|
since you bothered to separate out legal from economic and property related matters, it is interesting then that you forego such a distinction here. if the law is regarding things such as material possessions and activities we term economic, what is the need to stress the legal angle? if the legal discrimination is economic, great, let us rejoice in an agreement.
Because the means of effective exploitation are legal, nor economic. It's the difference between my forcing you to drink sewage because I say so, and your being forced to drink sewage because you're locked in a sewer.
exploitation is not tied to coercion, but to the concept of fair and proper behavior or relations. but in any case, smacking around naive agency theory gets boring, so i suggest you acquaint yourself with elementary problems such as distributive justice or power relations. but perhaps you think various forcefully and coercively enforced conditions that limit the options available to people are detached from their lives.
You have no argument here apart from attempting to establish a theoretical framework. Lacking is not only a description of proper moral acts, but their political/legal security. "Forcefully and coercively enforced conditions" is a blueprint for calling any system an unfree one, including more or less free ones, and without specific charges, further lends the tendency of unremitting whining. These kinds of opinions, if given practical application, are more forceful and coercisive than any which they criticize.
it is not an ambition, it is the view that gives rise to ambition. an idealistic vision that has among its virtues motivation. the argument is not that such a functionary ambition is not good, it is very important, but that the situation as traditionally envisioned is false and prevents or discourages inquiry into change
So what. The reasons for which most people live their lives are "false" under this criteria. Give people another challenge of transcendence and they retreat into another ideal. Of course the intellectual feels it his duty to point out the flaws of their perspective, since he is immune to their irrationalities. Unfortunately, whiners also suffer from a false raison d'etre, and end up becoming a caricature of the very human nature they attempt to exorcise from the ignorant.
but still, iti s your problem when you try to reduce away a normative assertion to a neutral one
I never made any assertions in the quoted paragraph. I was lampooning your opinions.
suppose for the first 10 turns the b nation is resticted legally from doing certain things, then on the 11th turn they are 'emancipated.' do you then say the players of team b are treated justly.
At least here you're giving a thought-experiment a try. No, in this scenario for team b to be treated fairly, conditions would have to revert back to the original rules laid out which gave a and b equal chances. However by comparing life to a game you're assuming that the goals of every player converge on the same point, that the means of achieving them are largely the same, and that constitutes the definition of "fairness." Your definition of both goals and means are therefore arbitrary and you base your intuitions of fairness on what is only personal. If a 5 year-old cannot compete with a 10-year old in a foot race, you would discourage him from making the attempt fairly, and rigging the contest to give him equal chances for victory. By doing so you not only stunt his competitive growth but you now become an arbitrary odds maker, given moral authority over those who are unable to regulate what is fair for themselves.
i was talking about CONSTITUTIONAL ORIGINALISM, which has a quaint tendency to sanctify a certain reactionary interpretation fo the constitution and its place in society and government. it is something some people did. should we become shamans for some imaginary 'founding fathers' and ignore the amount of progress and changing conditions since. apparently ron paul has the illusion.
This is meaningless. The rhetoric of progress has no value, is arbitrary, and generally proceeds from an ignorance of history. The founding fathers, Montesquieuian and Burkean political theory, Tocqueville and the successive amendments of the constitution are "imaginary" in the modern American mythology largely because of ignorance of past intellectual achievement, narrow views, and a contempt for the limitations of human reason. There has hardly been an innovation in the constitutional order, from to the abolition of the original electoral college to the party system which has been progressive to the country's political interest.
The promoters of progress are often dictators of opinion masked in the facade of moral authority.
|
On January 04 2008 12:42 triangle wrote: Are you even trying to understand what Oneofthem is saying?
You cite two liberal originalists, compared to virtually all of the others who are conservative.
Every originalist (or originalist leaning) judge on the SC was appointed by a republican, and all are intensely conservative.
The right tends to favor originalism so originalism is a right wing position.
Got it.
It's a stupid argument.
Suppose that the right tended to like pie more than the left. Would that make pie something to be considered right-wing? No, of course not. That's ridiculous. Pie is neutral.
EDIT: I'm sort of loathing myself right now. "Left" and "Right" are not terms that anyone should use in any political sense.
|
i like pie <3
and Obama's speech was fucking amazing.!
|
Huckabee picked up on unexpected momentum there; he beat Romney by scores larger than anyone has predicted. Iowa is two-thirds evangelical and over one-third rural, giving Huckabee and Edwards good results by comparison.
-Edwards is badly hurt -Obama and Clinton are converging at this stage -Huckabee survives and becomes a contender, but faces enormous problems with most other states -Romney is weakened but not out. He'll come close to dropping when he loses in NH though -McCain isn't much affected, given a slight boost for NH -Giuliani is going to lose his lead if he keeps polling like this, he can't afford to wait for the Super Tuesday and nab single digits until then -Paul made no breakthroughs here, but not hurt either. He is likely to continue his momentum at a moderate pace
I also offer a moment of silence for Kucinich and Gravel, who polled 0%.
|
Obama has shocked me with his large win in Iowa. This is awesome, I really think he can pull it off, and I think if only all the Clinton supporters would vote him president, he will win.
|
And a last note of interest, how accurate were the opinion polls for Iowa? Fairly accurate, one must admit:
American Research Group Poll - Zogby International Poll - Actual Results
Mike Huckabee: 29 - 31 - 34 Mitt Romney: 24 - 25 - 25 Fred Thompson: 13 - 11 - 13 John McCain: 11 - 10 - 13 Ron Paul: 6 - 10 - 10 Rudy Giuliani: 10 - 8 - 3 Duncan Hunter: 4 - 1 - 0
Barack Obama: 25 - 31 - 37 John Edwards: 21 - 27 - 30 Hillary Clinton: 34 - 24 - 29 Bill Richardson: 6 - 7 - 2 Joe Biden: 8 - 5 - 1
All minor candidates lost badly.
|
Pie is neutral. Originalism isn't...
You cannot compare political preference's effect on judicial philosophy to (nonexistant) effects on food. Comparing Originalism to pie is silly.
You acknowledge correlation but deny causation? Why?
There has hardly been an innovation in the constitutional order, from to the abolition of the original electoral college to the party system which has been progressive to the country's political interest. What do you mean?
All minor candidates lost badly.-- On the dems side, that is because of the nature of Caucus rules, so that's hardly surprising.
Giuliani bombing is somewhat surprising though.
|
On January 04 2008 13:50 triangle wrote:Originalism isn't... You cannot compare political preference's effect on judicial philosophy to (nonexistant) effects on food. Comparing Originalism to pie is silly. You acknowledge correlation but deny causation? Why?
Originalism is neutral. That there are more visible conservative originalists than visible liberal originalists means nothing.
To prove my point: try contrasting the beliefs and conclusions of Akhil Reed Amar with those of Justice Scalia. And then compare their methods. Their methods, their textual application of originalism, are nearly identical.
Show nested quote +There has hardly been an innovation in the constitutional order, from to the abolition of the original electoral college to the party system which has been progressive to the country's political interest. What do you mean? All minor candidates lost badly.-- On the dems side, that is because of the nature of Caucus rules, so that's hardly surprising. Giuliani bombing is somewhat surprising though.
Giuliani doing poorly in Iowa is not surprising at all.
|
Sorry if this has been said, but...
OBAMA TAKES IOWAAAAA WOOOOT
|
Quite happy with Dr. Paul's result. Was neck and neck with McCain and Thompson for 3rd. Fringe candidate and unelectable? Hardly.
Looking forward to New Hampshire. =)
|
yea tonight was a good night.
gogo obama ranger!
IN SPACE
|
On January 04 2008 13:50 triangle wrote:Giuliani bombing is somewhat surprising though.
Considering he wasn't even Iowa, not really.
|
now we see if obama can take N.H.
|
Yeah Obama's speech was like a Lincoln/MLK trip.
|
Cayman Islands24199 Posts
Because the means of effective exploitation are legal, nor economic. It's the difference between my forcing you to drink sewage because I say so, and your being forced to drink sewage because you're locked in a sewer.
that's cute. the sewer is obviously naturally existing and of course, we cannot criticise the sewer. just like a sewer, which is naturally existing and inanimate, the economic system is naturally existing, operated by the hand of nature, and impervious to human rules like these silly laws that we keep talking about. everyone knows that if an exploitation is described as through legal means, it cannot be economic in nature.
You have no argument here apart from attempting to establish a theoretical framework. Lacking is not only a description of proper moral acts, but their political/legal security. "Forcefully and coercively enforced conditions" is a blueprint for calling any system an unfree one, including more or less free ones, and without specific charges, further lends the tendency of unremitting whining. These kinds of opinions, if given practical application, are more forceful and coercisive than any which they criticize. an elaborate positive exposition is not needed since the social concern is assumed to be the standard of respectability. feel free to lower yourself beyond a discussable level. of course, that i did not choose to elaborate on the positive normative groundings in the space of this thread does not mean i do not have them. you on the other hand stand impervious to any consideration of the originally limited point and attempt to drag the whole earth into this rather trivial 'argument.' please make an outline or something to assist you in locating the argument.
So what. The reasons for which most people live their lives are "false" under this criteria. Give people another challenge of transcendence and they retreat into another ideal. Of course the intellectual feels it his duty to point out the flaws of their perspective, since he is immune to their irrationalities. Unfortunately, whiners also suffer from a false raison d'etre, and end up becoming a caricature of the very human nature they attempt to exorcise from the ignorant.
their reasons are not false, it is what is lacking in terms of positive actiona nd commitments that is the problem. to better their lives and such is not objectionable, the problem is simply that envisioning a present and existing utopia limits our scope of reflection. this is not whining. rather, you are whining about the predominant concern for 'intellectuals' anyway, ever applied that analysis to yourself? do you want to caricature yourself? there are many tantalizing options from which to choose.
Show nested quote +but still, iti s your problem when you try to reduce away a normative assertion to a neutral one I never made any assertions in the quoted paragraph. I was lampooning your opinions. obviously then, the described gesture of yours occurred outside of the quoted paragraph. it may be your impression that 'my opinions' is vulgar protest against inequality, but sadly this si your own problem.
At least here you're giving a thought-experiment a try. No, in this scenario for team b to be treated fairly, conditions would have to revert back to the original rules laid out which gave a and b equal chances. irrelevant. whether the original players of b played to a certain state of affairs, or the next player of b is given that state of affairs by the machine is irrelevant to the player. the point is, the state of affairs, i.e. economic and material conditions, is important, and this is a product of history.
However by comparing life to a game you're assuming that the goals of every player converge on the same point, that the means of achieving them are largely the same, and that constitutes the definition of "fairness." Your definition of both goals and means are therefore arbitrary and you base your intuitions of fairness on what is only personal. If a 5 year-old cannot compete with a 10-year old in a foot race, you would discourage him from making the attempt fairly, and rigging the contest to give him equal chances for victory. By doing so you not only stunt his competitive growth but you now become an arbitrary odds maker, given moral authority over those who are unable to regulate what is fair for themselves. i am amazed at this. you drew a whole life lesson from a silly charge. we are not comparing life to a game i.e. deflationary reduction, we are drawing analogy to shed light on some aspects of life. whether this si done by a simple formal analysis or an analogy is irrelevant.
Show nested quote +i was talking about CONSTITUTIONAL ORIGINALISM, which has a quaint tendency to sanctify a certain reactionary interpretation fo the constitution and its place in society and government. it is something some people did. should we become shamans for some imaginary 'founding fathers' and ignore the amount of progress and changing conditions since. apparently ron paul has the illusion. This is meaningless. The rhetoric of progress has no value, is arbitrary, and generally proceeds from an ignorance of history. The founding fathers, Montesquieuian and Burkean political theory, Tocqueville and the successive amendments of the constitution are "imaginary" in the modern American mythology largely because of ignorance of past intellectual achievement, narrow views, and a contempt for the limitations of human reason. There has hardly been an innovation in the constitutional order, from to the abolition of the original electoral college to the party system which has been progressive to the country's political interest. the word is used for rhetorical and thematic effect. revive the dead word to draw some energy from a historical movement and aspiration. this is a rather common gesture. there is no need to type so much if you have nothing to say, and stop treating this so seriously if you are not approaching the question seriously.
The promoters of progress are often dictators of opinion masked in the facade of moral authority. obligatory
|
Cayman Islands24199 Posts
On January 04 2008 13:14 Mindcrime wrote:Show nested quote +On January 04 2008 12:42 triangle wrote: Are you even trying to understand what Oneofthem is saying?
You cite two liberal originalists, compared to virtually all of the others who are conservative.
Every originalist (or originalist leaning) judge on the SC was appointed by a republican, and all are intensely conservative. The right tends to favor originalism so originalism is a right wing position. Got it. It's a stupid argument. Suppose that the right tended to like pie more than the left. Would that make pie something to be considered right-wing? No, of course not. That's ridiculous. Pie is neutral. EDIT: I'm sort of loathing myself right now. "Left" and "Right" are not terms that anyone should use in any political sense. except the preference for pie is nto a political matter. if pie lovers prefer also pancakes overwhelmingly, one could be forgiven for drawing some analysis between pie and pancakes that are relevant to our interests in food. say, pancakes and pies are both pie foods, or that they are western. if a group of people having a particular taste of politics have preferences for something that is, let's say, not political, but having political consequences, perhaps they are doing so because they care about the political aspects. surely you see that seemingly unrelated fields are conceptually tied.
yea sure, originalism treats the courts instrumentally, as neutral as it can be when it comes to its stated aims. but, politics is not all about legal interpretations, rather, interpretations have effects on society and such, and presumably people who are motivated for a particular social order would gravitate toward a habit of dealing with the constitution that accords with their political aims. now, look out, im making an intentionally disingenuous question! are you suggesting that the many rightwingers are merely championing originalism because of abstract legal arguments?
now, since you seem like a fellow who is concerned about that legal argumetn in abstraction, do you mind if, a bunch of rightwinger cranks latch onto your position for political reasons, even to the extent of founding a well publicised party with a capital C in constitution, and as a consequence your position is seen as rightwing by political observers? if you do, who to blame seems a matter worthy of some reflection.
|
Obama baby~!~!~!
Thank god.
|
Cayman Islands24199 Posts
im so jaded by politiks that i was rooting for hillary. hillary will win the national votes and then dealing with the internal movements is easier than dealing with a republican, certainly. the question of electability is really important nowadays. sigh
|
why can't bush serve for 3 terms, god
|
i thought hillary was more electable too, but obama has won a very white state in iowa and i also checked the polls that pit democrats against republicans and obama had wider margins against every republican...
plus he gave a great speech last night. i'm starting to believe he could win a national election, just maybe. all eyes on N.H. for sure.
|
|
|
|
|
|