EPTPick Their Power Mafia - Page 4
| Forum Index > TL Mafia |
|
Karshe
United States212 Posts
| ||
|
Karshe
United States212 Posts
| ||
|
Karshe
United States212 Posts
Here is what I posted in regards to the lists: On June 09 2011 06:47 Karshe wrote: I would also recommend Hiro at this point since he is on both lists. It would seem to make sense... Hiro is the single mafia on Day 1 list, and Hiro and Bum are the two mafia on Day 2 list. TDL would be the missing mafia. | ||
|
Karshe
United States212 Posts
Bumatlarge Hiro protagonist Mr.Wiggles Torte de Lini Varpulis the mole | ||
|
Karshe
United States212 Posts
| ||
|
Karshe
United States212 Posts
On June 09 2011 07:16 redFF wrote: Why inspect Hiro? If he comes back Scum Barundar is town Everyone else on Palmar's vote list is confirmed not scum (Kurumi still black obviously) If he come back Town Barundar is Mafia 1 of Gm, Jackal, Cthasza, Karshe is Scum (likely Gm or Jackal) This seems really spot on. I believe Cthsazsa to be town as well. Based off his posting, and I gave him his role. The fact that he hasn't claimed any part of it yet makes me feel he is pro-town. I want to trust GM, but after the whole Palmar thing which he himself admitted he pretty much spear-headed... I'm not as sure. | ||
|
Karshe
United States212 Posts
On June 09 2011 08:06 hiro protagonist wrote: This needs to be talked about more. We can not leave it to chance that bum will die. I think we should lynch him NOW. He should have been the last lynch. towns got plenty of KP that can be put on people likely to die from it. we got Palmar. Letws Lynch Bum Scum damage control? Trying to only lose one buddy instead of two? | ||
|
Karshe
United States212 Posts
| ||
|
Karshe
United States212 Posts
| ||
|
Karshe
United States212 Posts
| ||
|
Karshe
United States212 Posts
I think we need to check, or preferably kill, hiro protagonist. He is on both voting lists from Day 1/2... and regardless, his posting the last day or so has been pretty scummy. Why is bum's role redacted in the night post? I was curious to see if he was as overpowered as batman. | ||
|
Karshe
United States212 Posts
On June 09 2011 06:34 Eternalmisfit wrote: Palmar bumatlarge Eternalmisfit Kurumi Jackal58 Karshe GMarshal Amber[LighT] Cthsazsa Rean hiro protagonist Day2 vote: 2/10 are scum VisceraEyes Eternalmisfit Barundar hiro protagonist Kurumi Day1 vote: 1/4 are scum Based off of VisceraEyes' vote list, we now know Barundar is mafia. ##Vote: Barundar Palmar's vote list has some more investigating needed, obviously. I'm most weary of GM at the moment (not including Barundar). Hopefully our dog will have some more info for us? | ||
|
Karshe
United States212 Posts
On June 11 2011 07:33 Rean wrote: Palmar lynch bumatlarge Eternalmisfit Kurumi Jackal58 Karshe GMarshal Amber[LighT] Cthsazsa Rean Yes, I inspected Jackal, I just said i'd inspect Amber to avoid possible framer shenanigans. He returned black on the inspect. Barundar is also the only one on the visceraeyes lynch left unaccounted for, making him mafia. ##Vote: Barundar This makes me even more uneasy of GMarshal, since Cthsazsa, Amber, and myself have all been considered pro-town for most of the game. | ||
|
Karshe
United States212 Posts
| ||
|
Karshe
United States212 Posts
On June 11 2011 07:55 Jackal58 wrote: Makes me uneasy of Rean. We either have a framer role or he's scum. I couldn't remember why Rean's name was in confirmed green, but didn't want to question it and make it look like I was trying to discredit a DT... | ||
|
Karshe
United States212 Posts
 | ||
|
Karshe
United States212 Posts
So we either need to lynch Barundar, or figure out who his accomplice is. | ||
|
Karshe
United States212 Posts
Unfortunately you've targeted the wrong person because I am town. I'm not going to do a quote by quote response, but I will respond to your main concerns. GMarshal Why am I becoming increasingly suspicious of him? Because everything I've heard about this guy is that he's a great player and a huge asset to town. I wouldn't say he hasn't been helping town, but he hasn't been an overly active poster, either. And certainly not a town leader. There is, of course, the whole Palmar lynch in which he totally convinced me to switch from Bum to Palmar. He himself stated that he essentially spear-headed the Palmar lynch. Granted, I ultimately take responsibility for switching my own vote... but I switched because what GMarshal was saying made sense. He is very persuasive. You also seem to think that because GM got roleblocked by Torte that this clears GM. I disagree. GM does not have an overpowered role. Given GM's knowledge of the game, I would not put it past him to intentionally get himself roleblocked to have an alibi later in the game. Bombing Mataza I have played two games with Mataza now and in both games I felt he was very hard to read. His playstyle is so erratic and at times hard to follow that even if he IS town, he is still causing confusion and attention with drastic "pro-town" planning. I stand by my decision to bomb him, when I sent in my night action I was confident he was mafia. Hiro's death To be honest, I'm still surprised Hiro was not mafia. At the time of discussing who should be next to die, I didn't bother doing a mass quote of Hiro's posts because it just seemed like an easy piece of the puzzle that fit in given the lists we had. Clearly this was a mistake. Ultimately, Hiro's failure to really defend himself is why I was confident in my choice. He basically said, "lol, well I'm town, so let's figure out who else is actually mafia." And that was it. It felt like he had given up, as Torte had done before him. This point of yours doesn't make sense: On June 11 2011 15:34 Cthsazsa wrote: Of course, you would preferably kill Hiro. This dude's an easy target and doesn't even defend himself. Because at the time I suggested killing Hiro, Hiro hadn't gotten the chance to "be an easy target" or defend himself yet. Are you suggesting I am psychic and knew Hiro would give up? Lynching Jackal since he has a vest (we're assuming), and having Palmar shoot Barundar seems to make the most sense. This will give us an extra day to rip apart each other's posts and if we're some how lucky, give Rean another day to work his magic. I can not agree to be shot or lynched for town information because I know I am town. So, if it's a situation like, "killing Karshe will clear the dog," as you suggest... I could not agree to that because as a townie, it makes more sense to kill the dog to clear myself. That said, according to your list, killing me will not clear Amber because you are on that list as well. | ||
|
Karshe
United States212 Posts
On June 11 2011 18:27 stefftastiq wrote: Yeah, I got some information - the crazy cat lady has chosen GMarshal I wrote Cthsazsa's role (cat lady), and the way I wrote it, he doesn't "chose" people until a certain action happens, which has not happened yet. So either he a) sent his action in advance before necessary or b) our host changed his role without telling me. If he's town, and it's some sort of tracking or KP, why wouldn't he put it on me? He seems to believe I am mafia over GMarshal. I still think we should lynch Jackal since we don't know how much night protection he has, but I'm also good with lynching the confirmed Barundar. | ||
|
Karshe
United States212 Posts
| ||
| ||
