"After capturing a province you may choose to “recruit” the player of the province. Doing so gains you any ability that they may have, with a few exceptions (such as the missionary role, for example). If you already have a recruiter ability, taking another ability nullifies your previous one."

If he did recruit someone day one, they didn't have an ability

kingjames01

Canada1603 Posts

November 21 2010 00:45 GMT

#986

He captured a Neutral province on the first day.

Chezinu

United States7447 Posts

November 21 2010 00:46 GMT

#987

Caller what province was he?

Pandain

United States12989 Posts

November 21 2010 00:46 GMT

#988

Caller, if he recruits someone, does he actually get the player to join his team, or just/and get the player's ability?

kingjames01

Canada1603 Posts

November 21 2010 00:57 GMT

#989

He started in Province 27. Didn't you read my plan?

kingjames01

Canada1603 Posts

November 21 2010 00:58 GMT

#990

Here it is again:

EVERYONE, I HAVE A PLAN!

No one wants to be eliminated, right? Every player, in theory, is in the game to win. It sucks being lynched early and no one likes being the the target. Thus, everyone fights really hard when they know they are facing a lynch vote. The ensuing discussion gets really messy and no one knows if it is a mafia-inspired lynch.

Here's my plan:
LYNCH HESMYRR.

He's confirmed that he was Sakura Gaibun
His last province was eliminated overnight so he no longer has a vote.

Wouldn't it be better if we lynch someone who cannot affect the game anymore? Someone whose vote does not count? We can still get information from their flip.

Here's the best part...
If he is town, we do not hurt ourselves by lynching him as the town-to-mafia vote ratio is not affected.
If he is mafia, we can benefit by clearing up confusion and finding connections between him and other Reds.

At this moment, this is our best possible proposed plan for a Day 3 action. Let's get out our vote.

Chezinu

United States7447 Posts

November 21 2010 00:59 GMT

#991

On November 21 2010 09:57 kingjames01 wrote:
He started in Province 27. Didn't you read my plan?

Let's see if Caller confirms. No, I didn't read your plan.

annul

United States2841 Posts

November 21 2010 01:00 GMT

#992

just because he's mafia does not mean my logic was any less sound.

you cannot say "LOL RECRUITER THAT'S WHY HE WANTED TO WAIT" when the guy is dead with no land. what would he do? did he even take a territory night one in order to steal a power?

note my entire argument was "give it one day" NOT "don't kill him!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!"

the guy had like 8 votes on him when i decided to question the logic. why would i give myself up if i were a mafia like that? that's retarded. every. single. post. that i made. questioned the TIMING, not the kill itself. hesmyrr had no power. as a mafia, if i were mafia, i'd know that. so why would keeping him alive one more day matter? why put my own nuts out there to be cut off?

kingjames01

Canada1603 Posts

November 21 2010 01:00 GMT

#993

Oh, this is also relevant and became an issue.

On November 20 2010 04:13 kingjames01 wrote:
I'm going to post something before the mafia figure it out.

Here's what I'm predicting. Since voting is not mandatory, the mafia is going to wait on this vote until they are sure the town has stirred. They don't want Hesmyrr to flip.

Now, somewhere along the line, one of the more clever mafiosos might realize a way out, so I've been trying to think of a way for Hesmyrr or one of his scum buddies to wriggle out of it.

They're going to advocate keeping him around so that he can still "benefit" the town. Maybe they'll claim that he's a Guerrilla Warrior. Any player who does any such action is suspicious.

Too bad Feeble Scum didn't pay attention...

annul

United States2841 Posts

November 21 2010 01:02 GMT

#994

or, you know, KJ, you say that because even you knew it was a possible way out for him, and you wanted to cut off the logical path before it was used

i am sorry that i came to the thread a few hours after you did with the exact same thought. it doesnt make it any less valid. i stand by my logic even as he flips mafia, because that is irrelevant. the logic was you cannot PROVE it.

you are like these nubs who go all in pre-flop in poker with 7 2 and then say how skilled you are when the flop is 777 and how great and intelligent your pre-flop play was

Coagulation

United States9633 Posts

November 21 2010 01:03 GMT

#995

I doubt they would do exactly what you said to expect scum to do if they are really scum.

annul

United States2841 Posts

November 21 2010 01:03 GMT

#996

besides, what you say is not the law. why is a player using logic "suspicious" if it is a perfectly valid possibility?

annul

United States2841 Posts