this list sucks starcraft is #1 no contest and starcraft2 should be on here and its not even out yet! but really runescape? how many 10 year olds were the ones that voted for this? also lego batman.... lego....batman.... sad.... Also where is the SIM CITY i loveee sim city amazing game soo gooodd and the sound track mmmm. also psychonauts sooo gooooddddd and funnnnnyyyy. im going to go kill some runescape peoples now byes.

iFU.pauline

France1660 Posts

May 07 2010 18:44 GMT

#22

Halo?

Did I miss something?^^

Impervious

Canada4212 Posts

May 07 2010 18:48 GMT

#23

On May 08 2010 03:37 ltiy wrote:
I can understand why many of my favorites aren't there, but no Earthbound/Mother is :|

That would be the only game I could see being above Starcraft.....

Corvi

Germany1406 Posts

May 07 2010 18:48 GMT

#24

On May 08 2010 03:44 paulinepain wrote:
Halo?

Did I miss something?^^

yea its such a bad game, but it was the first not totally crappy ego shooter for consoles and american xbox kids, who never experienced some decent pc ego shooters, think its actually a good game.

DCLXVI

United States729 Posts

May 07 2010 18:51 GMT

#25

I don't understand why people care about this list. It is some random survey of Other People's opinions, and naturally they will differ from you. Unless people start to make decisions based off this list, then there is no reason as to why you should pay heed to it. Go ahead and criticize its methods or results if you want, but I think that it is rather pointless. Making the discussion about what should be the top 50 list is fine though.

Roffles

Pitcairn19291 Posts

May 07 2010 18:51 GMT

#26

To have Runescape over the Final Fantasy series simply means the list is made devoid of any reasoning.

Completely absurd.

seRapH

United States9777 Posts

May 07 2010 18:51 GMT

#27

this is games ranked by popularity, which is often very different from games ranked by quality. but one is quantitative, while the other is qualitative, so its obvious which will be chosen to rank.

Emon_

3925 Posts

May 07 2010 18:52 GMT

#28

Halo is no. 1? Faillist.

rabidch

United States20289 Posts

May 07 2010 18:54 GMT

#29

Terrible list. Most of these games are recently released as well. Looks like the majority of "gamers" asked were teenagers or fanboys.

x11tman

Finland50 Posts

May 07 2010 18:55 GMT

#30

Star Control 2 and UFO: Enemy Unknown should be on any "Top 50 Games All Time" list, or I won't respect it at all.

University

United States263 Posts

May 07 2010 18:57 GMT

#31

I scrolled down, immediately saw "WWE Smackdown vs RAW," and disregarded anything else on this "top 50" list.

Tomer

United States105 Posts

May 07 2010 18:57 GMT

#32

I really want to know if the people that drew this list together actually played any of the games they listed.

The6357

United States1268 Posts

May 07 2010 18:57 GMT

#33

On May 08 2010 03:52 Emon_ wrote:
Halo is no. 1? Faillist.

I personally never played halo...but I would be surprised if halo was not in top 5

nevz

Sweden72 Posts

May 07 2010 18:58 GMT

#34

I'm surprised starcraft is even on that list, the general public tends to not like it very much.
I don't understand how tetris isn't on there though.

M155_G33k

United States470 Posts

May 07 2010 18:59 GMT

#35

That list sucks. I'm sorry but FF and SC should be so farther up on the list then they are. And Halo... Halo just sucks. It should be in the 30s if anything. SC2 should be on that list too even though only the beta has been out.

Rice

United States1332 Posts

May 07 2010 19:00 GMT

#36

look at all these trash games and no warcraft 3

shalafiend

United States62 Posts

May 07 2010 19:01 GMT

#37

christ..really wwe smackdown? THAT shit beat starcraft?
i understand how all the wii games/multiplayer fps and party games (rock band) beat starcraft ...due to the enormous number of "casual" (soccer moms, air headed 12 year olds) playing it...
but content wise...these games are crap (w/ the exception of zelda, ff series).

SkytoM

Austria1137 Posts

May 07 2010 19:01 GMT

#38

Horrible List.