TL Mafia XXXV

On December 27 2010 10:41 GGQ wrote:
Pretending to be mafia to make it seem like you couldnt possibly be mafia is actually kind of scummy. Town shouldn't be trying to play tricks on town like that, it may be kind of funny but it's not helpful.

On December 27 2010 11:11 LSB wrote:

Plan
Firstly. DO NOT CLAIM
DO NOT CLAIM

What does this mean? I'm being serious now, first time playing online mafia

On December 27 2010 11:14 Coagulation wrote:
EDIT MODKILL PLZ

On December 27 2010 11:19 Coagulation wrote:
generally anyone trying to get you to claim your role through pm's is a mafia trying to fish for information.

its best to keep all town roles a secret untill a DT can start a town confirmed pm circle.
then and only then should you reveal your role to anyone.

On December 27 2010 11:43 LSB wrote:
TheMango, just a question, why is it that when I try stalking you some of you posts don't show up in your post history?

On December 28 2010 10:15 Jackal58 wrote:
My vote for LSB is more of a place holder atm than an out right condemnation.
I'm actually wondering why The Mango hasn't been thoroughly grilled.
So without further ado.
Mango man where are you?
Did you get a list of your scum buddies yet?
Inquiring minds want to know.

A quick question as well - What do the following stand for?
RNG?
FOS - Full of shit?
PBPA?

I'm a bit hesitant to ask because I was immediately labeled a smurf in the HP game and got offed on the first night.

eh, not sure what we gain by waiting one more night, can you explain? I dont get this 2nd day explanation given by him. He's basically saying he's a blue role, but not mad hatter. Which means vigilante or DT. Do you honestly think he's a DT? I dont...

Also, how can we be 100% sure by waiting another round. If we are wrong, and LSB is not mafia, and DT checks him, LSB is the most likely target for the framer to choose. So we'd be nowhere...

-----------------------------------------
Original Message From Pandain:
unvote lsb
i am 99% sure he's mafia, but there's really no harm in waiting just one night just to be 100% sure.

Better safe than sorry, and just remember, he will die unless he gives proof.

On December 29 2010 07:13 Insanious wrote:
Killing a mafia today or killing one tomorrow is not very different in this early stage of the game. But killing a blue early really hurts as they dont get to do any night actions.

As such, killing LSB later if he does not follow through with his plan is >>>>>>> killing him now.

Killing a random green >>>>>>> killing a blue.

As such, killing anyone but LSB today is >>>>>>> killing LSB.

LSB has a 20% chance of being mafia as anyone else, you make it seem like he has slipped up somewhere, but he hasn't... he has a 20% chance just like everyone else, and there is nothing that screams mafia about LSB.

LSB is giving us an alternative route...

Vote someone else, and save a possible blue.
If he is not blue, kill him.

Town loses nothing, we only gain the life of a blue, so killing LSB is bad right now.