TL Mafia XXX - Page 3

On August 08 2010 10:29 BrownBear wrote:
really its between BM and Love1another. The people voting for Roffles are mostly just placeholders/people who don't care about the day 1 lynch.

On August 08 2010 10:33 chaoser wrote:
It's not even close, it's just 10 v 6. I feel like if it was closer we would learn a lot more. IE if one was mafia, people would move late in the day to save them.

On August 06 2010 14:08 rastaban wrote:
Regarding inactivity, last game both SouthRawea and Xelin were very inactive, if we had lynched them earlier for this we would have gotten the IT before he had a chance to wreck us. instead we pushed for supposedly obvious lynches. Day 2, not a single person on the kill list was mafia. Mafia can be quiet as well.

The reason for lynching inactives is because it forces activity which is good for the town. Regardless of your alignment if you are not posting and barely contributing you are anti-town. The Traitor role is added to games because having even one town person trying cause problems can balance a game where the mafia is too weak. Every person who creates chaos for sake of chaos or who hides and doesn't post is effectively playing a traitor role. The town feels good if a lynch gets the traitor even though he isn't technically red. For some players even if they flip green town should cheer because at least we got traitor even if in name only.

If everyone is active then sure, lets look at posts for day one, but if we have inactives you can be sure I will be voting for them because regardless of how they flip the town is better off.

Sorry for the rant, but is something I have been pondering for a while and wanted to share.

On August 08 2010 11:02 chaoser wrote:
why did you switch and then switch back rastaban -_-

On August 08 2010 11:13 flamewheel wrote:

I've killed six off in a 30 game before.

Relevant Posts.

On August 08 2010 13:08 Foolishness wrote:

Aren't you supposed to be arguing with BM? I recall you making multiple posts about how when BM flips red I'm for sure his mafia buddy. Which is strange as a whole since BM has been actively opposing me for a while now...but I guess that's just cause he realized you were obviously townie so he turned to look at the next best player who could be mafia and here I was!

Say, have you dared to notice how this thread has been dominated by the same 10ish people? I mean surely you have to have realized that you've been holding conversations in the thread with the same people over and over and over again.

I only happened to take notice when I decided to make a list of the inactive/lurkers. And I got 16-20 people on that list, give or take.

And now I beg to wonder...when you, BM, Divinek, Pandain, and youngminii are through killing each other off, how you going to find the rest of the mafia? Do you even have any idea who among the lurkers is probably innocent and who's suspicious? Probably not because you're busy formulating the town plan and looking at the active players (there's nothing wrong with this at all, I'm just saying how it is).

Now it seems very reasonable to me (and I'd hope a few others) that all you goody active players just toss your ego's aside for a moment and take care to notice of the fact that good players who are normally active are pretty much mia this entire game (i.e. Chezinu, Infundibulum, DTA). Not to mention some veteran is smurfing under the name VayeshMoru. Perhaps we should be looking here since when the lot of you are finish killing yourselves off the town is going to be screwed. And I do realize that there's a better chance I'm going to invent a perpetual motion device tomorrow than of this happening, but I guess I just secretly hope someone takes note of this and learns from it.

I don't see any reason why this game isn't a repeat of the one BM hosted. Mafia sit back and do nothing and watch town kill themselves. Yes I realize it got a tad bit complicated in the middle but still.

I know you're probably thinking at some point "Well hey Foolishness, you are normally more active that you're currently being why should we pay more attention to Chezinu than you?" Truth is, I don't have time to deal with all your "town plans" that probably aren't going to work and your suspicions against me. I got a job to do, I'm weeding out mafia members among the lurkers. And that's what I do best. It's day one and I don't got much to go on since nobody is pressuring any of the lurkers, but I'd like to think I'm getting somewhere with it. And there are more than enough people that can vouch that I'm active in PM land.

You go do what you do. I'm going to go do what I do. I'll talk to you when it's necessary and I have information. If you or BM or anyone keep taking one-liner shots at me in the thread, don't expect a response, I don't have the time.

On August 09 2010 00:04 LSB wrote:

I wouldn't recommend it. My plan relys on complete town cohesion. Every single blue role must participate, or else it fails.

The problem is, people have been accusing each other distracting from forming a plan. Certainly someone in there is doing this deliberatively, in order for us to win, we have to work together and random accusations distracts us.

Just proceed as normal. I'll try to push my plan tomorrow

On August 09 2010 05:48 BrownBear wrote:
I've been thinking about it, trying to find a hole in it for the last hour or so, and so far I find it foolproof. Doesn't mean there isn't a hole, just means I haven't found one

I'm alright with it. Let's do it!

On August 09 2010 13:15 Roffles wrote:
You guys suck, where are my PMs?

On August 09 2010 13:59 Divinek wrote:


well so far you have been playing very different than you usually do man

where's the young we know and love with his big red bold lists

and his 'im gonna get you lynched motherfucker' attitude

On August 10 2010 00:59 SouthRawrea wrote:
Question: Why is Youngminii tied for votes against Bill Murray? Something is wrong here. If there is a reason for those votes please tell us. This would've probably been brought up later once the vote count came in.

On August 10 2010 01:08 youngminii wrote:
Oh yeah rastaban, good work coming up with solid reasoning, maybe you should have talked a little more with your scummates first. The votes on BM came before the votes on me. Both bandwagons are dumb.

I'd like to direct your attention to foolishness, stop voting uselessly on me and BM please. Kthx.

On August 10 2010 01:50 tree.hugger wrote:

Pretty sure BM *isn't mafia.

On August 10 2010 05:13 VayeshMoru wrote:


Simple mistake to make. One must learn to read the past to make sense of the path we walk on. That is why a scribe has been needed.

On August 10 2010 05:31 VayeshMoru wrote:


Does not matter. You fail to see the logic in this. A framer followed leads to a dead victim, not who he framed. The tracker would prove xelin town if xelin went out. No?

On August 10 2010 07:51 XeliN wrote:
How long do we have left of today?