The Masquerade: Bloodlines was probably my dearest game, such a shame Activision forced an early publish, thus destroying the studio and hurting the game.

Imzoo

132 Posts

November 18 2012 13:30 GMT

#282

Battlefield 1942

Chilling5pr33

Germany518 Posts

November 18 2012 19:34 GMT

#283

Homeworld 1/2 (strategie)

MutaDoom

Canada1163 Posts

November 18 2012 19:43 GMT

#284

Legend of Dragoon (Playstation) is my favourite of all time (excluding BW, but I think we're excluding that right?)

Zooper31

United States5714 Posts

November 18 2012 20:26 GMT

#285

Gotta add Guildwars 2 on there if we are going by specific titles. MMO for PC.

Also I think MOBA style games should be in their own seperate category imo.

sGSuperSlinkY

United States72 Posts

November 18 2012 20:49 GMT

#286

I nominate legend of zelda: orcarina of time for action/adventure

phaZe-PropheT

United States30 Posts

November 18 2012 21:04 GMT

#287

Can we add Golden Sun to the list?
It wasn't very widely played since it was only on the game boy advanced, but it was considered one of the best, if not the best games for the GBA. (both the original and Golden Sun The Lost Age, the third one wasn't very good though)

Also, oblivion and day of the tenticle is repeated in the list

TheMooseHeed

United Kingdom535 Posts

November 19 2012 01:00 GMT

#288

Just reading through these lists makes me realise how many great games there have been. I feel the need to make a list of them so I never forget them!

I do feel like some classics are being neglected.

Mainly Streets Of Rage 2, Golden Axe 1/2, Gunstar Heroes

+Little Big Adventure 1/2 needs some more love its only got 2 mentions including me

FiWiFaKi

Canada9859 Posts

November 19 2012 01:03 GMT

#289

Neopets the Darkest Fairy for PS2
Gran Turismo 5

autoexec

United States530 Posts

November 19 2012 01:29 GMT

#290

wii sports

Cele

Germany4016 Posts

November 19 2012 01:48 GMT

#291

Albion is the greatest RPG ever to me.

Fishes

United Kingdom47 Posts

November 19 2012 01:51 GMT

#292

Chrono Trigger hands down

Xenocryst

United States521 Posts

November 19 2012 03:09 GMT

#293

The masquerade: Bloodlines, very well made game.

Hylirion

Netherlands968 Posts

November 19 2012 03:14 GMT

#294

This list needs Freelancer. Best space flying/exploration/rpg game ever.

Also Commander Keen, THE platform game of the floppy age for me at least.

Also Atlantis: The lost tales was a beautiful point and click with such awesome graphics, sound and gameplay at the time.

For strategy, Red Alert 2 is missing. "It will be a silent spring!"

Last one I'd like to add is Magic Carpet.

catabowl

United States815 Posts

November 19 2012 03:21 GMT

#295

X-Wing vs Tie Fighter

007 Goldeneye 64

Civilization II

RPG by Console

Mario RPG - SNES
Final Fantasy 4 - Playstation
Skies of Arcadia - Gamecube/Dreamcast
Pokemon Red/Blue - Gameboy

If I missed any, it's because I forget what system the title came out on first.

Greenei

Germany1754 Posts

November 19 2012 03:37 GMT

#296

how is gothic 1 and 2 not on the list by now? 5 people or so already nominated it.

HiTeK532

Canada171 Posts

November 19 2012 04:15 GMT

#297

Donkey Kong country
Super Mario rpg legend of the seven stars
Double dragon
Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles II: The Arcade Game
Excitebike (the nes version)
mario bros 3
Streets of rage
shining force
Starfox 64
Harvest moon
Bomberman
Duke nukem
kirby's dreamland

darthfoley

United States8004 Posts

November 19 2012 04:32 GMT

#298

CALL OF DUTY (1) IS THE BEST CALL OF DUTY/FPS EVER MADE.

yes, it is worthy of all caps. i've played almost 2000 hours of it since 2006. Had some of the best times ever, for example...

This is completely real, we were playing a scrim/war...

MichaelJLowell

United States610 Posts

November 19 2012 04:33 GMT

#299

Look, the purpose of a "Best X Games of All-Time" List is to provide a definitive conclusion for video game criticism. It's the very last thing you do when you have exhaustive every last meaningful piece of advice you could give on this topic. There's no sense in acknowledging these awful lists from IGN and TIME and whomever (let alone responding to them) because there isn't a single person (or group of people) on this planet who are capable of undertaking that task. If you're going to do this, just acknowledge the absolutely unbearable painstaking amount of effort that is required to make a decent list and don't use the thousands of horrible game lists as a barometer for whatever the end result of this project may be. Thanks.

FakeDouble

Australia676 Posts

November 19 2012 05:07 GMT

#300

On November 18 2012 16:40 DTX180 wrote:
My suggested additions:

possibly add a shoot em up category:
Gunstar Heroes
Metal Slug
Gradius

Strategy/Sim:
Civ 2 (having 3 civ games might be overdoing it, and i love civ 4 and civ 1, but civ 2 to me was the biggest jump in depth from one to the next)

Overall though I love the list. Not sure if i like what genres you placed some of the games under, but i like it.

shmup is a comparatively narrow category, but if we are, you have to add the Touhou project series of games to it
Otherwise, putting them under 'arcade' is fine

Don't get what the point of this is though, giant pissing contest between fans of different games? It's not like the results will change someone's opinion of a particular game or convince someone to go play a game they haven't before. At least for me, I don't look up popularity lists when choosing a new game to play...