tunkeg

Norway1235 Posts

February 23 2012 13:56 GMT

#4168

On February 23 2012 21:56 syllogism wrote:
There were too many people in the game who realized that this was the third party palmar for him to ever get lynched. Well I would hope so. Why do you think he would play like this as mafia? He would get shot by some vig or at least DT checked very quickly.

Well the further the game dragged on the more certain it was that this play could only be explained from a 3rd party perspective. But early game this wasn't known. If scum had put in an effort early to have Palmar lynched I think this town would have killed him. Not that scum needed to do this, as they won anyway, but at least Palmar put himself in a more vulnerable place by playing this way than he would playing more straigth forward.

Tunkeg

Norway1235 Posts

February 23 2012 15:19 GMT

#4179

On February 24 2012 00:17 rgTheSchworz wrote:
Also, If I want to lie as scum, I have to lie as town, while being helpful.
Else, scumtell.

Hmm, you should never do scummy stuff as town to help your meta as scum...

Tunkeg

Norway1235 Posts

February 23 2012 19:00 GMT

#4192

On February 24 2012 03:40 Kurumi wrote:

Show nested quote +

I pinned Schworz as Town D1 and WBG as scum D1 and that never changed. Then I added Tunkeg and Adam to town list somewhere around D2.
They were so damn good.

Hehe, I think you are trolling, but I'll thank you anyways

I actually felt abit bad for going after you on Day 4, you having been more of an asset to town then most of the townies. But I think if we hadn't taken you out, town would have lost even badder ^^

Tunkeg

Norway1235 Posts

February 23 2012 21:23 GMT

#4225

I say a townplayer have way more to lose by lying, because of what WBG says. All the lies made it so damn hard to be certain on any of the lying towns, and that was what got rg lynched in the end...

Prev 1 8 9 10 All

Please or register to reply.

Live Events Refresh