Don't lose yo village! - Page 10

On November 15 2010 03:57 DoctorHelvetica wrote:

plan in regards to what

On November 15 2010 01:50 Pandain wrote:
In addition, LSB who is confirmed. Why should you tell? Obviously in case I'm missing something mull this over, but here's my thoughts:

If it's a townie, then you know he's confirmed because he didn't do anything.

If it's a doctor, then you would know he's confirmed because he didn't hit Artanis(assuming artanis is town, which shall be found out via the above.)

So there's no way to know who is.

On November 15 2010 03:57 Pandain wrote:


as in "dang was hoping we caught a scum"
and "Was hoping he would claim clam and than mafia claims calm" or something.

On November 15 2010 04:00 Pandain wrote:


LSB what about this.

In addition, I think you should track Dr. H tonight, and doctor and shrink both protect you.

On November 15 2010 03:55 LSB wrote:
Kenpachi what do you think of DoctorH? Can you address Pandain's accusation against him?


As for my analysis, I feel dumb for missing out on a post, so I'll do my analysis later.

On November 15 2010 04:00 DoctorHelvetica wrote:

"doctor and shrink both protect LSB so we can convert DrH and kill someone else"

On November 15 2010 04:00 Pandain wrote:


LSB what about this.

In addition, I think you should track Dr. H tonight, and doctor and shrink both protect you.

On November 15 2010 04:01 Kenpachi wrote:



To Pandain:We could have possibly faked a possible roleclaim if Artanis claimed Clam, Mafia could have tried to cause confusion and claim Calm and fall for the clam claim. the clam bros know that the role didnt specify which clam they were.

On November 15 2010 04:03 Pandain wrote:


We? We could have possibly faked a possible roleclaim?

On November 15 2010 04:04 Kenpachi wrote:

We being town.. assuming Artanis to be town..

On November 15 2010 04:05 Pandain wrote:


So town fakes a possible roleclaim....why?

On November 15 2010 04:05 Kenpachi wrote:

to bait a Mafia to take the fake roleclaim

On November 15 2010 04:06 Pandain wrote:


But what if the vet's claim because they think they then found scum? Which was very likely.

On November 15 2010 04:08 Kenpachi wrote:

wait what? im not understand this :S

On November 15 2010 03:54 DoctorHelvetica wrote:
I'm surprised I didn't get converted, moreso than shot. But I provided two reasons why they might not have targeted to me. Why wouldn't the mafia think medics would protect me? Who else would the doctor protect lol and I already said, it is possible mafia don't target vets. particularly if one of the 2 mafia is a vet, not targeting the other vet in the game will keep suspicion off of him and then mafia can bandwagon me, naw sayin? that's how I tried to get brownbear or whatever in micro mafia. i have no idea why you think its unlikely a doctor would protect me lol
One of your reasons was they might be doing the thing where they don't target vets so, like your example game, you don't get under suscipioiini. The other one was that it could lead to wifom about "why are you alive." I think the more logical option is just to take you out and be safe.
Why wouldn't the doctors protect LSB, lol. Would be pointless for him to track someone and then die.
But it's mainly besides the point if a doctor protect you, the point is you didn't get shot/converted, yet Artanis did.

i believed artanis claim, i was hoping mafia would bandwagon the shit out of him trying to make his claim look fake, that's what i meant when i was talking to kthez
Why would they be so rash?

anyway about pressure being a bad thing. coagulation is bad at this game. if he is town pressuring him will just make him look bad, if he is mafia pressuring him will make him look equally bad. the best bet with him if he's mafia is that he'll be really transparent and defend some mafia buddy in a super obvious way
So we should never pressure coagulation? And again, if he's mafia, I'm pretty sure he's being coached from his previous mistakes.

I was just going to say how pressuring inactive players with votes can be good as long as it doesn't become a deathwagon
Your not doing anything though

as far as me not scumhunting sure I am. i'm reading everyones post and thinking. i'm not gonna spam the thread with FoS's on everyone who says something mildly dumb or suspicious otherwise I'd be FoS'ing all the time lol. i decided my biggest mistake as town in insane mafia was posting too much and thinking too little.
Well you are spamming the thread "tru", "he was good at both games imo" and so forth. So your just not going to spam when its actually relevant? The point is your spamming, but not with real info.

and i wasn't analysing artanis really. you said "i don't like how you're saying he isn't confirmed" but he fucking isn't lol. the other bulletproof shouldn't claim, this narrows mafia targets down way too much, the whole purpose of a bulletproof role is you goad the mafia into shooting you. sure if the other one claims the same thing it "confirms" artanis but then we just lose the whole point of the role, don't do it
Well now you say he should claim. And in all liklihood he is confirmed. I would say your right, he's not because he doesn't know whether he's clam, calm, but since you never brought it up I will stand by this point.
now as far as not saying "i think this person is 100% townie" here's why. if I say and convince everyone, say, Kenpachi is definiiiiitely town. Mafia just won't even bandwagon them. If I hold my tongue and wait to see if mafia pressure him with bullshit then I can come out and hopefully cut through their bullshit and catch a mafia. we all know who we think is town, it doesn't limit discussion, it's a pointless discussion in the first place imo
Good, they will have to find other people. And we'll have more general info. For example, if a more expierenced player is like "Hey, this guy is obviously town!" then that's useful to share with less skilled players. And it's definitely not pointless since you've already said you don't think artanis is red.
you can feel free to disagree but I want to a play a game where the mafia makes mistakes, the more we tell them the less room for that there is. artanis claiming was a mistake, let's not do additional damage by having the other BP roleclaim even if its to do something like confirm
artanis
and aren't you saying now we should have him claim.