|
On May 19 2011 12:29 DropBear wrote: If a miller dies, do they flip miller or just townie?
We've had a lot of townie deaths but no millers yet
They flip miller.
|
I know who the chatic voteswitching of Jaminz saved.
##Vote: orgolove
|
I also find Jaminz voting and contributions very suspicious, I find this post that dropbear also postet shows a lot: + Show Spoiler +On May 18 2011 10:26 jaminz wrote: I've been pretty MIA thus far, as you all have undoubtedly seen. I've been reading the thread, but just barely. I'm going to vote for Impervious after looking over his post history and reading the analysis from Kita and others.
I'm not voting for ilovejonn because the only two people who are currently voting for him are people I don't really trust (orgolove and Impervious).
I'm not voting for orgolove (yet) because I think that while his posting has been very erratic, I don't really think it's possible that scum would be that wild/weird this late in the game (and with only two of them left).
I'm not voting for redtooth (yet) because while his analysis was completely wrong in the early game, I don't think he's done enough to raise my suspicion about him to the point where I'd vote for him over Impervious. If I had to rank my top suspects it'd probably look something like this:
1. Impervious 2. ilovejonn 3. redtooth 4. orgolove . . . (5). Kitaman and some others I just have weird gut feelings about He tells us why ne finds ilovejonn and orgolove are not that suspicious, like people before have done. Then he says redtooth is not as suspicious as impervious and thats why he votes for Impervious. He actually never tells us why he finds Impervious is suspicious. If he was mafia and knew that redtooth is a townie that would be modkilled, that explains why he wanted another townie to get lynched.
Also this post is the only one where he wrote anything that could be called a contribution, except for posting the remaining players at the beginning of night 5, which can be seen at page one of the thread. That is why I will vote for him for now, maybe I can pressure him into being more active in spirit of VarpuliS.
|
On May 19 2011 15:55 Forumite wrote: I know who the chatic voteswitching of Jaminz saved.
##Vote: orgolove
That's something of a WIFOM argument though. He may have switched away in order to make orgolove look scummy. Vote jaminz today and we can figure out the other one tomorrow.
|
I´ve had my eye on orgolove far longer than jaminz.
|
United States22154 Posts
Event 2: Firestorm!
![[image loading]](http://i.dailymail.co.uk/i/pix/2009/08/24/article-1208348-06290F32000005DC-903_964x443.jpg)
The town has been hit by a ravaging firestorm, hitting the majority of the houses! Some of you will be too busy putting out the fires to vote! (you must still vote, it just won't be counted) those of you whose vote will be nullified will be notified. The rest of you can choose to either take advantage of the cover of smoke to take night actions or voting, being able to you know, lynch someone. The people choosing to take advantage of the cover of smoke might be burned, or spotted by the more attentive villagers putting out the fires.
Remember even if you choose to take an action that nullifies your vote you must still vote, and the mafia needs to have two non-voters for each kill they choose to conduct.
PM me your choices!
Oh and the emperor has enacted a double lynch! This should be interesting.
+ Show Spoiler +In seriousness though, sorry for going AFK last night, shit came up, I hope it won't happen again.
|
@GM you keep posting lame excuses for the dealy on troll posts. I conclude you are Scum.
|
On May 20 2011 00:25 sandroba wrote: @GM you keep posting lame excuses for the dealy on troll posts. I conclude you are Scum. I question your scumhunting skills since you thought I was scum.
|
|
kitaman27
United States9244 Posts
Won't be around a comp for more than 2 min until about 6 tonight. I'll post my thoughts then. I'll also probably rage at the lurkers who don't post, so here is your warning :p
|
Vatican City State1650 Posts
Yet ilovejonn still lives. Go ahead - lynch me, if that'll give a 1-1 exchange I'm all for it. But I'm still 100% convinced that ilovejonn is scum.
|
On May 15 2011 12:37 orgolove wrote:Btw varpulis, if I really was red, then I would've known that sinai was a red. Given that, would I really have posted the following, right after the first fake day post? I'd be proven immediately wrong, in fact, within 5 minutes. Would I really have purposefully put in that position? Show nested quote +On May 15 2011 12:01 orgolove wrote: Fun. As I said. You will all eat your words when the game is over. Sigh. So pathetic. Show nested quote +On May 15 2011 12:03 orgolove wrote: Anyway. The post won't change anything. You just lynched a green. And the reds know it, and are probably laughing their asses off right now in their IRC or quicktopic. Read: Mafia trying wayyyyy too hard and sticking out like a sore thumb.
Voted orgolove
|
Either, or? We can´t lynch two, so we want to lynch the one that give the most information. orgolove is suspicious because of his actions, votes and analysis, while jaminz because of his lurking and voteswitching, but if these are the candidates, who is the best candidate for a lynch?
If we lynch jaminz then we don´t get any information on scum. If we lynch jaminz then we can´t KNOW if orgolove is scum, since the voteswitching could just have been a way to throw us off. If we lynch orgolove then jaminz looks suspicious still. If we lynch orgolove then jaminz or imp are probably scum, and ilj is cleared.
Because the main incriminating action of Jaminz does not connect him to others, he´s actually a worse lynch than orgolove, whose activity and actions give us much more to work with once he flips, no matter which way he flips. I´m not clearing jaminz, not at all, but right now I´m more interested in what orgolove is up to.
Also I´m a helper; On May 20 2011 03:04 orgolove wrote: Yet ilovejonn still lives. Go ahead - lynch me, if that'll give a 1-1 exchange I'm all for it. But I'm still 100% convinced that ilovejonn is scum.
Do I make sense?
|
I'm sticking with oroglove as he has been my number one lynch candidate for the past two day cycles.
|
Australia4290 Posts
On May 20 2011 07:09 AirbladeOrange wrote: I'm sticking with oroglove as he has been my number one lynch candidate for the past two day cycles. Really? I make it last 1 day.
On May 15 2011 07:24 GMarshal wrote: Vote Tally Day 4: AirbladeOrange (0)
Kenpachi
ilovejonn (4) DropBear orgolove sinani206
Varpulis Kenpachi
ilovejonn
sinani206 (7) Forumite AirbladeOrange kitaman27 Impervious chaos13
ilovejonn Varpulis Mig
orgolove (1) ilovejonn
About 4 and a half hours left in the day. Sinani206 currently leads with 7 votes, ilovejonn the runner-up with 4.
The only reference you have to orgolove is this, from Day 5:
On May 16 2011 13:00 AirbladeOrange wrote: Oroglove is my number one and redtooth is my number two.
Why orgolove AO? You continue to say absolutely nothing. I know you're quite active from when I played with you last game.
In reference to this again. You never said why you thought Mig or EM could be mafia. Why?
|
Australia4290 Posts
I'm switching to AO and I encourage others to do so. - No contribution - Massive lurking - Voted Kurumi day 1, Cthazsa day 2, EM Day 3 all townies - Doesn't feel obliged to do analysis - No reasons given for any votes
|
6/10 people have voted
jaminz - 2 orgolove - 2 AO - 1 ilovejonn - 1
This is another split lynch with multiple candidates. The last times we have had this there have been scum within the vote candidates. We need to lynch either jaminz or orgolove today. For the moment my vote stays on jaminz.
|
Would somebody care to update an analysis on orgolove showing how he is scum please?
I looked through every one of his posts in this thread and I am not getting a solid scum read on him. jaminz, on the other hand, is definitely scum.
|
kitaman27
United States9244 Posts
I've been pushing for jaminz since nearly the beginning of the game when I first suspected him so that is where my vote will be. Compared to his games in newbie mafia and XXXVIII, he has been lurking and absolutely useless. He had that weird post after the killer death and had that real sketchy hammer vote on EM on day three.
@DropBear: Guess you will have to ask mafia why I'm not dead. Scum had a long list of confirmed towns to plow through, though I have to admit I was kinda surprised it wasn't me last night rather than varp.
@jonn: Why have you quit? The game is not over yet and we still have a decent chance to win. What gives?
@elmizzt: Your posts are usually pretty brief and I have a hard time getting a read off them. Could you post analysis of why you are voting orgolove?
@Mig: You've also been pretty quiet lately. Your play is fairly consistent to what it was in XXXVIII, but I would still like to see your thoughts.
|
I just finished reading over every player's posts in this thread. DropBear has posted a ton -.-
Here are the results I have come up with:
TOWN kitaman27 Forumite Mig Xedat AirbladeOrange (ilovejonn)*
SUSPECT jaminz
UNCERTAIN orgolove elmizzt (ilovejonn)* DropBear
*ilovejonn is in brackets because I am uncertain of him, but have definite leanings towards him being town. Yes, his votes and accusations have been remarkably scummy, but the overall feel of his posts does not make me believe he is scum.
I believe jaminz is scum, and that the other scum player is amongst the 'uncertain' four.
|
|
|
|