|
On January 04 2008 15:42 oneofthem wrote:Show nested quote +On January 04 2008 13:14 Mindcrime wrote:On January 04 2008 12:42 triangle wrote: Are you even trying to understand what Oneofthem is saying?
You cite two liberal originalists, compared to virtually all of the others who are conservative.
Every originalist (or originalist leaning) judge on the SC was appointed by a republican, and all are intensely conservative. The right tends to favor originalism so originalism is a right wing position. Got it. It's a stupid argument. Suppose that the right tended to like pie more than the left. Would that make pie something to be considered right-wing? No, of course not. That's ridiculous. Pie is neutral. EDIT: I'm sort of loathing myself right now. "Left" and "Right" are not terms that anyone should use in any political sense. except the preference for pie is nto a political matter. if pie lovers prefer also pancakes overwhelmingly, one could be forgiven for drawing some analysis between pie and pancakes that are relevant to our interests in food. say, pancakes and pies are both pie foods, or that they are western. if a group of people having a particular taste of politics have preferences for something that is, let's say, not political, but having political consequences, perhaps they are doing so because they care about the political aspects. surely you see that seemingly unrelated fields are conceptually tied. yea sure, originalism treats the courts instrumentally, as neutral as it can be when it comes to its stated aims. but, politics is not all about legal interpretations, rather, interpretations have effects on society and such, and presumably people who are motivated for a particular social order would gravitate toward a habit of dealing with the constitution that accords with their political aims. now, look out, im making an intentionally disingenuous question! are you suggesting that the many rightwingers are merely championing originalism because of abstract legal arguments?
Conservatives are championing originalism because the alternative to the various forms of originalism has lead to many judicial decisions that they disagree with. They have a motive. They have a reason for supporting a certain brand of originalism.
But this is irrelevant.
now, since you seem like a fellow who is concerned about that legal argumetn in abstraction, do you mind if, a bunch of rightwinger cranks latch onto your position for political reasons, even to the extent of founding a well publicised party with a capital C in constitution, and as a consequence your position is seen as rightwing by political observers? if you do, who to blame seems a matter worthy of some reflection.
The Constitution Party supports (or claims to support) an interpretation of the Constitution that reflects the original intent of the framers. There is nothing wrong with that. What is wrong is that they take an ultra conservative position on any subject that is not covered, or not covered clearly in the Constitutiion. And sometimes, they are just plain wrong about the original intent of the Founders. Their stated reasons for opposing the 16th amendment don't mesh with their support of an intentualist reading of the Constitution either. The framers knew that things would change and allowed for that. The Constitution party wants nothing to do with that original intent.
In short, it doesn't bother me that those nutjobs support intentualism, what bothers me is that their brand of intentualism is just plain wrong.
|
On January 05 2008 01:06 a-game wrote: i thought hillary was more electable too, but obama has won a very white state in iowa and i also checked the polls that pit democrats against republicans and obama had wider margins against every republican...
plus he gave a great speech last night. i'm starting to believe he could win a national election, just maybe. all eyes on N.H. for sure.
Would you recommend watching it? I didn't catch it :o
|
On January 05 2008 01:28 Servolisk wrote:Show nested quote +On January 05 2008 01:06 a-game wrote: i thought hillary was more electable too, but obama has won a very white state in iowa and i also checked the polls that pit democrats against republicans and obama had wider margins against every republican...
plus he gave a great speech last night. i'm starting to believe he could win a national election, just maybe. all eyes on N.H. for sure. Would you recommend watching it? I didn't catch it :o I watched it too when they replayed it this morning, and it was actually pretty good.
|
im just genuinely scared that huckabee won =[
does anyone think that the republicans could possibly win this election in the fall?
|
On January 05 2008 01:42 Hawk wrote: im just genuinely scared that huckabee won =[
does anyone think that the republicans could possibly win this election in the fall?
I heard that Huckabee is pretty behind in the other states 
It's possible the Republicans could win, I think they are underdogs for right now. Who knows what will change.
|
HUCKABEE?
LOL
THE MENTALLY RETARDED OF THE UNITED STATES, COME ON... YOU CAN VOTE BETTER THAN THAT.
i had to use caps, its the only way i can correctly describe my feelings
|
YOU'VE BEEN VOTING BUSH! TWICE!
LOL
btw fuck Iowa
|
Huckabee's support came from the large amount of evangelicals in Iowa iirc. You know, the people who lobby to bring about armageddon, so they get beamed up to heaven and watch from above as the rest of us writhe in flames or whatever... the people who want creationism in school...
I've heard New Hampshire's republicans are libertarian, so Ron Paul probably has a better chance in New Hampshire than Huckabee.
|
entrance polls had 68% of voters were satisfied with bush's job 61% considered religion a major factor in their choice..
what a weird state..speaking of mike huckabee,what if..
|
On January 05 2008 03:36 z7-TranCe wrote:entrance polls had 68% of voters were satisfied with bush's job 61% considered religion a major factor in their choice.. what a weird state..speaking of mike huckabee,what if..
rofl
|
If Huckabee becomes the Republican candidate I'm going to lol. If Huckabee becomes the President I'm moving.
|
On January 05 2008 05:35 mahnini wrote: If Huckabee becomes the Republican candidate I'm going to lol. If Huckabee becomes the President I'm moving.
This sums up my thoughts nicely as well.
I was about to strangle my dad today. He's democrat, and I can remember the last time that he voted for a republican, but he told me that he thinks Huckabee isn't 'that bad' and that he's not a religious whacko.
>.<
|
People like Huckabee are the exact reason that the Founding Fathers tried to keep "the people" as far away from the election of the president as they could.
|
Religion and politics don't mix. Ever.
I swear the day that our public schools start teaching intelligent design arhghadhfashdf
|
Cayman Islands24199 Posts
On January 05 2008 01:07 Mindcrime wrote: Conservatives are championing originalism because the alternative to the various forms of originalism has lead to many judicial decisions that they disagree with. They have a motive. They have a reason for supporting a certain brand of originalism.
But this is irrelevant. then we can say at least for the present, originalism has conservative political implications. talking about the theory itself would seem to make this irrelevant, but talking about picking a particular legal position as a political move, originalism has some niceties for rightwingers.
In short, it doesn't bother me that those nutjobs support intentualism, what bothers me is that their brand of intentualism is just plain wrong. great, but see, someone like me doesn't really care for the constitution, so i see little merit in arguing about it in the first place. in any case, paul seems to share some nutty ideas on the constitution.
of course, the people can go suck it. legislatures mess things up etc etc.
|
Can any of the Obama supporters explain why he would be a good president? He has pretty much the exact same stance on every issue as Edwards and HIllary.
|
On January 04 2008 11:45 IdrA wrote:Show nested quote +On January 04 2008 11:31 Try wrote: Dude Huckabee isn't that bad, he's quite liberal when it comes to foreign policy and domestic issues, and doesn't really support the war in Iraq. Its just some maniac supporters of him that make him sound crazy, just like some maniac supporters of Hillary or Obama (omfg Oprah). ... what? he supports the war and he is about as conservative as it comes on every social issue. hes against abortion, against any kind of gay rights, and all of the other shit that comes with being an evangelical nutjob.
He's actually right. Huckabee sounds a lot like Edwards. He rails against "corporate profit" and free trade agreements. On net, Huckabee increased state taxes by more than $500 million, and has supported numerous other federal spending stances.
Romney is pretty big spending as well. I really don't want either of them to win the repub nomination.
|
On January 05 2008 07:42 shmay wrote: Can any of the Obama supporters explain why he would be a good president? He has pretty much the exact same stance on every issue as Edwards and HIllary. I don't know much about this... but, Hillary wants to continue the Iraq war -> lol ban & ggnore pls.
|
On January 05 2008 07:49 shmay wrote:Show nested quote +On January 04 2008 11:45 IdrA wrote:On January 04 2008 11:31 Try wrote: Dude Huckabee isn't that bad, he's quite liberal when it comes to foreign policy and domestic issues, and doesn't really support the war in Iraq. Its just some maniac supporters of him that make him sound crazy, just like some maniac supporters of Hillary or Obama (omfg Oprah). ... what? he supports the war and he is about as conservative as it comes on every social issue. hes against abortion, against any kind of gay rights, and all of the other shit that comes with being an evangelical nutjob. He's actually right. Huckabee sounds a lot like Edwards. He rails against "corporate profit" and free trade agreements. On net, Huckabee increased state taxes by more than $500 million, and has supported numerous other federal spending stances. Romney is pretty big spending as well. I really don't want either of them to win the repub nomination. hes not right, he does support the war and is hardcore conservative on social issues, even if he is more economically liberal.
|
well in one sense he was right. but any way you cut it he's a piece of shit.
|
|
|
|
|
|