Penalty Mafia - Page 6

LSB

United States5171 Posts

August 18 2010 14:27 GMT

#825

On August 18 2010 23:20 citi.zen wrote:
Hmmm... I guess then the doctor role was just really weakened - the mafia can choose to hit a non-protected person every time. Since there are no clear ways to confirm people in this set-up (other than the day-vigi), was this nerf necessary?

I must be missing some possibilities here...

I think the doctor is more for protection. He're what I think Hesmyrr was thinking.

Day 1, random person gets killed
Day 2, Pyrr goes check someone, finds if they are green or red. Claims DT.
Ace's role was to protect Pyrr. If the mafia decided to hit Pyrr, they'd have to waste the next nights role. Either way, that should create at 2 confirmed townies.

Confirmed Townie 1: Ace, Hesmyrr's post in the night automatically gets him confirmed

When Pyrr dies, whoever he checks will be confirmed, so that would leave 2 Confirmed Townies

LSB

United States5171 Posts

August 18 2010 14:36 GMT

#829

On August 18 2010 23:32 Hesmyrr wrote:
I mentioned the hypothetical Ace/chaoser/LSB/bumatlarge group in the above post of mine. That's exactly how it should have worked. Had Ace survived, chaoser claims and reveal his intent to shoot Ace, and Ace subsequently fully claims also (or vice versa). Because both are mod-verifiable, their lynch should be delayed and chaoser would vote for someone in the "unconfirmed" pool while Ace protect him. Because two clear town roles are in open, LSB would also claim and reveal his bumatlarge investigation.

Ah! I see.

As for Bum, I didn't bother claiming because he was never under much suspicion, and I didn't want him to get nightkilled, since I liked knowing who one of the townies was. I was planning on claiming and explaining everything day 4, but I got killed so that's that.

LSB

United States5171 Posts

August 18 2010 14:41 GMT

#832

On August 18 2010 23:39 Hesmyrr wrote:
Anyway thanks to everyone for playing my first modded game in TeamLiquid! It could have been far better - especially disappointed about my inability to produce flavour text in time, wireless internet getting kaputt every night did not help matters either - but it was valuable experience for me.

Thanks for hosting! It was a fun concept that everyone got some sort of power, good or bad.