On August 09 2010 10:50 chaoser wrote:
People are not saying mafia will know the specific role of each player, just that they will know if the player is blue or not -_-

please respond to this -_-

chaoser

United States5541 Posts

August 09 2010 02:00 GMT

#283

@chaoser: You can't know who's blue. Everyone has a role. Everyone has a penalty. I've already said that if anyone is so sure that knowing penalties will reveal who is blue then tell me what roles myself and zeks have if it's that simple.

On August 09 2010 10:38 citi.zen wrote:

Show nested quote +

I am stuck in "regular" mafia land, but to me this translates into:

Ace: weak blue
bumatlarge: strong blue
zeks: vanilla townie

Do we want this info out there?

chaoser

United States5541 Posts

August 09 2010 02:04 GMT

#289

On August 09 2010 11:02 Ace wrote:
@chaoser: If I'm blue then what's my role. How does a voting wagon imply that zeks must be townie?

It doesn't matter what role you are, just that you're blue so mafia would target you. zek's penalty in itself doesn't imply that he is townie, but people with penalties that are linked to "actions" (do action and something happens, must do something and then you can act) are a lot more likely to blue no?

chaoser

United States5541 Posts

August 09 2010 02:18 GMT

#292

bumatlarge: If acting mafia population goes up by 1, town population goes down by 1

I'm pretty sure when bum says action, he doesn't mean talking or voting...that'd be too simple an action to make the penalty that bad

chaoser

United States5541 Posts

August 09 2010 03:18 GMT

#302

well, BM just posted in other thread, I assume we'll get a response from him soon

chaoser

United States5541 Posts

August 09 2010 12:49 GMT

#331

wait....seriously? BM comes back, makes a statement about how he's just dicking around and now all of a sudden the pressures off him and on Pyrr in a huge way? something strikes me as odd, I'll go back and re-read

chaoser

United States5541 Posts

August 09 2010 17:25 GMT

#337

Just as a note, youngminii has been way active (well now at least =p) in the other game, not a peep in this one

chaoser

United States5541 Posts

August 09 2010 21:40 GMT

#355

##vote Ace

I gotta leave for friend's house, taking her out to dinner cause I GOT ACCEPTED INTO MED SCHOOL!!! But I'll explain my vote after I get back, Pyrr is still going to be lynch regardless I think, can someone else put a vote on him? I gotta switch off cause of my penalty.

chaoser

United States5541 Posts

August 10 2010 14:22 GMT

#434

jesus, i'm gone for a night and shit goes down -_-. Why didn't people get off Pyrr when he claimed DT? I guess it was too late at that point? Ace, you got some explaining to do...what is this "hidden ability" stuff about?

chaoser

United States5541 Posts

August 10 2010 15:59 GMT

#437

mm, are you sure it's bs? I want him to talk about it first/how he came tot he conclusion that he has a hidden ability before I decide

chaoser

United States5541 Posts

August 11 2010 00:13 GMT

#452

mm, i don't think so, seems like he died outright to mafia. Occam's razor ftw. Unless someone claims vigi/shot him.

chaoser

United States5541 Posts

August 11 2010 02:17 GMT

#469

let's keep doing the penalty listings, while people can draw conjecture from the penalties about what color we are green/blue, they can't pinpoint our roles and we might as well to get all info out there. My penalty, If I vote majority (as in if I vote for the person being lynched), I can't vote (gotta abstain) the next day.

chaoser

United States5541 Posts

August 11 2010 02:17 GMT

#470

also, it's weird that BM's thing is that if he dies, a certain type of power role loses it's power and yet mafia didn't hit him, that's like killing two birds with one stone.

chaoser

United States5541 Posts

August 12 2010 01:11 GMT

#515

I am Obvious. I'm starting to think that there is no townie role, everyone is just blue. Think about the penalties so far, Ace could only do an action if he tells it ahead of time, meaning everyone will know/suspect he's blue. And Pyrr's is that he had to wait till Night 2. Those are some crazy penalties. Unless we're all blue.

chaoser

United States5541 Posts

August 12 2010 06:26 GMT

#539

so basically claiming meant nothing...so we're back to no info again. Are we only suppose to play this game via reading scumtells and then using powers to catch them in the act or what? In either case, BM's whole charade with saying he couldn't talk and then letting Pyrr and Ace fight it out seemed VERYY scummy. And now he says he killed Ace which is weird cause that means mafia either didn't hit, or it got blocked, possibly by Ace though that seems off, I'd rather believe Occam's razor that the mafia just hit Ace and BM is lying out his ass.