|
On January 04 2008 11:53 azndsh wrote: Just because you don't support Ron Paul's views does not equate with not supporting the Constitution. Perhaps not with a literal interpretation of the Constitution, but you still support it.
Like how the majority of Christians don't support a literal interpretation of the Bible doesn't mean they don't support the Bible.
Your argument fails.
I never made such an argument. I asked the question because I sensed a certain amount of contempt for the Constitution in the post that I was responding to.
|
Cayman Islands24199 Posts
i was talking about CONSTITUTIONAL ORIGINALISM, which has a quaint tendency to sanctify a certain reactionary interpretation fo the constitution and its place in society and government. it is something some people did. should we become shamans for some imaginary 'founding fathers' and ignore the amount of progress and changing conditions since. apparently ron paul has the illusion.
|
If by "contempt for the Constitution", you really meant "contempt for Ron Paul's use of the Constitution as rules for how the country should be run 250 years later", then yes. I think we just had two completely different interpretations of his blatant parodying of Ron Paul supporters.
forget everything I said in that case
|
|
|
OBAMA THIRTY SEVEN PERCENT
|
On January 04 2008 11:57 oneofthem wrote: i was talking about CONSTITUTIONAL ORIGINALISM, which has a quaint tendency to sanctify a certain reactionary interpretation fo the constitution and its place in society and government. it is something some people did. should we become shamans for some imaginary 'founding fathers' and ignore the amount of progress and changing conditions since. apparently ron paul has the illusion.
You're equating originalism with conservatism. Stop it. If you want to argue against conservatism then argue against conservatism.
|
All the major news networks have projected Obama and Huckabee as the winners of their respective contests.
Obama 37 Edwards 30 Clinton 30 (slightly less than Edwards)
Huckabee 34 Romney 25 Thompson 14 McCain 12
|
Cayman Islands24199 Posts
On January 04 2008 12:04 Mindcrime wrote:Show nested quote +On January 04 2008 11:57 oneofthem wrote: i was talking about CONSTITUTIONAL ORIGINALISM, which has a quaint tendency to sanctify a certain reactionary interpretation fo the constitution and its place in society and government. it is something some people did. should we become shamans for some imaginary 'founding fathers' and ignore the amount of progress and changing conditions since. apparently ron paul has the illusion. You're equating originalism with conservatism. Stop it. If you want to argue against conservatism then argue against conservatism. i am not arguing for anything but a classification. it si pretty obvious that originalism is a rightwing position and a reactionary gesture.
|
I don't understand the hate for originalism. Originalism is not conservatism. Originalism does not make any statement about what the Constitution ought to say. It is simply a way to interpret what the Constitution does say. Originalism, in its various forms, is the most logical and well-founded way of doing that.
Again, originalism is not equivalent to change-hating conservatism. The Constitution is not written as an unchangeable document. As written, it can be changed through legislative processes.
|
Cayman Islands24199 Posts
originalism is founded on the desire for legitimacy of government. it is a well appreciated attitude, but let's move on now. surely we care about justice and good government more than abstract theories of legitimacy taht are themselves nonneutral. anyway, looking at the law from within law is obviously constrained. look at the sociology of law. even if you arrive at a position that favors firmness and powerlessness of the thing, you wont do so with some vague axioms. we could analyse the peculiar mentalities that result from such an outlook, but i dont think it will be productive here.
|
Edit--nevermind, let's move on.
Big night for Obama!
|
On January 04 2008 10:20 Jibba wrote:Show nested quote +From Nutjobhuckabee's forum:
IF WE IS GONNA BE TAKEN OUT IN WAR... THEN BRING IT ON...
JESUS IS COMING BACK@@@@
VOTE HUCK 2008 FOR JESUS TO COME BACK FIRST WE GET RID OF THE USA + RE PLACE WITH THE CSA (CHRISTIAN STATES OF AMERICA)
Logged
READ MY WEB SIGHT 2007RAPTURE.COM NOW AND I SHARE THE DOOM THAT god N jesus WILL BRING UPON THE WORLD UNTIL YOU VOTE FOR HUCKABEE TO BE KING OF AMERICA IN 2008. AD MY DREAM FROM god CCUM TRUE WE WILL BE THE LAST HUMENS BE4 JESUS RETURN FROM THE HELL TO SAVE AMERICA WORLD FROM SATAN PREY FOR IT NOW ... eh u dont realize that 50 % of the posts are made by non-huckabee supporters who mock him? i hate this trolls on presidential forums
|
On January 04 2008 12:10 oneofthem wrote:Show nested quote +On January 04 2008 12:04 Mindcrime wrote:On January 04 2008 11:57 oneofthem wrote: i was talking about CONSTITUTIONAL ORIGINALISM, which has a quaint tendency to sanctify a certain reactionary interpretation fo the constitution and its place in society and government. it is something some people did. should we become shamans for some imaginary 'founding fathers' and ignore the amount of progress and changing conditions since. apparently ron paul has the illusion. You're equating originalism with conservatism. Stop it. If you want to argue against conservatism then argue against conservatism. i am not arguing for anything but a classification. it si pretty obvious that originalism is a rightwing position and a reactionary gesture.
Justice Hugo Black and Dr. Akhil Reed Amar disagree.
|
|
|
Cayman Islands24199 Posts
On January 04 2008 12:29 Mindcrime wrote:Show nested quote +On January 04 2008 12:10 oneofthem wrote:On January 04 2008 12:04 Mindcrime wrote:On January 04 2008 11:57 oneofthem wrote: i was talking about CONSTITUTIONAL ORIGINALISM, which has a quaint tendency to sanctify a certain reactionary interpretation fo the constitution and its place in society and government. it is something some people did. should we become shamans for some imaginary 'founding fathers' and ignore the amount of progress and changing conditions since. apparently ron paul has the illusion. You're equating originalism with conservatism. Stop it. If you want to argue against conservatism then argue against conservatism. i am not arguing for anything but a classification. it si pretty obvious that originalism is a rightwing position and a reactionary gesture. Justice Hugo Black and Dr. Akhil Reed Amar disagree. and there are marxist libertarians.
but please drop it. my internets is not good.
|
Chris Dodd just dropped out. Ron Paul did score some votes but didn't get any mention. Glad that frigid bitch Clinton got 3rd.
|
On January 04 2008 12:32 oneofthem wrote:Show nested quote +On January 04 2008 12:29 Mindcrime wrote:On January 04 2008 12:10 oneofthem wrote:On January 04 2008 12:04 Mindcrime wrote:On January 04 2008 11:57 oneofthem wrote: i was talking about CONSTITUTIONAL ORIGINALISM, which has a quaint tendency to sanctify a certain reactionary interpretation fo the constitution and its place in society and government. it is something some people did. should we become shamans for some imaginary 'founding fathers' and ignore the amount of progress and changing conditions since. apparently ron paul has the illusion. You're equating originalism with conservatism. Stop it. If you want to argue against conservatism then argue against conservatism. i am not arguing for anything but a classification. it si pretty obvious that originalism is a rightwing position and a reactionary gesture. Justice Hugo Black and Dr. Akhil Reed Amar disagree. and there are marxist libertarians. but please drop it. my internets is not good.
So originalism is a right wing movement because marxist libertarians exist? Come on, you can do better than that.
|
Cayman Islands24199 Posts
it is rightwing because rightwingers are originalists. but really, i can't see much potential in this quaint idea to the way of social progress and such. since we are trying to locate people based on their ideas, as opposed to locating the ideas, a simple consideration for why people believe in certain ideas is enough. in this view, it is rightwing and reactionary to get attached to traditional set-ups.
anyway, back on topic, back back
|
Are you even trying to understand what Oneofthem is saying?
You cite two liberal originalists, compared to virtually all of the others who are conservative.
Every originalist (or originalist leaning) judge on the SC was appointed by a republican, and all are intensely conservative.
|
Women love black men. Polls, yet again, bear that out.
|
|
|
|
|
|