Survivor Outwit, Outplay, Outlast (Experimental) - Page 13

Post a Reply

Prev 1 11 12 13 14 15 22 Next All

Mr. Wiggles

Canada5894 Posts

February 25 2011 05:19 GMT

#241

Also, are there any clues about the hidden immunity idol?

LunarDestiny

United States4177 Posts

February 25 2011 05:24 GMT

#242

On February 25 2011 14:18 Mr. Wiggles wrote:

Show nested quote +

That gets pretty WIFOM though, because following your exact reasoning, the SK could've come to the same conclusion. Kill annul, and make sure your alliance stays together. This will make sure you guys keep voting us out, and will keep the suspicion away from him.

Notice how dead players can't vote. If the SK is within our group, he just killed one of his voter.
There are two side and if SK is trying to use this method to stay alive, then at the last day of 1-1. He would have killed most of his potential voters and the other person would receive the full 3 votes from the lynched.

Mr. Wiggles

Canada5894 Posts

February 25 2011 05:36 GMT

#243

On February 25 2011 14:24 LunarDestiny wrote:

Show nested quote +

To win as the serial killer you must be on the island on the last day. You will immediately kill the only other person left on the island. It is important to vote off the serial killer before the last day.

The SK doesn't care about votes. He wants you guys to vote us while he kills you. Then your alliance will take him to the end, and he autowins if he makes it to the final two.

LunarDestiny

United States4177 Posts

February 25 2011 05:48 GMT

#244

On February 25 2011 14:36 Mr. Wiggles wrote:

Show nested quote +

The SK doesn't care about votes. He wants you guys to vote us while he kills you. Then your alliance will take him to the end, and he autowins if he makes it to the final two.

Oh, that is correct. SK don't care about the final day vote. I'll retract that.

But it still doesn't explain annul's death is because it was caused of a person in the group.
Again, if SK is not a person from the group, the best thing to do is also killing annul.

Now I do find this disturbing...
A sacrifice was neccesary. Sacrificing my closest allies, I surpassed the most high. It was my greatest battle, but also my greatest disappointment. I had allies still, but I could not overcome anything else. I was desperate.
The sacrificing and my closest allies part... do hint that SK is within the group.
However later sentences about he could not overcome anything else and desperate part do say that he was on the losing side of the lynch and pretty desperate because he might be voted off soon. If the SK is in the group, he wouldn't be desperate but scheming of some sort.

Mr. Wiggles

Canada5894 Posts

February 25 2011 05:55 GMT

#245

On February 25 2011 14:48 LunarDestiny wrote:

Show nested quote +

On February 25 2011 14:36 Mr. Wiggles wrote:

On February 25 2011 14:24 LunarDestiny wrote:

On February 25 2011 14:18 Mr. Wiggles wrote:

On February 25 2011 14:14 LunarDestiny wrote:

On February 25 2011 11:33 Mr. Wiggles wrote:
Nice vote reason coag. :p

I actually think the SK is in the annul alliance. If you think about it, they have a numbers advantage over us. It was 5-4, now if alliances stay the same it's 4-3. This keeps the number advantage, but also reduces the numbers for SK after. This makes sense if the SK believes his alliance will stay together, because it will eventually get to 2-1, and if he lives through that vote he wins.

I like this reason. If the SK is in annul's group of 5, then it will be advantages for the SK to keep the two side fairly close and eventually get to 2-1...

If the SK is in our group, why would he killing the person who is most responsible creating the group and the person who is most likely to hold the group together. Man, if SK is in our group, there are 3 other better targets.

Hmm... so you think annul dying is because the SK is in our group???
If the SK is the other 4 people. who do you think the SK will kill?
LOL, annul of course. Need to break the Pentagon or he will get lynched soon.

The SK doesn't care about votes. He wants you guys to vote us while he kills you. Then your alliance will take him to the end, and he autowins if he makes it to the final two.

Like I said, we get a problem with circular reasoning. Outside the group the SK will kill Annul. Inside the group he will realize someone outside the group would kill Annul. Same outcome.

Good catch with the clue though. It hints he might be in your group. Maybe the last part has to do with immunity though? Was there anyone in your alliance who was having lots of trouble with the immunity question and was just doing miserably? That might explain that he has allies still, but he can't overcome the immunity, because the SK can't kill the immune. So maybe he's desperate to win the immunity? Or he's desperate because he can't win the immunity and needs it so he can kill whoever he wants? Did anyone send in an answer to yesterday's challenge that was incorrect, or did they ask a lot about it and were having troubles?