Mini Mafia IV - Page 2

On January 23 2011 23:50 GGQ wrote:


What is this? Is this just bluster? Over-confidence for humour's sake? Or do you really think that your post justify's calling Pandain 100% confirmed scum?

On January 24 2011 00:10 GGQ wrote:


Answer seriously, please.

On January 24 2011 00:43 GGQ wrote:Why would you not vote for someone that you consider to be 100% scum?

On January 24 2011 01:32 chaoser wrote:
Let's all just step back for a moment. Jackal, I think you're misunderstand the events of the day. Pandain had initially voted Shockey and then switched to LSB when it seemed like "no one was defending shockey on day 1". Pandain thought he was "green" and so switched. Now, if Pandain was actually mafia, do you think he would switch? We now know that both LSB and Shockey are townies. It doesn't make sense for mafia to switch between the two, especially so late in the day. Mafia is usually content on sticking to one vote and sitting on it. If Pandain was actually mafia, he could have avoided the tie situation all together by just sitting on his vote of shockey. This makes me less suspicious of Pandain now than before.

So the thing that make me think Pandain isn't [r]red[/r]:
1) Both Shockey and LSB were green, why would mafia switch from one to the other? It makes no sense since a dead townie is still a dead townie.

At first I thought like you too, but stepping back, I noticed it was a weird thing that happened last night. What do others think? Might be wrong lol.

On January 24 2011 01:56 chaoser wrote:


There was already a guaranteed lynch though. At that point I think it was like 4 on Shockey and 1 of LSB. It was only because of Pandain's switch that caused the "tie". Which is why I'm so confused.

On January 24 2011 16:10 GGQ wrote:
##vote Jackal58

Justify yourself, please.

On January 25 2011 00:50 Barundar wrote:
Posting from airport, should be home in time for tonight. Quick thoughts:

- Since it's quite possibly lylo, dt should claim if he has found red. Another night of check won't help us if we have already lost. Also please stop us if we are about to lynch someone you have found town. Personally i doubt we have any dt's, but hey...

- It appears Gmarshal claimed to have gotten roleblocked, so we should probably not look at lynching him tonight. We have atleast 2 other reds to look into.

On January 25 2011 00:50 Barundar wrote:
Posting from airport, should be home in time for tonight. Quick thoughts:

- Since it's quite possibly lylo, dt should claim if he has found red. Another night of check won't help us if we have already lost. Also please stop us if we are about to lynch someone you have found town. Personally i doubt we have any dt's, but hey...

- It appears Gmarshal claimed to have gotten roleblocked, so we should probably not look at lynching him tonight. We have atleast 2 other reds to look into.

On January 25 2011 07:09 Pandain wrote:
I was serious on LSB too >.>. Sorry if I can't remember all of the 5 people I pressured.
And how could I have broken the tie with a vote on nemesis? If I switched to nemesis, Shockkey still would've gotten lynched.

As for my playstyle, I heavily disagree. I feel I have done well this game so far, albeit I admit whether Nemesis is mafia will determine just how well I've gone. I've been THE most active player this game, generated the most information(and how is it bad for town, getting people to talk is ALWAYS good).

Great, now if even one townie voted for me, we lose.

Jackal, if you're really serious about wanting me lynched, and not just mafia, then please respond to my coments to you. You still have really nothing that you yourself are lynching me for besides "I'm unlucky"(got one thing wrong? wtf?).

And still, I'm the only person actually trying to scum hunt. I'm the only person pressuring people.

How am I mafia?

On January 25 2011 07:21 Pandain wrote:
hai jackal u just posted in the other mafia game -.-
sup?

On January 25 2011 07:50 Pandain wrote:


Let's see:
http://www.teamliquid.net/forum/viewmessage.php?topic_id=184673&currentpage=9#162-say shockkey is town
http://www.teamliquid.net/forum/viewmessage.php?topic_id=184673&currentpage=9#174
I THINK lsb is mafia

http://www.teamliquid.net/forum/viewmessage.php?topic_id=184673&currentpage=8#145
That is the only post in which I voted shockkey, and note how I said I don't think he's mafia, but didn't have anyone else to vote for. Later on I thought LSB was our best bet, so I tried for him.

As for BC, originally I thought he was scummy(and keep in mind when I say that I mean keeping in mind that its day1), but then when he was like "you guys have to learN" instead of the typical"I'm busy", that made me think he's town.

Are you really voting me because I was wrong on day1? Because I got ONE person wrong on day 1?

On January 22 2011 12:59 Pandain wrote:
Fadoodle
##Unvote LSB
##Vote Shockkey

On January 25 2011 08:21 Pandain wrote:
1. Jackal58-What he says doesn't make alot of sense. He could just be really confused, but for instance saying I thought Shockkey was town. So either he is just not understanding everything, or is mafia.

On January 22 2011 02:08 Pandain wrote:
Finally, I've decided that I don't think Shockkey is scum. He's playing his norm, in fact, even has contributed more with a semi analysis of Nemesis. I think Hesmyrr is a far better person to vote considering he has barely talked at all.

On January 25 2011 09:28 Pandain wrote:
Except again, I would rather lynch a person who wouldn't contribute THAT much anyway, than not lynch at all. And how am I encouraging a tie breaker? By trying to save Shockkey, who later turned green?

Finally, I thought BC was green. So I didn't want him lynched anyway.

What your doing right now is analyzing me in the MINDSET that I'm mafia, rather than in the mindset of "I'll find out." My actions make just as much sense when you put them in the perspective of "Pandain is town."

Finally, that was my vote, since no one else was changing. Since they didn't make a choice, I had to. And it was better to lynch an inactive, then not lynch at all.

On January 25 2011 09:32 Pandain wrote:
That's actually an honest mistake. You can tell by looking at the post above, which says "This is where I say Shockkey is town". You however said I was unlucky with Shockkey because I thought he was red.

On January 25 2011 09:32 Pandain wrote:


How about you actually answer the content rather than say "If you do that your an idiot".

I don't deny I'm an idiot, but at least show me the way.

And what do you mean "day 1 rush to lynch"
Furthormore, how many times do I have to say that the day 1 analysis was mostly forced up until I offered Nemesis as a viable lynched, because I was just generating discussion.

On January 22 2011 12:59 Pandain wrote:
Fadoodle
##Unvote LSB
##Vote Shockkey

On January 25 2011 10:24 Barundar wrote:
##vote nemesis

Im going to go with my gut. Where the hell is ggq?

On January 25 2011 10:31 Pandain wrote:
Yeah, so at the very least what do we find out:
Keeping in mind its day 1, meaning I'm only 60-75% sure he's town, meaning theres still a chance he's mafia. And at the very least a useless townie.
Keeping in mind that if BC, who i thought was green, died, then it would be as if we started off a townie down, and mafia got a free hit.

Keeping in mind that its better at the very least to lynch than not lynch, when a modkill won't gurantee us any information...

I don't see why you're so insistent on believing I'm mafia. Either your scum or tunneling, and need to think.