EPTDisregarding the nightkill for a while, I think Chaos13 is scummy for his craplogical push on Jackal, reasoning in my analysis post above.
Cosmic Horror Mafia - Page 29
| Forum Index > TL Mafia |
|
Forumite
Sweden3280 Posts
Disregarding the nightkill for a while, I think Chaos13 is scummy for his craplogical push on Jackal, reasoning in my analysis post above. | ||
|
chaos13
Canada885 Posts
On August 31 2011 00:02 Forumite wrote: This is why we post analysis at the end of the night, to avoid becoming a target for the Scum, and creating WIFOM. Disregarding the nightkill for a while, I think Chaos13 is scummy for his craplogical push on Jackal, reasoning in my analysis post above. Explain to me what about my argument for him being EA is wrong or illogical, and give me a better idea of who it could be. I'm always open to discussion. With that in mind, you guys think I'm scummy. So pressure me. I'll answer to the best of my ability and if you still feel I'm anti-town after that, then I can relax knowing that at least I provided a bunch of information before being lynched and that I played the game as well as I can. | ||
|
Jackal58
United States4264 Posts
If I were scum Chaos you would be dead today and not the Ferryman. So unless you are either A) The EA or B) Scum please kindly start looking for realsies instead of insisting I am something I'm not. Of course if you are either scum or EA please continue to tunnel me. | ||
|
Cyber_Cheese
Australia3615 Posts
On August 30 2011 10:33 Cyber_Cheese wrote: I'm thinking we should ##Visit Chaos13 because of these two posts That's the whole point, it's like extra details we can help turn into a case against him Why can't any role go through and try to figure out who's who? ##Vote Chaos13 | ||
|
TheFerryman
United States39 Posts
+ Show Spoiler + nail the bastards for me! | ||
|
tnkted
United States1359 Posts
Did we all abandon the wiggles lynch? | ||
|
chaos13
Canada885 Posts
On August 31 2011 01:33 Jackal58 wrote: If I were EA Chaos The Ferryman would not have been sane. I considered him to be high on the list of probable Psychs. Were I EA he would have been my night one visit. If I were scum Chaos you would be dead today and not the Ferryman. So unless you are either A) The EA or B) Scum please kindly start looking for realsies instead of insisting I am something I'm not. Of course if you are either scum or EA please continue to tunnel me. This is total wifom here. It would be so easy for you to say this from an EA or mafia perspective, so it doesn't go any length to convincing me you're town. With that said, I seem to be the only one suspicious of you, so pursuing you will do no good for today. On August 31 2011 01:38 Cyber_Cheese wrote: ##Vote Chaos13 You're doing an excellent job of voting for me with no explanation and completely ignoring my request to pressure me if you think I'm suspicious. If you want to vote for me, don't leave the information where it's at. Ask me questions and see if my responses are still scummy. Point out the mafia/EA objectives I have been pushing this game. If at the end of the day I'm still your #1 suspect, so be it. Don't do a one-liner vote. On August 31 2011 03:19 tnkted wrote: I'm not sold on a chaos lynch yet... he seems more like, dumb than someone posting scum objectives. Jackal clearly isn't EA or we'd have lost our psychologist. Did we all abandon the wiggles lynch? Thanks :p I'm doing my best here. I'd like to find out from everyone why they think Jackal isn't the EA, because from my perspective he is the most likely candidate for it right now. Maybe some outside opinions will help me figure things out. | ||
|
Jackal58
United States4264 Posts
On August 31 2011 03:19 tnkted wrote: I'm not sold on a chaos lynch yet... he seems more like, dumb than someone posting scum objectives. Jackal clearly isn't EA or we'd have lost our psychologist. Did we all abandon the wiggles lynch? Unless you are either the EA or the Psychologist you cannot make that claim. No matter how true it is you possess no knowledge of who the Psychologist visited unless you are him. The other option is you are the EA. | ||
|
Cyber_Cheese
Australia3615 Posts
On August 31 2011 03:25 chaos13 wrote: You're doing an excellent job of voting for me with no explanation and completely ignoring my request to pressure me if you think I'm suspicious. If you want to vote for me, don't leave the information where it's at. Ask me questions and see if my responses are still scummy. Point out the mafia/EA objectives I have been pushing this game. If at the end of the day I'm still your #1 suspect, so be it. Don't do a one-liner vote. Take a second look at who I quoted | ||
|
Jackal58
United States4264 Posts
On August 31 2011 03:25 chaos13 wrote: This is total wifom here. It would be so easy for you to say this from an EA or mafia perspective, so it doesn't go any length to convincing me you're town. With that said, I seem to be the only one suspicious of you, so pursuing you will do no good for today. You're doing an excellent job of voting for me with no explanation and completely ignoring my request to pressure me if you think I'm suspicious. If you want to vote for me, don't leave the information where it's at. Ask me questions and see if my responses are still scummy. Point out the mafia/EA objectives I have been pushing this game. If at the end of the day I'm still your #1 suspect, so be it. Don't do a one-liner vote. Thanks :p I'm doing my best here. I'd like to find out from everyone why they think Jackal isn't the EA, because from my perspective he is the most likely candidate for it right now. Maybe some outside opinions will help me figure things out. Your only reason for calling me the EA is because I spent Sunday morning looking for breadcrumbs. I spent Sunday morning looking for breadcrumbs because I was sitting next to my phone waiting for my kid to call me. Let it go man. There are several other peoples in this game that have shown more interest in the Psych and the EA than I have. We also have 2 people that hardly post at all. Look at them first. | ||
|
chaos13
Canada885 Posts
I saw that. I also saw zero explanation of why you think I'm anti-town. | ||
|
Mr. Wiggles
Canada5894 Posts
I'm wondering if you actually have anything stronger than just that he found the breadcrumb. Also, try to write it from an objective stand-point, and not one where you begin with the thought that he's already the EA. Number of insane players: 1-3/10 | ||
|
chaos13
Canada885 Posts
On August 31 2011 03:59 Mr. Wiggles wrote: Chaos, do you have any other analysis/reasoning to believe that Jackal is the EA besides that he found the breadcrumb? Can you relate his thread behaviour and posting in general to how he is the EA? I'm wondering if you actually have anything stronger than just that he found the breadcrumb. Also, try to write it from an objective stand-point, and not one where you begin with the thought that he's already the EA. Number of insane players: 1-3/10 Yes, I'll actually write a proper analysis later this afternoon that covers everything. I have to head out the door in a minute or two, so I don't have time to do it right now. # of insane players could actually be 0, if psych and EA visited the same person each night. EA's action goes through first, meaning the player is already insane once the pysch visits them, so they're cured of their insanity the same night it happens. | ||
|
tnkted
United States1359 Posts
On August 31 2011 03:29 Jackal58 wrote: Unless you are either the EA or the Psychologist you cannot make that claim. No matter how true it is you possess no knowledge of who the Psychologist visited unless you are him. The other option is you are the EA. I think I can make that claim assuming that the psychologist is following orders and visiting the person we voted for. We all voted for you, so we can assume that psych visited you and didn't die. That's what im basing that claim on. Why, are you the EA? | ||
|
Mr. Wiggles
Canada5894 Posts
On August 31 2011 04:22 chaos13 wrote: Yes, I'll actually write a proper analysis later this afternoon that covers everything. I have to head out the door in a minute or two, so I don't have time to do it right now. # of insane players could actually be 0, if psych and EA visited the same person each night. EA's action goes through first, meaning the player is already insane once the pysch visits them, so they're cured of their insanity the same night it happens. I know that, but EA counts as insane, so the minimum is 1. | ||
|
Jackal58
United States4264 Posts
On August 31 2011 04:26 tnkted wrote: I think I can make that claim assuming that the psychologist is following orders and visiting the person we voted for. We all voted for you, so we can assume that psych visited you and didn't die. That's what im basing that claim on. Why, are you the EA? Nope. EA is going to be Eiii or Erandorr. | ||
|
Erandorr
2283 Posts
 | ||
|
Erandorr
2283 Posts
I am ultra super busy right now but i think i will be able to participate when my internship is done tomorrow | ||
|
Forumite
Sweden3280 Posts
Chaos13, you haven´t seen/answered the FoS I sent on you, it went out just before the new day, and regards the same thing Cyber pointed out. Basically, it´s that you didn´t want to send the Psych on Jackal, who you think is the EA. You argued that it´s a waste to send the Psych to die, it might look that way, but it´s craplogic. If we get the EA because the Psych die finding him, then we can be much more sure on the lynch. Also, if we send the Psych and he doesn´t die, then we can be more or less sure that Jackal is not the EA. That´s the thing that looked bad, it looked like you wanted to make sure that Jackal was not cleared of EA-suspicion, so that you could lynch him today. Anyway, I´m looking forward to that analysis on Jackal. I want to hear what made you so sure about Jackal that you thought a Psych verification was unnecessary. | ||
|
Jackal58
United States4264 Posts
| ||
| ||
