Sengoku Mafia - Page 32

On November 17 2010 12:15 Hesmyrr wrote:
In fact Caller still has not yet confirmed if eliminated players can talk to surviving players at all. Still waiting for him to officially clarify it on thread.

On November 17 2010 12:14 Hesmyrr wrote:
No, lynching #17 will provide a solid flip, and you prior stated that you are willing to do this just to prove that you are on right side. But now when I asked for info on #17, you suddenly withdraw completely. I do not understand that change in stance. And are we really discussing counterclaims when only five people like posted since this argument started?

Note that 17 doesn't have a vote and only a slim chance of reviving. I don't think the real 17 would object if we had to lynch him (who's already dead) in order to take care of a mafia.

But if it comes down to it, lynching both people who claim to be 17 isn't going to hurt the town, because we don't lose any townie votes.

On November 17 2010 12:23 Hesmyrr wrote:



Okay, just read your last post. But before that, is there any eliminated player currently posting in this thread? I just want to see if counterclaim is available, because otherwise I am guessing you are going to keep sticking to attacking me regardless of how much I explain that my words you are incriminating me with can be interpreted ambiguously.

On November 17 2010 12:15 Hesmyrr wrote:
In fact Caller still has not yet confirmed if eliminated players can talk to surviving players at all. Still waiting for him to officially clarify it on thread.

On November 16 2010 05:12 Caller wrote:
(mod note: eliminated players are not removed from the game just yet. in fact if you have been eliminated you should PM me.)

On November 17 2010 12:28 kingjames01 wrote:


What are you talking about? Caller already said, and I also repeated it, that "eliminated" players are not out of the game.

On November 17 2010 12:35 seRapH wrote:
God this was hard to read through, especially since you all kept using numbers.

For those who are calling me out:
I suggested the plan because I thought I found a possible loophole. I was wrong, I admit that. And Ace was the one who actually pointed that out, and immediately afterwards a few people jumped on that and said HEY YEAH THIS SOUNDS SCUMMY. This doesn't make me suspect Ace, but rather those who followed his lead.

I did not attack, I defended as promised. I'm not about to start lying unless I have to. (But maybe that was a lie!). In any case, that should narrow down which country I am, shouldn't it?

Sorry, it's really hard to follow this thread when everything's written in numbers and so much crap is happening in PMs. Plus I keep losing my spot because of LR threads >.> So maybe I missed it or it's happening through PMs, but who knows who 17 and 13 are (if anyone)?

On November 17 2010 12:36 kingjames01 wrote:
Alright, before this gets out of hand, we should calm down and try to sum up our thoughts. If we learned anything from Insane Mafia, it's that too many posts cloud our judgement and allows mafia plenty of wriggle room to hide.

First, I'd like to lay down a ground rule that will only serve to help the town.

NO EDITING.

Editing helps mafia if they get caught in a lie. I suggest that we not give them the advantage. However, we need a majority to agree. I propose that anyone caught editing their posts from this moment forward be subject to a lynch. This may lead to some inconvenience for the townies but it will help us all.

So, who's in?

On November 17 2010 12:36 kingjames01 wrote:
Alright, before this gets out of hand, we should calm down and try to sum up our thoughts. If we learned anything from Insane Mafia, it's that too many posts cloud our judgement and allows mafia plenty of wriggle room to hide.

First, I'd like to lay down a ground rule that will only serve to help the town.

NO EDITING.

Editing helps mafia if they get caught in a lie. I suggest that we not give them the advantage. However, we need a majority to agree. I propose that anyone caught editing their posts from this moment forward be subject to a lynch. This may lead to some inconvenience for the townies but it will help us all.

So, who's in?

On November 17 2010 12:57 annul wrote:
im in with kingjames' edit plan.

ps does pandain ever speak in proper english? "meesa" what? =(

when does the day end?

also, do LYNCHED players ever have the chance to revive on the game board?

On November 17 2010 12:40 jcarlsoniv wrote:
I'm cool with no editing. I've done it a couple times myself, but mostly just because of formating issues. Idk if everyone will follow this, especially since it's not mod upheld. And wasting a lynch on a townie editing would just suck.

On November 17 2010 12:57 annul wrote:
im in with kingjames' edit plan.

ps does pandain ever speak in proper english? "meesa" what? =(

when does the day end?

also, do LYNCHED players ever have the chance to revive on the game board?

On November 17 2010 13:04 Caller wrote:

lynched players are dead

On November 17 2010 13:05 kingjames01 wrote:


If we don't follow through, then mafia can change 'history' and revel in the chaos.

On November 17 2010 13:06 jcarlsoniv wrote:


AHHHH since you're here:

Can eliminated players still talk in the thread?

On November 17 2010 13:10 Caller wrote:

^_^