That RPG nomination is hilarious lol.

RPG:
Baldur's Gate II
Planetscape: Torment
Mass Effect
KOTOR
Chrono Trigger

RTS: Worthless, just pick SC:bw

FPS: I'm not enough hardcore to pick.

Oh and please, add a Adventure/Action list

On November 16 2012 11:09 jdseemoreglass wrote:
Does chess count as a video game?

Nope, chess is beyond videogames, is a sport.

SpearWrit

United States300 Posts

November 16 2012 02:14 GMT

#22

Metal Gear Solid
Mass Effect series
Final Fantasy I
Diablo
Diablo II
Team Fortress 2
Mega Man series

MichaelDonovan

United States1453 Posts

November 16 2012 02:16 GMT

#23

Ocarina of Time of course.

Terranasaur

United States2085 Posts

November 16 2012 02:17 GMT

#24

No Chronotrigger?

List not valid.

Deleted User 3420

24492 Posts

November 16 2012 02:18 GMT

#25

Baldurs Gate 2

WIllBIll

590 Posts

November 16 2012 02:29 GMT

#26

Metal Gear Solid god damnit.

Zocat

Germany2229 Posts

November 16 2012 02:29 GMT

#27

You can probably make a poll on a third party poll website to circumvent the 12 options restriction. And just link to it then.

I'm also not sure if we should use all versions from a series? As in Age of Empires 1, 2, 3 but i.e. only WC 3.
Would anyone really say Q1 was better than Q2/Q3? I dont know.

Best Shooter:
Unreal
Unreal Tournament

Best RPG:
Might & Magic 3
Neverwinter Nights (1? 2?)
Final Fantasy 6
Betrayal at Krondor (none of you will vote this piece of awesomeness

)
shitton of other games you kids dont know about and therefore never vote!

Best Adventure:
Monkey Island (1 & 2)
Indiana Jones 4
Maniac Mansion
Day of the Tentacle (MM 2)
King's Quest (havent played all so cannot say which one was the best, for me 5)
Quest for Glory 5

Best Stealther (?)
Deus Ex (I'd put it there... dont know)
Thief 2
Metal Gear Solid (I dont know which one^^)
Splinter Cell (again no idea which one)
Hitman (maybe?)

Best RTS:
Dawn of War
Company of Heroes

Best turn based strategy:
King's Bounty
Heroes of Might & Magic
Jagged Alliance 2
UFO: Enemy Unknown
Alpha Centauri
Civilization

Best Indie:
Minecraft
Terraria

Best MMO:
Ultima Online
Everquest

I actually liked the "Best Freetime" sort of category from the TIMES list:
Angry Birds
Solitaire
Minesweeper
Microsoft Pinball

Best fighting game:
SSBM
SSBB (lol!)
Street Fighter

Diks

Belgium1880 Posts

November 16 2012 03:04 GMT

#28

Here's my list per genre :

RPG : Baldur's gate
FPS : Half Life
RTS : Warcraft 3 (hard to not scream BROOOD WAAAAAAR)
Fighting game : Garou Mark of the Wolf
Hack'n Slash : Diablo 2
Racing game : TrackMania
Platform : Super Metroid
Other : Minecraft

I'm all about the classics

Essbee

Canada2371 Posts

November 16 2012 03:08 GMT

#29

Amnesia: The Dark Descent

GolemMadness

Canada11044 Posts

November 16 2012 03:10 GMT

#30

On November 16 2012 11:09 jdseemoreglass wrote:
Nominations:

RPG: Final Fantasy VII
Strategy: Civilization IV

Does chess count as a video game?

Only if it's BATTLE CHESS.

CeriseCherries

6170 Posts

November 16 2012 03:11 GMT

#31

POKEMONNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNN

WightyCity

Canada887 Posts

November 16 2012 03:13 GMT

#32

mortal kombat 1

]343[

United States10328 Posts

November 16 2012 03:14 GMT

#33

ocarina of time

super smash bros. melee

sc:bw

ragz_gt

9172 Posts

November 16 2012 03:16 GMT

#34

RPG:
Zelda Ocarina of Time
Zelda Twilight Princess
DQ III
DQ IV
FFVI
FFVII
Chrono Trigger

Silent Hill
MGS
DMC
Resident Evil II
Resident Evil IV
Parasite Eve

TBS:
Tactic Ogre
FFT
Heroes of Might & Magic III

Strategy / Sim
C&C
Age of Empire II
SC
Civ II
Civ IV
Sim City 2000
Sangokushi V

Fighting:
Street Fighter II
KOF 96
KOF 98
SSM

FPS:
Counter Strike
Doom 3

MMO:
FFXI
EVE online

Tewks44

United States2032 Posts

November 16 2012 03:17 GMT

#35

Definitely need to specify instead of list series. It would be a travesty if all Mario games got lumped into one category, because some of the Mario games stand above most other games in the series. (Super Mario bros. III for example)

Tatari

United States1179 Posts

November 16 2012 03:18 GMT

#36

People.

y u no mention fire emblem

FlyingToilet

United States840 Posts

November 16 2012 03:20 GMT

#37

just put starcraft and super mario world or the series on the list and i will be happy

Tewks44

United States2032 Posts

November 16 2012 03:20 GMT

#38

Dawn of War (based on the warhammer 40k universe)

Jockmcplop

United Kingdom10020 Posts

November 16 2012 03:21 GMT

#39

Best Shooter:
COD4 (say what you want, its an amazing game, and set formula for so many clones its unreal)
Goldeneye
HOW coudl i have forgotten Jedi Knight - Maybe the best level design of any shooter i have ever played

Best RPG:
Never really played many RPGs tbh

Best Adventure:
Monkey Island 2
Day of the Tentacle
Zelda: Ocarina of Time

Best Stealther
Deus Ex
Thief 2
Splinter Cell: Chaos Theory

Best RTS:
Commandos
Company of Heroes

Best turn based strategy:
UFO: Enemy Unknown
Civilization IV

Best fighting game:
Street Fighter 2
WWF No Mercy
WCW/NWO Revenge

Reason

United Kingdom2770 Posts

November 16 2012 03:24 GMT

#40

This might be a crazy idea but why not do the poll by series first and then take the winning series and then have a seperate vote on the best in the series to find the best game?

This would allow people who didn't vote for that particular series as their favourite to have their say about which particular one is best, I think the results would be more inclusive and credible as a result.