Sigh. Pretty sure we've been duped by GMarshal, Palmar. It's either him or Cthsazsa, who is a zombie.

Based off of redFF's role, GMarshal could have gotten 25% lucky and falsified a Miller claim, knowing it was his best way to take the heat off. It's a stretch, but it's definitely possible.

Karshe

United States212 Posts

June 16 2011 21:14 GMT

#3468

##Fistpound: Palmar

Karshe

United States212 Posts

June 16 2011 21:37 GMT

#3483

I guess I forgot about Steff since he has been "confirmed" town for a day or so, hrm.

Palmar, what reasons do you have for trusting Cthsazsa? I will not volunteer myself to be shot because I am town and it's the wrong choice... but our list of suspects is dwindling.

Karshe

United States212 Posts

June 16 2011 21:57 GMT

#3487

On June 17 2011 06:45 Palmar wrote:

Show nested quote +

He created Wiggles's role.

Sorry, I don't really see where you're going with this.

On June 17 2011 06:41 Cthsazsa wrote:
Ninja'd.

##Fistbump Palmar

Karshe what reasons do have to not trust me? I swear it almost seems like you're not even reading the thread. You hardly post anything and when you do post it contains nothing valuable to town.

I'm not ruling out GM as a possibility but I'm more towards steff or Karshe as the remaining scum. Both have been lurking considerably and hardly helping Town at all, whereas GM is actually contributing.

Number of posts =/= alignment, as I'm sure you realize. Just because I haven't been posting page long PBP's every day and because GM has been more active than me doesn't mean I'm scum and GMarshal is town.

Speaking of posting habits, going back through the last 10 pages, Steff's posting has become much more scarce ever since he has been "confirmed" town. I am very curious to see what his role provided last night. I'm guessing it's going to be something we already knew.

Karshe

United States212 Posts

June 16 2011 22:33 GMT

#3500

Cthsazsa already role claimed in full at some point... he gets to kill someone the following night of his death, doesn't matter how he dies.

Karshe

United States212 Posts

June 16 2011 22:35 GMT

#3503

Sorry Cthsazsa.

I was going to have different cats do different things, i.e. a tracker cat, a cat that can absorb a hit for you, etc, but I thought it would be too much and rejected by host. This, of course, was before I saw some of the other roles. I'll definitely be more creative in a similar game type in the future.

Karshe

United States212 Posts

June 16 2011 22:40 GMT

#3504

I guess you're right, Cthsazsa. It's different than how I submitted it:

You are the Crazy Cat Lady.

You love your cats so much that not even death can keep you apart! You must be so happy. If you are ever slain during the game, the following night of your death your ghost comes back to collect your "children" to take to the after life. Oh, and while you're back, you get to kill any single person of your choosing. This ability goes through all protection--no one can withstand the wrath of the Crazy Cat Lady.

Karshe

United States212 Posts

June 16 2011 22:43 GMT

#3506

Anyway, back on topic... it's pretty hard to argue against GMarshal's role. I don't see anything obvious that could go wrong with it.

I would just suggest lynching Steff before me, since I know I am town and I'm unsure about Steff.

Karshe

United States212 Posts

June 16 2011 22:44 GMT

#3507

On June 17 2011 07:43 Karshe wrote:
Anyway, back on topic... it's pretty hard to argue against GMarshal's role. I don't see anything obvious that could go wrong with it.

I would just suggest lynching Steff before me, since I know I am town and I'm unsure about Steff.

Sorry, EBWOP:

Anyway, back on topic... it's pretty hard to argue against GMarshal's plan.

Karshe

United States212 Posts

June 16 2011 23:38 GMT

#3517

Kill Steff first, I'm not mafia and at this point I doubt GM is either. If nothing else it will get our game to end quicker. You can shoot me tonight if you'd like. I know I'm going back on what I said earlier today (about not volunteering to get shot), but at this point I'm hoping we're pretty much in the clear.

Karshe

United States212 Posts

June 17 2011 15:27 GMT

#3529

Why GM over Steff? In case GM has extra knives or something?

Karshe

United States212 Posts

June 17 2011 17:27 GMT

#3533

What does that mean, Palmar... what are you wanting to do?

Karshe

United States212 Posts

June 17 2011 22:31 GMT

#3564

I still believe Steff is scummier than GM and think Steff should be lynched...

Karshe

United States212 Posts

June 18 2011 16:30 GMT

#3570

Sorry GM...

Karshe

United States212 Posts

June 18 2011 18:06 GMT

#3574

How is Cthsazsa killing me if you're shooting Steff?

Karshe

United States212 Posts

June 18 2011 18:16 GMT

#3577

I am voting with Palmar because he is our only CONFIRMED 100% town and he is also our Vig.

You're grasping at straws GM, Cthsazsa does not have a "shot." His role that *I* wrote specifically says it goes through all forms of protection.

That said, I am still fine with switching over to Steff because I think he is most likely to be mafia. But decide quick, I'm leaving the house in 10 minutes.

Karshe

United States212 Posts

June 18 2011 18:24 GMT

#3579

Cthsazsa couldn't be a SK, right?

The only thing I found odd was the night he chose GMarshal, before Cthsazsa was even dead. And there were two nights in a row where Amber protected GM.

Karshe

United States212 Posts

June 18 2011 18:27 GMT

#3580

I'm headed out the door, and switching back over to Steff.

If you can convince one other person to switch over too, GM, well done.