Pick Your Power Mafia! - Page 44

On May 08 2010 17:06 Korynne wrote:
How will it end sooner...
We have 2 days either way...and 3 tries instead of 2 tries to hit mafia if we keep you around (and mafia kills you tonight).

So right now my choices for lynch would be: Qatol, Falcynn, or OpZ.

On May 08 2010 17:27 Korynne wrote:
Foolishness who do you think is mafia?

On May 08 2010 17:12 Foolishness wrote:

If you kill me today, 1mafia/5 town. Goes to night, 1 mafia/4town. If you mislynch, 1 mafia/3 town, goes to night, 1 mafia/2town. Lynch ends the game

Worst case scenario there's 3 more days (including today).

Keep me alive and we mislynch, 1mafia/5town. Goes to night, mafia hit. Lets say my hit doesn't hit mafia. 1 mafia/3town. Lynch ends the game as if there's a mislynch it goes to night and mafia will kill someone and win.

Worst case scenario there's 2 more days (including today).

This is all assuming all hits go through, meaning there's no Jack/bulletproof/etc alive.

On May 08 2010 16:56 Foolishness wrote:

Game will end 1 day sooner if you keep me alive

On May 08 2010 17:37 Qatol wrote:

I'd like to point out that I was the one pushing for the CompVig hit on Zona. I realize it probably gets me nowhere in anyone's eyes, but it is still a fact.
With Zona flipping scum, as Korynne mentioned, citi.zen is cleared through the numbers. (I think the mafia would have to be insane to double up on 12 with the original setup.)


Does it? How?
Let's assume you are innocent:
5 1 - lynch an innocent player other than you
4 1 - mafia miss, you miss
2 1 - lynch or lose

5 1 - lynch you
4 1 - mafia miss
3 1 - this is still lynch or lose. If the town mislynches here, we still lose.
This is because we would be at 2 1 with a mafia hit incoming. That takes us down to 1 1 and mafia win if their numbers equal our own.

Anyways, I have an analysis of you in the works. You have some questions I think you need to answer.

On May 08 2010 17:46 Foolishness wrote:

I pointed it out above. Ends one day sooner. Your math is wrong here. Stick to your draft numbers, you know the thing you have been focusing on ALL GAME LONG.

If your analysis has anything to do with the draft or number picking, I'm not going to bother to respond. You need arguments that aren't centered around it; my eyes are continually sore from your repetitive arguments about people picking numbers.

I always thought you were more of a behavioral analysis guy, not an Ace "omg guys I found the ultimate plan to find the mafia if any of you disagree with me we kill you!" kinda guy.

On May 08 2010 17:12 Foolishness wrote:
If you kill me today, 1mafia/5 town. Goes to night, 1 mafia/4town. If you mislynch, 1 mafia/3 town, goes to night, 1 mafia/2town. Lynch ends the game

Worst case scenario there's 3 more days (including today).

Keep me alive and we mislynch, 1mafia/5town. Goes to night, mafia hit. Lets say my hit doesn't hit mafia. 1 mafia/3town. Lynch ends the game as if there's a mislynch it goes to night and mafia will kill someone and win.

Worst case scenario there's 2 more days (including today).

This is all assuming all hits go through, meaning there's no Jack/bulletproof/etc alive.

On May 08 2010 17:58 Foolishness wrote:
And oh, I also pushed for Zona to get modkilled. But I suppose the fact we both wanted him dead only strengthens your innocence and not mine. I'm just going to say now your "analysis" is probably going to include something along the lines of "See how Foolishness wanted to modkill Zona and Hobbes? He knew Zona was mia so he was just trying to fool us all into thinking he's innocent."

Am I right? Am I right? Am I right?

That was my devious plan from the beginning. Modkill my mafia buddy to prove me innocent. Not to mention modkill my PARDONER mafia buddy, who could save me from lynch. And now that I think about it, if I was mafia with him, we might actually have this game in the bag had he been alive. With a pardon, and 2 kills each night, I think we'd win no matter what (definitely need to double check the numbers, I'm too tired to do so).

So yes, I gave up a possible auto win to modkill my mafia buddy to try to prove my innocence, and hope to avoid 2 days' worth of lynches. You found out my plan. GG.

On May 08 2010 18:06 Qatol wrote:


Actually, there is a mistake in your analysis.
Here is what you said:
5 1 - mislynch
4 1 - mafia kill an innocent
3 1 - mislynch
2 1 - lynch ends the game? I see a missing night hit.

Town still only gets 2 lynches no matter who we lynch.

If you think my biggest strength was ever behavioral analysis, you seriously need to reread mafia 4. However, I still found Zona, didn't I?

Why have I been making those arguments on numbers? Well have they been wrong yet? Actually, they have been 100% correct so far. I said that the mafia likely didn't pick two of the same number. So far we have seen a [6][1], [8][1], and [12][1]. I said that after we found sidesprang and darth were mafia, JeeJee was cleared. Notice how he was pretty much instantly hit.


Pushing for Zona to be modkilled doesn't exactly get you anywhere. How would you look if you had been fighting against him getting modkilled? Especially if you had only been fighting against HIM and not Hobbes too? I don't think that really gets you anything either way. And a pardoner mafia buddy still can't pardon if he isn't around to do so. My analysis wasn't going to mention this at all, but thanks for highlighting that it does nothing for or against you.

But don't you worry. I have a real analysis coming on you.

On May 08 2010 18:25 Korynne wrote:
Uh Foolishness. There's 6 of us left. So after we lynch you we're left with 1 mafia and 4 townspeople.

Is this your slipup as mafia? xD As in, oh hey, if I die there's 5 townies left. xP