BC is the mayor (literally this is a power role) and he drove the kill BM train all day long until he decided to get off it and hop the sandroba train late in the day.

p4NDemik

United States13896 Posts

January 22 2012 03:05 GMT

#3416

rip protact. you were invaluable for town and I'm assuming you made some great checks in addition to solid reads.

scamp I hardly knew yeh.

GGQ is a weird lynch. I thought he was suspicious enough to keep around.

Now, our elected officials need to go. It is looking more and more like one or both of them is mafia.

p4NDemik

United States13896 Posts

January 22 2012 03:10 GMT

#3419

Lots of people need to die because of sandroba's flip toadesstern but you need to put BC at the top of your list.

p4NDemik

United States13896 Posts

January 22 2012 03:17 GMT

#3422

Why do you want to lynch a lurker who has had no real case made against him? What about my case against BC is lacking enough that we should give him more time? Why don't you want BM dead either?

And mafia choses their masons this was something that was discussed ad nauseam earlier in the game on day 1.

p4NDemik

United States13896 Posts

January 22 2012 03:38 GMT

#3427

Logs have been faked over and over and over again from what I understand in this history of mafia. To not want to lynch someone because you don't think logs are faked is a mistake and poor logic to boot.

p4NDemik

United States13896 Posts

January 22 2012 03:54 GMT

#3435

On January 22 2012 12:48 BloodyC0bbler wrote:
Ok people. You can jump up and down and yell at me all you want however. BM DIES NOW.

You guys can all say "but BC we don't trust you" Yea so let me ask you this. Why are we not following the advice of the dead town DT who snagged near every red thus far this game?

BM drops. If he somehow flips town im fucked and dead after.

If anyone was jailed last night, claim it. If anyone took a hit same shit, if you were rb'd again.

Anyone who was mason'd to scamp should be coming forward as well.

The mafia are running with their tails in their legs trying to keep bm alive right now, DO NOT LET IT HAPPEN.

Who are you insinuating is mafia then?

p4NDemik

United States13896 Posts

January 22 2012 03:59 GMT

#3440

Who is trying to keep BM alive? Last I saw it was you, proact (may he rest in peace), and foolishness who worked so hard for him to live just one more day yesterday.

p4NDemik

United States13896 Posts

January 22 2012 04:01 GMT

#3441

Toadesstern he was also wrong on Jackal.

p4NDemik

United States13896 Posts

January 22 2012 04:10 GMT

#3446

On January 22 2012 13:06 BloodyC0bbler wrote:

Show nested quote +

except jackal admits to purposely derping to make sure he got to shoot. He has been his typical self since then for the most part. With his play he should have known that would happen. He was wrong on Kingjames like I was who was arguably the unofficial mafia of the game as the guy was clearly behaving as a mafia would.

Seriously, no one should be hesitating to lynch BM at the moment.

What point are you trying to make? He called his shot right as the clock struck midnight. He is town. What does anything before or after that moment in time have to do with his alignment? He is like 99.9% town. He shot and killed one of the best mafia players on TL.

p4NDemik

United States13896 Posts

January 22 2012 04:11 GMT

#3449

The only reason Protact made that mistake was that he was composing his list while Jackal was calling his shot. Protact posted that list four minutes after Jackal called his shot.

p4NDemik

United States13896 Posts

January 22 2012 04:12 GMT

#3450

He has no reason to defend Protact putting you on his list. It wouldn't have happened if you guys hadn't coincidentally posted in the same 5 minute window.

p4NDemik

United States13896 Posts

January 22 2012 04:13 GMT

#3452

He's just trying to make his agenda (Proact's old lists) seem more viable and he isn't using any sound logic while he's at it.

p4NDemik

United States13896 Posts

January 22 2012 04:14 GMT

#3453

Moreover he's more defending his previous attacks on you than he is attacking Protact's putting on your list.

p4NDemik

United States13896 Posts

January 22 2012 04:15 GMT

#3456

On January 22 2012 13:14 p4NDemik wrote:
Moreover he's more defending his previous attacks on you than he is attacking Protact's putting on your list.

"than he is defending Protact's putting you on his list"

editing post above me i dk what your acronym is blah blah

p4NDemik

United States13896 Posts

January 22 2012 04:17 GMT

#3458

On January 22 2012 13:14 BloodyC0bbler wrote:

Show nested quote +

As you are trying to discredit the dead man, I would say there is a valid reason.

wtf I'm not discrediting him I just gave a very clean and very logical reason why Jackal was still on his list at that point in time. He was busy composing that list at nearly the same time Jackal called his hit. If he would have read and realized he wouldn't have put Jackal on his list. I have nothing against Protact here I was posting a simple clarification to toad's mistake and explaining why Protact made that mistake. In a roundabout way I was sort of helping you by explaining away one of Protact's mistakes.

But yet you are on my ass ... wonder why.

p4NDemik

United States13896 Posts

January 22 2012 04:19 GMT

#3460

Jackal the important thing is why is BC attacking me just now I actually just helped him a bit.

p4NDemik

United States13896 Posts

January 22 2012 04:20 GMT

#3462

BC u mad bro? Can't hide your inner mafia emotions that even when I help you in a roundabout way you still attack me?

p4NDemik

United States13896 Posts

January 22 2012 04:33 GMT

#3472

On January 22 2012 13:22 Jackal58 wrote:

Show nested quote +

Because he gets a tad arrogant?

Fair enough if you want to read it that way but that's not how I see it. I feel like I've done enough and I've presented myself in such a way that I am playing very much with town's interestes in mind. I have been very active and very town. He's been careful not to push very hard that I am mafia up until this point in time because I have been very pro-town and a case against me would be very difficult to make.

Now. He presents Protact's agenda on top of his casket and tells us to follow our brave leader despite him being dead and not being able to give us actual guidance. He does this to rally support behind an initiative that isn't mine and that wouldn't spell his demise obviously. Now, what I did was clarify a small mistake in Toadesstern's analysis of Protact's list. But I quickly followed that up with the point that the fact you were on that list is not Protact's fault and should not take away from the merit of the list. I did not detract from the merit of Protact's list. All I did was clarify a small error.

But BC is mad and hinting I'm mafia. Which is absurd. I think we saw a brief moment of BC's real emotions slipping out folks.

p4NDemik

United States13896 Posts

January 22 2012 04:46 GMT

#3477

@ BC: Ok you didn't say I was mafia. I was reading into "I would say there is a valid reason" the wrong way. Whatever, my mistake disregard that stuff about you letting emotions slip. The point still remains, why are you defending his putting Jackal on the list the way you did. I thought my way was the most logical way to defend it. You are defending yourself as well as Protact.

Now. We have this.

On January 22 2012 13:04 BloodyC0bbler wrote:

Show nested quote +

To save the dt who is now dead? That same dt who's near final words were kill bm -_-

Do you seriously think hes town? Honestly? Can you sit in your chair with a straight face and say "bm is town"?

Bm has performed badly and three people were duped by a claim.

You weren't duped at all. You never believed him. You were doing this to make you look like you were these good town trying to save our savior Mr. Protactinium. Then you murdered Protact in the night and went back to attacking BM. Don't make it look like you were ever fooled. I think you're a better player than that. Yesterday you even made a point that you guys didn't truly believe him, you just "didn't want to take the risk." Again, you are trying to gain brownie points by "saving" protact before you murder him.

And don't get me wrong I still want to lynch BM I think he is likely red. Even if he is Mad Hatter he doesn't do town any good if he lives very much longer. If he is town-aligned his ability to take town some mafia is more valuable than his ability to jail dudes at night provided he has time to get good reads and doesn't suck (but then again he kinda sucks so =/).

p4NDemik

United States13896 Posts

January 22 2012 04:59 GMT

#3486

On January 22 2012 13:53 BloodyC0bbler wrote:

Show nested quote +

so that means that 3 people who first unvoted are all either red or horribad right? Since it was done based on his claim and all.

It means you weren't duped but you said you were which is a lie and even worse something you are using to defend your agenda. Why would you admit that you are horrible town when you are trying to push your agenda? Because you are mafia, not horrible town.