Blue horse/shield all the way....but it doesn't look like it's going to win. I really don't want to wear the jellycat logo in public so please people vote for blue horse/shield.
edit: I just saw that the current pic for the horse/shield was not there originally, so I vote we redo the poll between that and the jellycat logo. (maybe skull included too).
Really I agree with you guys that
jellycat: insider shirt. nice to people who go to tl.net to everyone else looks retarded. I personally will not buy one of those.
horse/shield: looks almost like a brand shirt that a designer made. It's difficult to tell that it's a starcraft shirt and you could wear it in public without many questions.
On July 06 2007 16:58 CharlieMurphy wrote: You guys' justification of the pony is fubar.
I don't think it has anything to do with the pony. The scarf looks like it's drawn on with a magic marker now that it's solid.
Even if you like the pony, the modest duplication of the design that we'de have to go with is too much of a sacrifice. I'm surprised so many people are in support of it in that overly simplified state.
You guys realize that we actually expect you to buy these shirts right?
Seems to me we've got a bunch of people voting based on aligence and group think, rather than what they would actually be willing to PAY to get. Whether you agree with Charlie Murphy or not, at least he intends to buy one.
Can we do that though? I thought the reason the pic was editted was because the flags were too small to be printed on a shirt.
EDIT: Also, the SC units need to be editted out and replaced with different shapes or grass or something. That was the reason the other design got disqualified.
horse/shield: looks almost like a brand shirt that a designer made. It's difficult to tell that it's a starcraft shirt and you could wear it in public without many questions.
Horse/Shield FTW
You guys are so insecure.
This is a STARCRAFT forum, if you are ashamed of telling other people that you are/were a Starcraft nerd, so be it, don't buy and wear the shirt.
Also, the point of having a poll is so that the majority of the people get what they want, if you are not in the majority, too bad so sad.
btw all the votes that aren't for the top 2 shirts are basically wasted.
Hello? Wtf does this sentence even mean? Do you not know how a public poll works?
I think we should do a re-vote with the top 2 shirts as the only choices.
Or we just go with the winning vote?
There is gonna be a lot of unhappy people with the pony choice,
Random generalization.
if you add all the votes from every shirt that isn't the pony its pretty damn close too.
Again, WTF? Refer to my first comment.
The way I see it the pony shirt wearers will wear just about anything so it doesn't matter if their shirt loses. On the other hand, All the pony haters will settle for anything but that. Everyone makes a sacrafice and we settle on the compromise.
The way I see it the pony shirt wearers will wear just about anything so it doesn't matter if their shirt loses. On the other hand, All the pony haters will settle for anything but that. Everyone makes a sacrafice and we settle on the compromise.
Two generalizations and what's the compromise?
manablue told me to calm it down so ill keep it short. My points were made, you obviously don't understand my logic, and thats fine.
Think of it like preliminary presidential voting. Everyone votes for best democrat / republican. then the two go to finals and there is the final voting.
If half the votes are not for the pony shirt, then yes a lot of people will be unhappy with the pony shirt, how does that not make sense?
btw all the votes that aren't for the top 2 shirts are basically wasted.
Hello? Wtf does this sentence even mean? Do you not know how a public poll works?
I think we should do a re-vote with the top 2 shirts as the only choices.
Or we just go with the winning vote?
There is gonna be a lot of unhappy people with the pony choice,
Random generalization.
if you add all the votes from every shirt that isn't the pony its pretty damn close too.
Again, WTF? Refer to my first comment.
The way I see it the pony shirt wearers will wear just about anything so it doesn't matter if their shirt loses. On the other hand, All the pony haters will settle for anything but that. Everyone makes a sacrafice and we settle on the compromise.
Two generalizations and what's the compromise?
manablue told me to calm it down so ill keep it short. My points were made, you obviously don't understand my logic, and thats fine.
Think of it like preliminary presidential voting. Everyone votes for best democrat / republican. then the two go to finals and there is the final voting.
If half the votes are not for the pony shirt, then yes a lot of people will be unhappy with the pony shirt, how does that not make sense?
And it's fine if it does. Let's not get too emotional about this guys.
mnm has put a TON of effort into making this tshirt thing fly from the early stages. Obviously there will be a lot of care put into the final decision about the shirt.
She's done such a great job with this project. Don't start doubting her now, in the home stretch.
I personally prefer Jellycat's logo because it's different. All of the other designs look like generic graphic-design tees, with little life or invention in them. There are thousands of places to find dramatic looking t-shirts, but not so many to find more original, idiosyncratic shirts like Jellycat's. Its playful and interesting; serious-face overly designed shirts are a dime a dozen.
EPT
(
