|
This is my scum team:
GMarshal Kenpachi Serejai Robellicose
Marshal is red. He's flipflopped so many times it's ridiculous. His DT claim is rubbish. Kenpachi, Serejai and Robellicose are bandwagoning for him, while trying to stay under the radar.
I can't seem to convince anyone about Kenpachi and Marshal does have the pardon, so I'm switching to him.
|
Was dropbear the guy that claimed tracker? I forgot about this.
|
No I haven't claimed anything. Look how well all the roleclaims have gone for people so far. I think it was M0nsterchef who claimed tracker.
|
On April 15 2011 12:12 bumatlarge wrote: Was dropbear the guy that claimed tracker? I forgot about this.
No, that was the guy with a 0 in this name. umm Monsterchef claimed he tracked redFF and redFF didn't go anywhere.
|
On April 15 2011 12:10 DoctorHelvetica wrote:This isn't mafia play, it's bad town play. I wouldn't be surprised if a vig targeted Serajai and he's worth a check/track but I don't think he's scum anyway. If I did, I'd advocate lynching somebody else instead. Serajai hasn't really posted in regards to anything, his lynch won't lead to a better situation for town on the next day whereas catching a scum like GMarshal/LSB would have a pretty severe domino effect.
I was seriously kidding, but I get your point. Don't kill Serejai guys!
|
I'm just going to make a simple meta claim here: The last time I recall Coagulation being "outed" as scum by a DT check it was a situation in which it would have been even easier to call the DT a liar (insane mafia) and coagulation didn't defend himself as quickly, as well, or as emotionally as he did here.
In fact he actually just kinda let it happen in that game.
That's why I personally feel LSB is most likely scum. His "plan" revolves around coagulation being a blue to waste our vig hit. I think it's less about him trying to protect Coagulation than it is him trying to manipulate our suspicion of him in a way that hurts the town even more.
IMO wasting a lynch on an assassin and wasting a vig hit is worse than lynching a non-contributing vet and letting the assassin die.
WIFOM though, people change playstyles. Just a thought. If GMarshal flips blue, besides noting him down as never to be listened to again, I'd start to look less at the Coagulation and his little defense force. Not that this clears him by any means.
|
On April 15 2011 12:10 DropBear wrote: This is my scum team:
GMarshal Kenpachi Serejai Robellicose
Marshal is red. He's flipflopped so many times it's ridiculous. His DT claim is rubbish. Kenpachi, Serejai and Robellicose are bandwagoning for him, while trying to stay under the radar.
I can't seem to convince anyone about Kenpachi and Marshal does have the pardon, so I'm switching to him. keke
your analysis on me was terrible btw.
|
we need to take a look at wiggles if GMarsh flips scum. He seemed to make a bunch of fake analysis on him that seemed fluffy. Also M0nsterChef Monsterchef has supported Gmarsh unquestionably all game.
|
Well about monsterchef, the guy is pretty much confirmed town in my eyes.
redFF pushed him really hard and gave same good analysis calling chef a lurking scum, which seemed fairly accurate. But chef claimed tracker like a BAMF, saying redFF didn't go anywhere, making redFF either green or a non-moving red (not quite sure if that actually exists). Either way redFF didn't call him out on that. Chef completely shut down stuff coming from redFF, because in order for chef to be scum, redFF has to be as well.
Otherwise it was a monster of a gambit, and he should be applauded.
|
On April 15 2011 12:24 Kenpachi wrote: ##Unvote ##Vote GMarshal Now that I have called you out, you are bussing him. I'm pretty certain now.
|
Guys... I know I have been trolling most of the game, and I feel with the recent drama I owe my Opinion on what is currently happening in the game. Because this is my first time playing I'm sure I Don't really know what's going on, but here's my take on things.
First off, it seems like most people are just being sheep and following the advice of others without Any thoughts of their own. I know that's what I'm doing because I don't feel I understand enough to Think for my own just yet. Because of this, you veteran players need to realize that what you post Has a very large effect on players like myself. It feels like some players have personal issues with Each other and that's making it extremely hard for me to learn the gameplay. Stop the hateful Responses and personal attacks and stick to analyses and stuff please.
Secondly, it feels like most of you are doing things with no real reason. A lot of you seem so overly Eager to tunnel in on someone even without solid proof, and so I'm finding myself changing votes to React to the newest "omg he's mafia, lynch him" target quite often. Like, is there a method to Everyone's madness? I'm having trouble seeing anything other than people calling out each other Just for the hell of it. For example, I personally feel that Coag and GM are scum and I don't have an Analysis of my own for them, so I don't post one. Yet other players that don't have their own are Insistent on posting random garbage just to bandwagon. It makes it hard for me to understand things.
|
On April 15 2011 12:42 DropBear wrote:Now that I have called you out, you are bussing him. I'm pretty certain now. lol
|
DropBear i wont argue with you. you're just new.
|
On April 15 2011 12:43 Serejai wrote:Guys... I know I have been trolling most of the game, and I feel with the recent drama I owe my Opinion on what is currently happening in the game. Because this is my first time playing I'm sure I Don't really know what's going on, but here's my take on things. First off, it seems like most people are just being sheep and following the advice of others without Any thoughts of their own. I know that's what I'm doing because I don't feel I understand enough to Think for my own just yet. Because of this, you veteran players need to realize that what you post Has a very large effect on players like myself. It feels like some players have personal issues with Each other and that's making it extremely hard for me to learn the gameplay. Stop the hateful Responses and personal attacks and stick to analyses and stuff please. Secondly, it feels like most of you are doing things with no real reason. A lot of you seem so overly Eager to tunnel in on someone even without solid proof, and so I'm finding myself changing votes to React to the newest "omg he's mafia, lynch him" target quite often. Like, is there a method to Everyone's madness? I'm having trouble seeing anything other than people calling out each other Just for the hell of it. For example, I personally feel that Coag and GM are scum and I don't have an Analysis of my own for them, so I don't post one. Yet other players that don't have their own are Insistent on posting random garbage just to bandwagon. It makes it hard for me to understand things. data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/77e98/77e98be67f263e78995d632fb850d627ce97d99f" alt=""
Don't keep changing votes to react to the newest 'omg he's mafia'. Your job is to read all these accusations and figure out which ones make sense and which ones are bullshit. Sometimes you'll be right, sometimes you'll be wrong. As you get better at the game, you'll be right more often.
|
oh wow. I'm definitely voting GM now, but I'm gonna keep a close eye on what goes on until the day ends.
|
On April 15 2011 12:45 Kenpachi wrote: DropBear i wont argue with you. you're just new.
I'd like to see your argument, actually. You've just dismissed the accusation over and over. I trust DropBear more than you at this point. Let's see what you have to say for yourself.
|
On April 15 2011 12:45 Kenpachi wrote: DropBear i wont argue with you. you're just new. I might be new but I still think you're scum.
|
On April 15 2011 12:52 GGQ wrote:Show nested quote +On April 15 2011 12:45 Kenpachi wrote: DropBear i wont argue with you. you're just new. I'd like to see your argument, actually. You've just dismissed the accusation over and over. I trust DropBear more than you at this point. Let's see what you have to say for yourself. why? Didnt i post why his reasoning is flawed?
|
I have a town read on kenpachi
|
kitaman27
United States9244 Posts
If GMarshal already decided to pardon when the majority was on coag, we would have been informed, right?
|
|
|
|