EPTLord of the Rings Mafia - Page 10
| Forum Index > TL Mafia |
|
Curu
Canada2817 Posts
| ||
|
OriginalName
Canada1140 Posts
| ||
|
Navillus
United States1188 Posts
##Vote Drazerk | ||
|
Navillus
United States1188 Posts
| ||
|
Ciryandor
United States3735 Posts
On September 17 2011 09:46 prplhz wrote: EBWOP Oh yea Samwyse also had it at some point right? He had it and then he willingly gave it to Frodo 'cause he didn't want to walk around with it or something and then later he indirectly carried it, carrying Frodo who was carrying it. Woopseedaisy. Yes, Sam did carry the ring for a few hours when Frodo was stung by Shelob as they crossed into Mordor; then gave it up once he discovered Frodo to be alive after rescuing him. Quite a faithful colleague he was, doing all that. Do note that its effects are focused only on the person who possesses it, no more, no less. | ||
|
Ciryandor
United States3735 Posts
On September 17 2011 10:24 Navillus wrote: To clarify though I'm really suspicious of him for dropping a third vote on someone that originally had no justification, then he voted without adding any justification. Yeah, I was going to post on that point that it looked like he was blatantly trying to start a bandwagon with his vote right there. Suspicious, but not yet enough to trigger a vote from me for it. | ||
|
chaoser
United States5541 Posts
| ||
|
Navillus
United States1188 Posts
Frodo probably can give the ring Sam almost definitely can Aragorn possibly can And In LOTR the powerful people, even the goodies made it seem particularly bad if they were to get the ring, specifically Galdrial and Gandalf make sure never to touch it, this won't necessarily factor into the game but I think it's info everyone should have, beyond everyone getting the basics (and do add if I missed something obviously important) I think we should stop talking about this. | ||
|
xtfftc
United Kingdom2343 Posts
On September 17 2011 09:32 Radfield wrote: Posts like this(mine) should not be given consideration when you are trying to determine a players alignment. They definitely should be. | ||
|
Navillus
United States1188 Posts
On September 17 2011 10:35 xtfftc wrote: It's not really important as it's all speculations at the moment but I don't see Tom Bombadil as anything else but a neutral PGO who shoots at anyone who visits him apart from hobbits and Gandalf. They definitely should be. See now I don't know the lore but unless this is like a 110% perfect fit, I'd rather stay away from guessing such specific roles (especially with specific exceptions) just from lore. Even if it is a fit, maybe Curu doesn't like PGOs (paranoid gun owners if like me you had to look it up, xtfftc described the whole role though) so I really don't think we can or should try to assume these things. | ||
|
Drazerk
United Kingdom31255 Posts
On September 17 2011 10:23 Navillus wrote: God @#$% it I have now rolled VT in literally every &*!@ing game that had it that I have played in >:[ anyways if Drazerk gets to vote people with little to no justification then I do too ##Vote Drazerk Fine with me... no idea why you would claim VT this early in the game though. | ||
|
GreYMisT
United States6736 Posts
On September 17 2011 10:33 Navillus wrote: Also I don't like cluttering the space with too much talk about the ring, I think for the sake of those with no knowledge of the lore I should say (btw I've only seen the movies) Frodo probably can give the ring Sam almost definitely can Aragorn possibly can And In LOTR the powerful people, even the goodies made it seem particularly bad if they were to get the ring, specifically Galdrial and Gandalf make sure never to touch it, this won't necessarily factor into the game but I think it's info everyone should have, beyond everyone getting the basics (and do add if I missed something obviously important) I think we should stop talking about this. Navillus I think the following list is correct in terms of most resistant to the ring's corruption to the least resistant. Hobbits Wizards Elves Dwarves Men I think a townie should never give the ring away unless specific mechanics of the ring make it detrimental to hold on to (corruption possibly). Anyways to get more discussion going what do you guys think about lynching a lurker day 1 in the absence of a better target? Maybe its just me but whenever this happens it always ends badly for the town. Don't seem to get much info from them because they were lurking from the get go anyways. Thoughts on the lynch lurkers policy guys? | ||
|
OriginalName
Canada1140 Posts
On September 17 2011 10:29 chaoser wrote: OriginalName, what do you "sorta see" about greymist? I sort of see why people are suspicous but it really boils down to a poor reaction to a really null tell (IE fishing for the ring as if you noted i fished for the wand in PYP2 and flipped town) I want to see how things develop first. | ||
|
OriginalName
Canada1140 Posts
On September 17 2011 10:58 GreYMisT wrote: Navillus I think the following list is correct in terms of most resistant to the ring's corruption to the least resistant. Hobbits Wizards Elves Dwarves Men I think a townie should never give the ring away unless specific mechanics of the ring make it detrimental to hold on to (corruption possibly). Anyways to get more discussion going what do you guys think about lynching a lurker day 1 in the absence of a better target? Maybe its just me but whenever this happens it always ends badly for the town. Don't seem to get much info from them because they were lurking from the get go anyways. Thoughts on the lynch lurkers policy guys? ... DIDNT YOU JUST WANT TO TRADE THE RING TO YOU. ok i see im not sure if scum or really stupid. | ||
|
wherebugsgo
Japan10647 Posts
My sons, my residents of Middle Earth, Today, we all have a mission. We must destroy the evils that walk among us, and we must be united in doing so. They will use deception. They will use force. And they will not relent. We must be careful, otherwise we may be tricked. But, we cannot be complacent; we must fight. And fight we shall. On September 17 2011 09:26 Drazerk wrote: I actually had stated my reasons regarding the ring earlier I just didn't vote for you then. My brethren, I have only one thing to say to this: Liar. | ||
|
GreYMisT
United States6736 Posts
On September 17 2011 11:11 OriginalName wrote: ... DIDNT YOU JUST WANT TO TRADE THE RING TO YOU. ok i see im not sure if scum or really stupid. sigh. As supersoft mentioned on page 8 of this thread, the "guys give the ring to me" bit was a joke post. No one can possibly believe that a real scum player would step into the spotlight, on the first page of day one, and with no reasoning demand what might be a very powerful ability just be handed over to him. The post you quoted is my actual opinion on the subject of the ring or any other items that might be present in this game. | ||
|
Navillus
United States1188 Posts
On September 17 2011 11:11 OriginalName wrote: ... DIDNT YOU JUST WANT TO TRADE THE RING TO YOU. ok i see im not sure if scum or really stupid. Wait does anyone think that he was seriously trying to get the ring?? I thought it was quite clear that his original post was a joke, not just the content he makes it look joking, it really is a null tell and doesn't matter if he contradicts it, cause you know, it was a joke... | ||
|
Ciryandor
United States3735 Posts
On September 17 2011 11:19 Navillus wrote: Wait does anyone think that he was seriously trying to get the ring?? I thought it was quite clear that his original post was a joke, not just the content he makes it look joking, it really is a null tell and doesn't matter if he contradicts it, cause you know, it was a joke... Just a talking point, what if he's Smeagol/Gollum? His behavior seems normal if that was his role; as he would want the ring, try to fish for it, and throttle anyone who got in his way of looking for it. | ||
|
raynpelikoneet
Finland43270 Posts
On September 17 2011 09:57 kitaman27 wrote: sandroba, you mentioned you won't be around until Sunday. Will you be providing your opening thoughts today so you don't earn yourself a free pass in the day one lynch? Would you provide some info why would you like to heve me lynched? And why would you ever want to claim you have/had The Ring (at least at this stage of a game - or with this stage of info). Do you really think it's wise? | ||
|
kitaman27
United States9245 Posts
On September 17 2011 11:31 raynpelikoneet wrote: Would you provide some info why would you like to heve me lynched? And why would you ever want to claim you have/had The Ring (at least at this stage of a game - or with this stage of info). Do you really think it's wise? Mainly to get a response from a player I've never played with before. Feel free to prove to me why you shouldn't be lynched. Obviously whoever has the ring should not claim. What I said was for the player to claim if they ever passed on the ring, since they were very likely be town. | ||
| ||
