EPTTL Mafia XXII - Page 3
| Forum Index > TL Mafia |
|
Korynne
Canada990 Posts
| ||
|
Korynne
Canada990 Posts
Incognito claimed he took a hit, but there were 2 hits. | ||
|
Korynne
Canada990 Posts
Another night, another four people dead. DarthThienAn and Roffles were walking home from a late night job during the night, but simultaneously both were ambushed and went down in an instant. The next morning, the Town would find the bodies of DarthThienAn and Roffles lying at the foot of a prominent Liq Vegas casino. The other two Mafia targets put up a fight, but did not fare much better. I'm assuming the other two Mafia targets "fared better" since they didn't die? So that means 2 people didn't get hit no? I don't really think I fully understand the day post so correct me if I'm wrong. | ||
|
Korynne
Canada990 Posts
But they were targetted by the mafia as well? But then that means Incognito is falsely claiming a hit? I'm so confused. Dx | ||
|
Korynne
Canada990 Posts
Looks like we're slacking off now since we're done our double lynch early. (I have to blame myself too for that, kinda decided to give up on analyzing everyone because along with the other mafia game it just feels like too much time spent on mafia...) How about we all do the analyze the person below you thing? Except I went and used a random number generator (in case a mafia can always cover up another guy's tracks by just poorly analyzing them). So ANALYZE THE PERSON 16 DOWN FROM YOU (take your number, add 16, if it's greater than 19, subtract 19 from it. ex. I'm #11, 11+16 = 27, 27-19 = 8 so I analyze Scamp). Here's a list for reference (don't forget to analyze people's predecessors): Player List: 1. Zona -> BrownBear 2. d3_crescentia 3. KF91 4. Scaramanga 5. Bill Murray 6. Fishball 7. RaGe 8. Scamp 9. Ace 10. meeple 11. Fulgrim -> Korynne 12. Falcynn 13. nbtnbt5 14. IntoTheWow 15. Elemenope -> Incognito 16. nAi.PrOtOsS 17. Osmoses 18. motbob 19. madnessman Let's try to get some analysis done to help our blues! | ||
|
Korynne
Canada990 Posts
Level of Activity 16 posts total 3~4 "real" posts total TONS of fluffy What do you think of this? Oh what do you think of that? etc posts. Summary and Accusations: Warns lardygooser that he will lynch him if he continues to cry noob Generally agrees with the lynch inactive idea "Right now it's either Jpak or nothing. I don't agree with nothing so let's get a lynch." Analyzes Abenson (person below you deal) and concluded confused town/scum (aka no conclusion really...) Notes that people should stop getting distracted Notes that BM seems to have dropped the plan for no reason Questions BM again about why he abandoned his plan Says it seems like he was asked to explain why he thinks RaGe is suspicious, but then says it looks like d3 is supposed to do it so he won't until d3 does, unless Ace asks him to Claims to get "a really bad scumdar sense" from d3's posts Asks KF91 of his opinion on Motbob Asks Osmoses to explain why he thinks KF91 has been convincingly pro-town Asks Osmoses about his opinion on himself, Scara, and Fishball Asks BrownBear if he is preemptively defending himself Conclusion: Looks scummy to me or just really un-contributing. So what do you think? Oh what about you? Hey guys analyze me while you're at it. Etc etc. If townie, pretty useless. Unsupported scumdar of d3. Why would you want someone to just randomly analyze you? To take their time away from analyzing other mafia? Why are you grouping yourself with Scara and Fishball? Do you know that they're both townies and hope that if you're last on the lynch list you'll manage to slip by? Why did you ask BrownBear if he's preemptively defending himself? Do you know he's innocent and that he's accusing someone innocent so you're hoping he'll get lynched? But seriously, WHY DO YOU ASK SO MANY QUESTIONS??? Dx "Well gee I don't know, what do you guys think?" -paraphrased from Scamp | ||
|
Korynne
Canada990 Posts
I have no problems with questions being asked. My problem with you is that asking questions is all you seem to do! You have contributed very little of your own analysis. Instead of helping town by analyzing people much (you've done so once, because it was requested of everyone to analyze the person below you, and gave a very very vague he's either confused town or confused scum conclusion. Well gee, if you're not going to make a conclusion I guess you don't need to preemptively defend yourself against anything...) You say the analysis you request on yourself wasn't random, care to explain? I eagerly await your very detailed and well thought out analysis of Bill Murray. | ||
|
Korynne
Canada990 Posts
| ||
|
Korynne
Canada990 Posts
| ||
|
Korynne
Canada990 Posts
OK SERIOUSLY GUYS TIME FOR ANALYSIS!!! Please analyze the person you are supposed to. We don't have time for inactivity and messing around. | ||
|
Korynne
Canada990 Posts
After 24 hours anyone who has not responded will be put on the suspicious list. | ||
|
Korynne
Canada990 Posts
So Falcynn should analyze Ace's guy, which is Fishball. | ||
|
Korynne
Canada990 Posts
Like BM said, I would like to add Scamp to your list Incognito. I also propose double lynch, like always. Given now that Ace is gone, we're on our own. Everyone posts so infrequently that we might as well step it up and do double lynches. Double lynches means we get two actions per mafia one action (think lynch lynch instead of lynch [mafia kills 3 people] lynch). Instead of like omg we might kill another innocent townie, at least we'll be killing the more useless or scummy townies, with a 1/3 chance of them being mafia. Whereas when mafia kills, it's up to 3 people and they're definitely going to be townies. So seeing as our yay let's just wait for Ace to turn something up every night route is gone, we should work twice as hard, and therefore lynch twice as many people. | ||
|
Korynne
Canada990 Posts
Scara's last post smells like scum. Why? I think stacking Ace is a big waste of mafia KP. If they stack Ace, that's -1 T, and without the 100% confirmed lynch we might have a 33% chance? So that's like -1.33T (-1 T - .33M - .66T = -1.33T). Whereas if they killed 3 random townies that's -2.5T at least (given that medics might randomly protect them), with Ace having say 100% chance of catching someone (since he talks about it in here, maybe mafia thought he would for sure catch someone). So that's -1.5T (-2.5T - 1 M) at least. I am inclined to believe that this was a dumb idea by Mafia, and Scara seems to think it was a good idea and would have executed it. | ||
|
Korynne
Canada990 Posts
Please post your analysis on your designated person, if you decline to do so, please give a reason (claiming newb is not a reason, just do your best job). | ||
|
Korynne
Canada990 Posts
On April 27 2010 18:13 meeple wrote: Yearg... you really love to put all the emphasis out there with caps and bolds on all your important parts... god forbid you learn how to use colours  ... These types of things were a nice contribution... Before now, it's mainly thoughts about stuff that's already happened and now she's being proactive and forming plans and putting forward ideas. (Do I smell a math major?) You should go find my first post, it had lots of spoilers and quotes in it. =D And yes, I'm a math major. >_> On a serious note, I'm not convinced that Scara is town, but I'm convinced that he's useless enough to leave alone for now. | ||
|
Korynne
Canada990 Posts
So it's a good forgery, if nothing else. xD | ||
|
Korynne
Canada990 Posts
| ||
|
Korynne
Canada990 Posts
| ||
|
Korynne
Canada990 Posts
On April 28 2010 14:42 meeple wrote: Ah there will be some tell... unless the mafia double up hits on someone... a missing mafia hit will mean either a medic or a veteran took it. But you're right.. the mafia don't really want to hit him now... since it will be an expensive kill. erg I mean it's a good role to claim in that after he claims and is not killed anytime at night, he can just claim it would not be in mafia's interest to kill someone takes twice the effort to kill. So if you're mafia and your last ditch effort is roleclaim, what do you do? -You claim any active role, you get lynched if you can't perform whatever action at night. -You claim townie well everyone does that, and besides what do you say when you're not killed at night (mafia certainly would prefer to target more confirmed townies than the suspicious looking ones) -You claim veteran, you can't do anything to actively confirm your role, mafia wouldn't want to hit you because a) that confirms your role b) you take 2 hits to kill, surely there are 2 better choices for townies. So this is something to take into consideration when voting with this new BB roleclaim in mind. | ||
| ||
