EPTLol thanks bro.
Pick Your Power Mafia! - Page 42
| Forum Index > TL Mafia |
|
L
Canada4732 Posts
Lol thanks bro. | ||
|
citi.zen
2509 Posts
Well if we have a mafia medic and a mafia jack on our hands, then I guess the mafia would know for sure that he was SK, bulletproof, or vet. What I think is more likely is that the mafia didn't know what was protecting Radfield from night hits. What they knew is that they took a shot at him and it was blocked. Then he turned around and found another one of their members. I'm not sure they shot him because they knew he was SK at all, they just didn't want him doing any more mafia hunting. I wasn't suggesting the mafia hit him because they knew he was SK - in fact they would not have done so, because of the bullet proof ability. I was wondering about Radfield's reaction afterwards - ie choosing to claim he was medic protected. At first I wasn't even sure he even got hit (someone had suggested maybe he held off on a hit and claimed the hit just to get more credibility) - but that seems wrong. Double stacking on Bill by chance could have happened too, but again, then there was little reason to claim. So Radfiled really did get hit by the mafia, and he killed Bill. Now, a pro-town player that gets hit would presumably announce it, so he had to say something if he wanted to try to remain undiscovered by the mafia. He could claim medic protection, veteran, or bullet-proof. All risky claims if there is someone else with that role around - and bullet proof makes people think of the SK anyway. So he went with the medic claim. As Foolishness said before, the "right call" would have been to state ambiguously that he "took a hit". | ||
|
Qatol
United States3165 Posts
On May 08 2010 03:30 citi.zen wrote: I wasn't suggesting the mafia hit him because they knew he was SK - in fact they would not have done so, because of the bullet proof ability. I was wondering about Radfield's reaction afterwards - ie choosing to claim he was medic protected. At first I wasn't even sure he even got hit (someone had suggested maybe he held off on a hit and claimed the hit just to get more credibility) - but that seems wrong. Double stacking on Bill by chance could have happened too, but again, then there was little reason to claim. So Radfiled really did get hit by the mafia, and he killed Bill. Now, a pro-town player that gets hit would presumably announce it, so he had to say something if he wanted to try to remain undiscovered by the mafia. He could claim medic protection, veteran, or bullet-proof. All risky claims if there is someone else with that role around - and bullet proof makes people think of the SK anyway. So he went with the medic claim. As Foolishness said before, the "right call" would have been to state ambiguously that he "took a hit". But that's exactly what I'm wondering about. What if he really WAS medic protected? Medic protection generally supercedes all other kinds except martyr, and if I were medic, he is the player I would have watched that night. As far as the "took a hit" claim goes - yes, that is almost always the right call in this situation. | ||
|
Foolishness
United States3044 Posts
On May 08 2010 04:21 Qatol wrote: But that's exactly what I'm wondering about. What if he really WAS medic protected? Medic protection generally supercedes all other kinds except martyr, and if I were medic, he is the player I would have watched that night. As far as the "took a hit" claim goes - yes, that is almost always the right call in this situation. At the same time, I feel like someone would have claimed medic at this point. Nearly everyone alive has been under heat from someone else or another (besides Hobbes, which is why he needs to die if he doesn't deliver), and from my perspective any of us could have claimed medic reasonably (i.e. Scamp has been under a lot of pressure, if he came out before day ended yesterday and said he was medic, it'd be believable because he doesn't want to die). That's my reasoning why I said we probably don't have a medic. At any rate it's probably best for us to just assume worst case scenario in that we don't have a medic. Making a plan and hoping for a medic save along the way is not the way to go. Yo guys, night is ~7 hours away from ending. We need a CompVig hit. If the votes so far stay the way they are it's going to be up to the CompVig's discretion to choose who to hit. And ya'll know who I want to hit. | ||
|
Qatol
United States3165 Posts
I think you should be hitting either Scamp or Zona (with my preference on Zona unless he speaks up). JeeJee voted Scamp. Several times. Citi.zen voted me. Scamp voted Hobbes. Does anyone else have a second choice? If I missed a vote, it wasn't in the last 4ish pages or it wasn't bolded. So anyone feel free to correct me. | ||
|
citi.zen
2509 Posts
| ||
|
Korynne
Canada990 Posts
Like I said I'm going to leave the hobbes+jeejee thing for now. If we have no leads, lynching jeejee tells us something about hobbes so I'm not worried about that "couple" for now. Someone should also perhaps analyze people's responses between when darth was to be lynched and when his mafia-ness was revealed. | ||
|
Foolishness
United States3044 Posts
On May 08 2010 05:39 Qatol wrote: I don't think you should be hitting Korynne. While she has been quiet, a mafia also just pushed pretty hard to get her lynched. That doesn't necessarily mean she is innocent (the mafia could be using this as a way to keep her out of the spotlight), but I think she just merits more watching right now. We can lynch her if her activity level doesn't increase. I think you should be hitting either Scamp or Zona (with my preference on Zona unless he speaks up). JeeJee voted Scamp. Several times. Citi.zen voted me. Scamp voted Hobbes. Does anyone else have a second choice? If I missed a vote, it wasn't in the last 4ish pages or it wasn't bolded. So anyone feel free to correct me. That's a good point about Korynne. Also, she claims to be green and have no role. If she were mafia with Darth, I think the mafia would have tried to push Korynne for lynch instead of Darth, since Darth would be more valuable to the mafia since he has a role. While this doesn't excuse her attitude, I guess they are notable points. Given's Zona recent inactivity, I'm totally cool hitting him. I'm skeptical about hitting Scamp though. I'd still choose Hobbes over these two guys. | ||
|
Korynne
Canada990 Posts
I think Scamp would be a good target... ##Compvig: Scamp## Also, no credit since the other target is essentially me. xD | ||
|
Scamp
United States1086 Posts
I'm honestly amused at the lack of a case against me yet people's willingness to seriously target me. | ||
flamewheel
FREEAGLELAND26780 Posts
In the embed she kind of looks like a man... | ||
|
d3_crescentia
United States4053 Posts
DUN DUN DUNNNNNN | ||
|
Scamp
United States1086 Posts
Compvigging me is a MAJOR mistake with a capital M. Throwing that out there last-second. | ||
|
Foolishness
United States3044 Posts
On May 08 2010 11:46 Scamp wrote: What the hell? No one is here? Compvigging me is a MAJOR mistake with a capital M. Throwing that out there last-second. That's what I said, but I'm in a very awkward situation here. | ||
|
Qatol
United States3165 Posts
| ||
|
Foolishness
United States3044 Posts
On May 08 2010 12:05 Qatol wrote: Ace, Hobbes hasn't posted in something like 2 days 6 hours. Zona hasn't posted in almost 2 days. Can we get a warning or something here? I like just killing them both. | ||
|
Ace
United States16096 Posts
On May 08 2010 12:05 Qatol wrote: Ace, Hobbes hasn't posted in something like 2 days 6 hours. Zona hasn't posted in almost 2 days. Can we get a warning or something here? Yea. Both of them have 3 hours after the Day starts to make a post. | ||
|
Ace
United States16096 Posts
Scamp (Pro Town Normal Doc) has been shot. JeeJee(Vanilla Towny)has been shot. With 8 alive, it is 5 to lynch! Day 4 ends at 11:00PM ET/12:00 KST(24 hours from now) | ||
|
Scamp
United States1086 Posts
Best of luck, town. | ||
|
~OpZ~
United States3652 Posts
I think the best way to go about picking out the mafia is to pick someone who picked one as their second number... Seems reasonable actually... | ||
| ||
