|
On June 14 2011 06:31 GMarshal wrote:Show nested quote +On June 14 2011 06:25 Cthsazsa wrote:
Ahh, ninja'd.
I am waiting for GMarshal's case against DropBear. But he is certainly a possibility. There you go. Any other requests?
Hmm, yes.
On June 14 2011 06:18 Rean wrote:
GMarshal
Palmar
Rean
DropBear
stefftastiq
Amber[LighT]
This is the last list of people that voted for the Jackal lynch. It has 2 mafia on it. For me, it's between DropBear/stefftastiq/Amber[LighT]. And with Amber also being on the previous list....he seems like a much better option to me.
As Rean said, there are 2 scum on this list, DropBear most likely being one of them.
imo It's between Amber and Steff.
There are so many possibilities. Assuming that I am correct about Karshe, that would mean stefftastiq is the 2nd scum.
Assuming I am wrong and Karshe is Town, it's either Amber or You.
If you're the missing scum on Palmar's list then it is between Amber and Steff.
Or there could be 3 Mafia left, Karshe/Steff/DropBear/Amber.
Who do you think is the 2nd scum on last night's vote list?
|
|
|
United States22154 Posts
On June 14 2011 06:52 Cthsazsa wrote:Show nested quote +On June 14 2011 06:31 GMarshal wrote:On June 14 2011 06:25 Cthsazsa wrote:
Ahh, ninja'd.
I am waiting for GMarshal's case against DropBear. But he is certainly a possibility. There you go. Any other requests? Hmm, yes. Show nested quote +On June 14 2011 06:18 Rean wrote:
GMarshal
Palmar
Rean
DropBear
stefftastiq
Amber[LighT]
This is the last list of people that voted for the Jackal lynch. It has 2 mafia on it. For me, it's between DropBear/stefftastiq/Amber[LighT]. And with Amber also being on the previous list....he seems like a much better option to me. As Rean said, there are 2 scum on this list, DropBear most likely being one of them. imo It's between Amber and Steff. There are so many possibilities. Assuming that I am correct about Karshe, that would mean stefftastiq is the 2nd scum. Assuming I am wrong and Karshe is Town, it's either Amber or You. If you're the missing scum on Palmar's list then it is between Amber and Steff. Or there could be 3 Mafia left, Karshe/Steff/DropBear/Amber. Who do you think is the 2nd scum on last night's vote list?
Im not 100% sure, I'd guess Amber, because his role gives next to nothing to analyze, however I need to reread the thread again and look at them before I make up my mind, I don't really suspect Karshe, steff I have no real idea of, I can't really bring to mind any significant posts by him.
Oh, btw, I know we love the lists, but if we don't want to lose theres something we need to consider. A serial killer miller already flipped, I think there might be a mafia miller as well, which means that if we get the list down to only people who are unlikely to be mafia we need to consider other possibilities.
I'm throwing that out there because otherwise this game seems dreadfully imbalanced, no?
Anyway, lynch DB and we can worry about everything else tomorrow, or tonight.
|
United States22154 Posts
Ohh, right
##Fistpound: Palmar
|
I'm betting that Rean was shot at because I don't think anyone else here has a veteran type role.
If that's true, I'm wondering why they chose to shoot Rean. Correct me if I'm wrong, but it's pretty damn obvious who has the medic-type role?
|
United States22154 Posts
On June 14 2011 07:13 Cthsazsa wrote:
I'm betting that Rean was shot at because I don't think anyone else here has a veteran type role.
If that's true, I'm wondering why they chose to shoot Rean. Correct me if I'm wrong, but it's pretty damn obvious who has the medic-type role?
True, but I think it was a gamble the mafia had to take, list checks rape scum badly.
I'm also betting that the remaining scum did not all vote for the same target, for obvious reasons.
|
On June 14 2011 07:13 Cthsazsa wrote:
I'm betting that Rean was shot at because I don't think anyone else here has a veteran type role.
If that's true, I'm wondering why they chose to shoot Rean. Correct me if I'm wrong, but it's pretty damn obvious who has the medic-type role?
As far as I am concerned I was not shot at. No messages telling me I was saved or anything. Maybe they tried taking down Palmar (lol)?
|
##Fistpound Palmar
ait, got some supadupa news as well - sorry im kinda doing nothing, busy reallife going on :-)
my info this day is that The Psychic has votechecked, and returned 2 mafia :-p useful role indeed
|
Dropbear/GM are the last 2 scum imo. GM busing DB.
|
|
|
United States22154 Posts
On June 14 2011 08:22 redFF wrote:
Dropbear/GM are the last 2 scum imo. GM busing DB.
hahahahahahaha
Post an analysis and *maybe* I'll stop laughing at you.
|
On June 14 2011 08:22 redFF wrote:
Dropbear/GM are the last 2 scum imo. GM busing DB.
Hmm I thought you said I was scum.
|
EBWOP: I just remembered that, Palmar can take extra hits right? >.>
It probably is him but he's not going to be on for a while.
|
United States22154 Posts
On June 14 2011 08:38 Cthsazsa wrote:Show nested quote +On June 14 2011 08:22 redFF wrote:
Dropbear/GM are the last 2 scum imo. GM busing DB. Hmm I thought you said I was scum.
He seems to be lashing out. I think its a response to me suggesting that there might be millers or *gasp* a godfather like role, which suddenly puts his towniness at doubt.
No worries though, if he wants to lynch me after db flips red we just have Palmar shoot him and probably win outright.
|
I didn't get shot tonight.
I like the dropbear lynch, as he can never be cleared anyway. If he flips red, that's no clearance for anyone though.
We still need more information. GMarshal, do you have a new member in your cult now? Amber, quote the person you targeted and wiggle your tail.
|
United States22154 Posts
On June 14 2011 09:46 Palmar wrote:
I didn't get shot tonight.
I like the dropbear lynch, as he can never be cleared anyway. If he flips red, that's no clearance for anyone though.
We still need more information. GMarshal, do you have a new member in your cult now? Amber, quote the person you targeted and wiggle your tail.
I inducted steff.
As far as clearing people, I really think that if we want to win we need to do analysis, rather than depending on "cleared" people, as far as I am concerned the only "clear" person is you, and thats because you flipped.
|
-_- wait are you seriously suggesting I am scum lol? It's just people are going around treating GM like a confirmed townie when he most certainly is not. He lurked like a bitch for the first few days and has come out guns blazing now that he see's scum are in a position to win and he can't survive by lurking and posting shitty shit with no substance. Lynch dropbear obviously, but then shoot GM imo.
|
Rean, you seem to really like sticking GMarshal in as townie. Do you have a valid reason for this, or is this just based on his actions/posts?
|
United States22154 Posts
On June 14 2011 09:58 redFF wrote:
-_- wait are you seriously suggesting I am scum lol? It's just people are going around treating GM like a confirmed townie when he most certainly is not. He lurked like a bitch for the first few days and has come out guns blazing now that he see's scum are in a position to win and he can't survive by lurking and posting shitty shit with no substance. Lynch dropbear obviously, but then shoot GM imo.
I don't lurk as town, I don't lurk as scum, I lurk when I have no choice, such as when I'm in the middle of exams.
And guess what? I *didn't* out two detectives, you did.
I killed TWO serial killers and told everyone bum was scum since he claimed.
How many anti-town forces have you killed lately Mr. I oust dts?
Again, come back when you have a case other than "he made a great case against DB, he must be scum!"
I was really close to rage quitting, the only reason I'm sticking with this town is because if I leave you on your own you will lose. Frankly I don't dislike anyone enough to make them struggle with this town.
Hell if you want to shoot me, feel free! Hand the mafia this game, why not? I mean I'm the only person who has analyzed this game, you might as well rely on your DTs and then cry when you discover the mafia had a godfather, or that there was a miller as part of balancing a role, or that the mafia had a framer. Damn I'm pissed right now.
People like you, who make absurd leaps of logic and then depend on detectives are why Ace had to write that guide on Cops and Vigis. If you are town start analyzing and backing up your reasoning. At this point though, I'm willing to believe you are scum, it curious how as soon as I threaten DB and question the list checks I must be scum. Its almost as if I had challenged your plan to victory...
|
Here is a player list
GMarshal
Palmar
Rean
DropBear
stefftastiq
Amber[LighT]
Karshe
Cthsazsa
redFF
We know there are at least 2 scum left. We also know that we (town) have 1 kp. We can assume that mafia has 1kp. We also know that GM has 1kp.
What else do we know?
2 people on this list are scum
GMarshal
Palmar
Rean
DropBear
stefftastiq
Amber[LighT]
9 players left, 2 scum (I would assume)
We can safely lynch and shoot into this list for the rest of the game and still not lose no? Here is how I recommend we do this.
Today-lynch Dropbear
Tonight-GM sacrifice Stefftastiq, Palmar shoot GM
Tommorow- If GM or Stefftastiq is still alive we lynch them, otherwise, if there is still 1 scum left on that list, we lynch Amber(this won't happen)
If after all that the game isn't over Palmar can shoot Cthazsa, and he can bring karshe with him.
Scum can obviously fuck this up with nightkills but there shots will likely be focused on me/karshe/rean/Cthazsa (basically people not on that vote list). Cthazsa if you die you need to keep a level head and not pull a viscera eyes and shoot into this list
Dropbear
GM
Stefftastiq
Amber
I ordered that for you aswell, shoot the highest person, if they are dead, move down the list.
If anybody has a problem with this plan I am dying to hear it, but then you will lose because all you will be is scum desperately trying to salvage a win.
|
|
|
|
|
|
EPT
