|
On September 18 2011 03:47 GreYMisT wrote:
Jackal, what do you feel is the best course of action? lynch you to confirm tntked? because we need to get to scumhunting as soon as possible.
I would say in the short term you guys need to decide which is more beneficial - lynching me or letting me live. You guys have to make that call. I can't do it for you. If you believe there is a higher probability that I'm lying scum than ballsy townie you must lynch me. If you do lynch me you're agreeing that tnkted is guaranteed town and will do all you can to keep him alive for as long as you can. If anybody brings him up as a lynch target lynch the hell out of the person suggesting it.
I think the best course of action is to wait for everybody to weigh in. We have over 24 hour remaining. I think?
GMarshal - How much time is left in the day?
I want opinions from Dreamflower and Forumite. I also want more from Curu. He has posted something about WBG and that's about it.
|
You said you have the "item" right? are you aware of what happens to the item in the event of your death?
|
United States22154 Posts
On September 18 2011 04:00 Jackal58 wrote:
GMarshal - How much time is left in the day?
31 hours.
|
On September 18 2011 03:43 Jackal58 wrote:
Dreamflower and Forumite need to step it up as well.
Reading through the thread as you said that.
I believe Jackal and tnkted's claim, and we should back off from them. It´s a closed game, and the simplest solution is that they got something interesting in their PMs, not that Scum suddenly tried an extremely risky gambit to get two of their own killed. In my eyes, they are confirmed Town, although how long they´ll last is anyones guess.
WBG, I feel like he knows what´s going on, and he´s not being honest about it. Anyway I think backing off from him might be a good idea too.
Right now I´m leaning towards Nisani as the next lynch, and I want to know if the case will hold up before scrutiny.
|
I'm against lynching for a confirmed townie at this point. That doesn't help us catch scum.
|
GreyMisT can you explain your reasoning? If you believe their claim, you should believe they are Townies. Yet you say you feel like WBG knows what's going on, which following your belief would mean he knows they're Townies, but he's not being honest about it and trying to get them lynched? So we should back off him too?
Say what?
|
On September 18 2011 04:50 Curu wrote:
GreyMisT can you explain your reasoning? If you believe their claim, you should believe they are Townies. Yet you say you feel like WBG knows what's going on, which following your belief would mean he knows they're Townies, but he's not being honest about it and trying to get them lynched? So we should back off him too?
Say what?
I believe you mixxed together my and forumite's post directly above you
|
WBG wants to get tnkted and Jackal lynched? Didn´t he just push to know more? That does throw some doubt on my assumptions.
Curu, what do you think about WBG?
|
Jesus Christ you guys are fucking slow.
On September 17 2011 14:38 wherebugsgo wrote:
I don't have PM ability, but I think I understand what's going on.
Let's be...honest about it.
This is a breadcrumb. I have one of the pieces of honesty.
I thought you guys were getting pieces together so I wanted to help you out.
That's why I wanted to know more about what Jackal was doing. When I realized he was telling the truth and I reread his songpost, I figured he can't be mafia with tnkted.
Then, I voted nisani because he was my number 2 lynch target. I've been pushing tnkted and nisani all day, if I get a town read on tnkted of course I'm going to go back and push my second lynch after clarifying that the claim indeed is made from a pro town perspective.
|
On September 18 2011 05:12 wherebugsgo wrote:Jesus Christ you guys are fucking slow. Show nested quote +On September 17 2011 14:38 wherebugsgo wrote:
I don't have PM ability, but I think I understand what's going on.
Let's be...honest about it. This is a breadcrumb. I have one of the pieces of honesty. I thought you guys were getting pieces together so I wanted to help you out.
That´s what I thought it was, but you haven´t used Honesty as a word earlier, so I wasn´t sure.
WBG, I have the other piece of Honesty. What shall we do about it?
|
|
|
we could both give them to Jackal.
I'm really not sure though. There's still the remote chance Jackal is mafia and is lying to save tnkted, but I thnk it's worth the risk.
|
United States1359 Posts
*facepalm*
WBG is almost certainly town at this point. You should either pass that shit along or keep it, but don't tell anyone what you do. It doesn't look like we have any vigs or I'd be dead, and mafia only has one kill.
|
There hasn´t been enough info about the elements before this, which makes me think the original claim from Jackal and tnkted are true.
I´m okay with sending both to Jackal to confirm him and ourselves.
|
Man I just keep getting homework and have to go places to do things with my family. so I've just asked for a replacement as I just can't play this and do it as well. sorry about me just not being there and helping (and god am I bad at analysis but if my guesses are somehow right I will laugh.)
|
WBG, if you can accept my early breadcrumb about the element, then send it to me, otherwise we´ll solve this some other way.
|
alright, I'll figure out what to do with the piece. If we have a medic they need to prot Jackal tonight.
|
Forum, what is your pick for a good lynch target today, if we are to assume that you, WBG, tntked, and jackal are all town for the moment.
|
omfg
wtf is going on
##Unvote, under the condition that Forumite gets the piece of honesty.
|
Lynch nisani, this guy is definitely our best lynch today.
|
|
|
|
|
|
EPT
