We're going to have to very very closely watch what every single player posts, and the second someone slips up, lynch them. Simple as that.

Honestly, without coroner I think we might be screwed.

BrownBear

United States6894 Posts

July 04 2010 20:34 GMT

#797

I think it has to do with heightened paranoia, given that we don't get confirmation or denial of our lynches. Ever. Unless we got very very lucky and the dreamcatcher caught coroner, or there are 2 in the game (which I doubt in a game of 20).

But it is time to give up on that idea. I think at this point, there's no doubt zeks is mason. However, I really do want him to post that friggin coded message already.

BrownBear

United States6894 Posts

July 04 2010 23:40 GMT

#825

There's always the chance that zeks is mafia. It's a small chance, but it exists.

Can we stop yelling at each other over this please?

BrownBear

United States6894 Posts

July 05 2010 05:35 GMT

#848

I think BM is correct, but I also think that we're now entering the stage where the really really good players are going to start being recruited. Now that mafia has a couple players (and remember the GF can only recruit 5), the GF is probably going to want to add the best scum players possible.

Take Ace, for example. Especially after his how-to-play-scum thread, I would be very surprised if the GF does not recruit him soon. We should probably take necessary precautions, unless Korynne was recruited already and he inherited that.

BrownBear

United States6894 Posts

July 05 2010 05:40 GMT

#849

On July 05 2010 12:29 YellowInk wrote:
After reviewing the list of participants, Abenson has still provided the least useful content. Since he has not provided enough content to figure out if he's turned to mafia, if he were recruited he would be difficult or impossible to reveal by post analysis.

I havn't been able to find anything that indicates someone was turned. Yet. So in the absence of something directly indicating red, my vote is going for Abenson.

On the flip side, what GF in their right mind would recruit Abenson? In normal games he's a liability for town, but in a recruitment game he might actually be an asset.

BrownBear

United States6894 Posts

July 05 2010 06:26 GMT

#855

On July 05 2010 15:14 Bill Murray wrote:

Show nested quote +

Generic comments
Excuse for not being here and lurking
Summary of last couple posts

Plz explain, BrownBear... Lack of reading, or scumminess? You have proven to me earlier that you don't read every post.

Job as a camp counselor. Working from 7 AM to 11 or midnight most days. Sometimes I just don't have the time to read everything, so I skim what doesn't look important. Sorry.

Also, neither blue nor red. Green.

BrownBear

United States6894 Posts

July 06 2010 06:03 GMT

#1014

L's post-death FoS on Abenson is likely more his suspicions rather than any cold hard evidence.

Having a second Coroner is far far better than we could have ever dreamed. What might happen...

1: L or bum will pop red. If L pops red, Abenson is likely cleared for now + the lover story carries more weight. If bum pops red... that's cool :D
2: L or bum pop green/blue. If L pops blue we gotta take a better look at Abenson, because then he could actually know something we didnt. If bum pops green/blue... dammit. Bum did claim townie (after claiming godfather lolz), so we should check that.

If L pops lover (which could happen, DTA did say he wouldnt modkill lover pairs), or if nothing pops, we should block divinek and Abenson for the rest of the game. If we have 2 confirmed scum, we can shut mafia down indefinitely while we continue our GF witchhunt.

Jailkeep: Protect whichever one you think is more likely to get killed. Roleblockers, if you block them you are dumb, dumb dumb.

And tomorrow: I really do think mass roleclaim is a good idea. With the information we get from the coroner-pop (hopefully), we should be able to figure out at least who mafia is, so we can roleblock them, and if we're lucky we'll nail the GF on day 3. That would be kind of awesome.

To start the mass roleclaim (because I don't know how much time I have), I am TOWNIE.

BrownBear

United States6894 Posts

July 06 2010 06:08 GMT

#1015

(and yes, I realize the implications of claiming at night, I just am not sure when I'll be back on, and I don't want to miss the party. I'm pretty secure in roleclaiming green at night, because scum know im town anyways. The only danger is if they decide to go for the sure green kill rather than gamble and hope they nail a blue, and I think that would be a dumb strategy for scum, especially in this setup).

BrownBear

United States6894 Posts

July 06 2010 08:07 GMT

#1053

lawldrama.

Also, YI... cult game = we gotta do the mass roleclaim much earlier. You weren't around for 3 kingdoms mafia, but the mass roleclaim essentially won the game for town.

BrownBear

United States6894 Posts

July 06 2010 20:11 GMT

#1069

I actually think mass roleclaim is a good idea, YI, simply because of the numbers.

Tomorrow, it will be 8 to 4 barring a very lucky roleblock. If we don't lynch a scum, when the next day rolls around, it will be 6 to 5. That's bad. Very bad. We need as much information as possible, and we need it right now.

BrownBear

United States6894 Posts

July 07 2010 01:52 GMT

#1094

On July 07 2010 08:46 DarthThienAn wrote:

Show nested quote +

Me too! I can't wait to see what roles the dead people are. keke

Lol so this is confirmation that Divinek is townie?

+ Show Spoiler +

BrownBear

United States6894 Posts

July 07 2010 02:37 GMT

#1119

On July 07 2010 11:08 youngminii wrote:
I am DT. citi.zen is GF.

OH SNAP.

Buying this. youngminii hasn't really given any reasons to do it. Let's do iiiit.

BrownBear

United States6894 Posts

July 07 2010 03:06 GMT

#1130

On July 07 2010 11:37 BrownBear wrote:

Show nested quote +

Buying this. youngminii hasn't really given any reasons for us to doubt him. Let's do iiiit.

ebwop above.

BrownBear

United States6894 Posts

July 07 2010 03:07 GMT

#1131

Also, lawl citi.zen. You had a chance at a decent defense until you made that blatant error there.

Youve been fingered as GF, you lie, means you're GF. We lynch you now ok bye.

BrownBear

United States6894 Posts

July 07 2010 03:14 GMT

#1133

And finally, since the question isn't really "who do we lynch today", I think we should talk about "do we vote double lynch today". I'm not really a fan of that idea. Here's why:

There have been 3 recruitements
We know one of them (L) is dead.
We (hopefully) are killing the GF today.

That leaves 2 mafia to 11 town. We have all the time in the world. Why would we double lynch unless we were absolutely sure we could nail both scum in one turn and end the game? I don't think it's possible given the current information we have.

Speaking of information:

citi.zen said BM was town = heavy heavy suspicion on BM now
L said Abenson was scum = Abenson is probably town (barring citibank recruiting him last night).

Pretty good start, I think.

BrownBear

United States6894 Posts

July 07 2010 03:29 GMT

#1161

On July 07 2010 12:21 Bill Murray wrote:
shut up a5j you scummy fuck

You are flailing so hard it's not even funny.

You don't play this bad, BM. You are definitely scum.

BrownBear

United States6894 Posts

July 07 2010 03:32 GMT

#1169

On July 07 2010 12:30 Bill Murray wrote:

Show nested quote +

shut the fuck up brownbear, i'm a fucking jailkeeper

Manner up and calm the fuck down. You are being a total asshole right now, and honestly, it's not called for.

Take 5, walk away from the thread, then post a coherent defense post, longer than 1 line, and I'll listen.

Until then, I'm going to just let you rage.

BrownBear

United States6894 Posts

July 07 2010 03:39 GMT

#1182

Let's talk about Abenson. L claimed he was scum in his death post, now thanks to Divinek we know L was both traitor and scum. Do we think this clears Abenson, or do we think the GF recruited him?

Personally, I'm thinking he is town.

BrownBear

United States6894 Posts

July 07 2010 03:40 GMT

#1187

On July 07 2010 12:39 Ace wrote:
DCLXVI

And now we have pretty good reason to believe DCL is town. I'm assuming Ace was DT or something similar, given he just joined the game so doesn't really have much to go on.

BrownBear

United States6894 Posts

July 07 2010 03:42 GMT

#1191

On July 07 2010 12:40 Bill Murray wrote:
now everyone else needs to roleclaim to protect the fact that i roleclaimed as jailkeeper
you all are safe, as i will be targetted 100%
i am our medic, after all

and if NOONE COUNTERCLAIMS then im the only jailkeeper

Sadly, mafia is probably not going to kill you tonight. All they have to do is hit someone, then we lynch you for still being alive. This is assuming you're jailkeep of course, which I'm still somewhat doubtful about (sorry, but the fact that citi.zen lied in a post where he said you were town is a bit damning.)