Perhaps not. It feels like a solid read from my point of view.

If you want to know, send me a PM of your top scumcandidates, otherwise I´d prefer to gather a solid case before I make it public. We have 2 days left in the day, and I don´t have the time to read through the whole thread at the moment.

sinani206

United States1959 Posts

October 07 2011 22:04 GMT

#1373

+ Show Spoiler +

GMarshal

United States22154 Posts

October 07 2011 22:16 GMT

#1374

On October 08 2011 07:04 sinani206 wrote:
+ Show Spoiler +

Sinani206 the overenthusiastic popcorn aficionado has drowned and died a happy death!

Nisani201

United States1400 Posts

October 07 2011 22:31 GMT

#1375

So ur browing tl mafia xlv and huntin scum
wen the inbox turns yello. U anser it n
the voice is "omg ur scum." U tell ur
buddies in the chat and they say
"lol he's dead"
THEN WHO WAS PM?

Forumite

Sweden3280 Posts

October 07 2011 22:59 GMT

#1376

Kenpachi, it´s the second one on the list of that PM you sent.

Forumite

Sweden3280 Posts

October 08 2011 03:32 GMT

#1377

On second thought, I´ll just drop it here before going to bed.

wherebugsgo is scum
WBGs motivations around the Palmar lynch was to disrupt discussion. The next day NC+Incog+WBG did the case on Curu, which was one of the reasons that two of those players got lynched, that´s 2 days wasted, worth risking one scum.

He did the customary early weak FoS on jcarl, but once we got to the lynch, he was the primary defender of jcarl, actively disputing Erandorr but also pushing and joining other lynches, like those on Sevryn, risk.nuke, sinani, me, and of course one of the players joining the mislynch on xtfftc. In all of this he´s said that Jcarl wasn´t just an unlikely scum, and an unsure lynch (no clear connections to others, this was repeated a few times), but that he must be Town, and adamantly defended him, at least until the lynch was decided, right after he posted that he really do consider jcarl.

On October 06 2011 07:21 wherebugsgo wrote:
can we kill sinani tomorrow?

I'll consider jcarl/sevryn too. We need to keep an eye on risk as well.

This one is really bad, WBG explained his Townread by quoting something in PM-land, something that Erandorr didn´t buy. Obviously he was wrong or lying, or jcarl is just that good at fooling people. I´m leaning towards lying.

On October 06 2011 01:44 wherebugsgo wrote:
Erandor have you not been reading the PMs I've sent you?

Jesus jcarl is not scum you thickhead

WBG has been very active in the thread and in PMs, he´s been putting himself out there, messing things up, causing confusion, while his allies have been allowed to lurk. If Town starts to hunt lurkers, then he´s safe, if Town hunt active Townies, then Jcarl would have been safe.

In the end, there are 2 things that really speak against a WBG lynch.
First Mig told me that WBG got scared when Jackal and I were aiming for him, and revealed his scumreads. Also Mig thought NC and Incog were more likely scum, and were manipulating WBG. That´s been cleared up, of those 3 only one possible scum remain.
Second, WBG and jcarl have posted some long conversations, but not even this is a very good defence. Jcarl has been very quiet in the thread and PM-land, by all accounts, except his own. I´m seriously considering that WBG and jcarl faked those conversations, to pass the time, and to make sure they wouldn´t get tied together at endgame. It would definetly explain why jcarl didn´t feel like lurking.

##Vote wherebugsgo

wherebugsgo

Japan10647 Posts

October 08 2011 03:52 GMT

#1378

I had a feeling you thought I was scum.

That's why I PMed you.

I can't really say anything other than the fact that my play is not consistent with being scum. Yes, I know I haven't had the best reads this game, and for whatever reason people are expecting me to play better (and yes, I admit, I have played badly.)

I've gone on tilt several times this game already and I think that was part of my mistake. Every time I did it I destroyed whatever remained of my ability to reason.

Anyway, tomorrow you guys can decide whether you'd like to win or not. I realize I haven't been much use to you all (and I'll take the responsibility for xt's mislynch) but if you lynch me you'll be down another townie and it's not like that'll help you at all.