EPT[TV] HBO Game of Thrones - Page 1649
| Forum Index > Media & Entertainment |
All book discussion in this thread is now allowed. | ||
|
The_Red_Viper
19533 Posts
| ||
KwarK
United States44195 Posts
| ||
|
Dazed.
Canada3301 Posts
~~~ I liked this episode overall -- frankly the first episode of the season i actually enjoyed -- but I was still annoyed by some things. They keep hitting us over the head with exposition on the plot. Seconds before an ambush...tarly talks about a potential ambush. He also makes sure to mention all the golds in, blah blah. Bad dick pun. Armourless horses and men charging a pike line... Small things but really, pretty avoidable as well. It would of been easy to do a kick ass battle without the added absurdity of horses charging an armoured pike line. I'm also worried about the jon and danny story line. Danny is overtly...OVERTLY insane. I was hoping for some subtlety, but when you point out that ice demons are coming to wipe out hundreds of thousands of people and destroy the world, and the reaction you get it is 'haha ill help if you bow'...that aint subtle. Even stranger was that jons reaction wasnt shock and disgust, as literally any normal persons reaction would of been, he actually seems to like her. It seems to me that the writers are trying to do two things at once, but lack the talent or the time to do it (probably both) 1) Make jon and danny hook up 2) Show that danny is losing her mind gradually But theres no subtlety, so it isnt believable. At this point im just waiting for someone to put a shiv in dannys back, because shes clearly batshit insane. Every. Single. Line. | ||
|
Logo
United States7542 Posts
Danny is overtly...OVERTLY insane. I was hoping for some subtlety, but when you point out that ice demons are coming to wipe out hundreds of thousands of people and destroy the world, and the reaction you get it is 'haha ill help if you bow'...that aint subtle. Even stranger was that jons reaction wasnt shock and disgust, as literally any normal persons reaction would of been, he actually seems to like her. It seems pretty reasonable for me that Dany wants a united 7 kingdoms to face the white walkers rather than fight two wars at once. | ||
|
Nesserev
Belgium2760 Posts
| ||
|
riotjune
United States3394 Posts
| ||
|
Dav1oN
Ukraine3164 Posts
On August 08 2017 05:39 KwarK wrote: "Chaos is a ladder" is a super specific reference though. It explicitly references Littlefinger's conversation with Varys following his starting of the war, if I recall correctly. That's Bran saying "I know what you did last summer". He can't not know, the line wouldn't make sense. Bran's visions are still limited, he need either animals or specific tree, he can't know everything | ||
|
Gorsameth
Netherlands22478 Posts
On August 08 2017 06:34 Dazed. wrote: Yeah im hoping that Jamie doesnt keep to his whole...split him in half with a sword thing if they meet up lol. Honestly, I'm a little surprised how much Jamie even cared for Joffrey, but I guess that goes to show just how dramatically hes changed. ~~~ I liked this episode overall -- frankly the first episode of the season i actually enjoyed -- but I was still annoyed by some things. They keep hitting us over the head with exposition on the plot. Seconds before an ambush...tarly talks about a potential ambush. He also makes sure to mention all the golds in, blah blah. Bad dick pun. Armourless horses and men charging a pike line... Small things but really, pretty avoidable as well. It would of been easy to do a kick ass battle without the added absurdity of horses charging an armoured pike line. I'm also worried about the jon and danny story line. Danny is overtly...OVERTLY insane. I was hoping for some subtlety, but when you point out that ice demons are coming to wipe out hundreds of thousands of people and destroy the world, and the reaction you get it is 'haha ill help if you bow'...that aint subtle. Even stranger was that jons reaction wasnt shock and disgust, as literally any normal persons reaction would of been, he actually seems to like her. It seems to me that the writers are trying to do two things at once, but lack the talent or the time to do it (probably both) 1) Make jon and danny hook up 2) Show that danny is losing her mind gradually But theres no subtlety, so it isnt believable. At this point im just waiting for someone to put a shiv in dannys back, because shes clearly batshit insane. Every. Single. Line. Its not a pike line tho, they are short spears. By the time a horse hits the spear its momentum will carry it strait through the shieldwall. The first wave will die but completely shatter the formation after which the soldiers are doomed. On August 08 2017 07:25 cSc.Dav1oN wrote: Bran's visions are still limited, he need either animals or specific tree, he can't know everything 'Chaos is a ladder' means he heard the conversation in the throne room between Varys and Littlefinger. | ||
|
Dav1oN
Ukraine3164 Posts
I guess Jon and Dany ends up in a bed in ep 6 or 7, but I hope such amount of fan service not gonna happen | ||
|
REDBLUEGREEN
Germany1904 Posts
On August 08 2017 02:04 Acrofales wrote: Also, I don't know how Jaime survives sinking to the bottom of a lake in a full set of metal armor, but I'm sure we'll find out next week. You can swim in plate armor. Maybe due to RPG games balancing issues and "heavy armor" and "light armor" skills a lot of people have wrong impressions about plate armor. They typically only weighed something around 25kgs (modern soldiers carry a lot more) and knights were still very mobile in them being able to swim, jump, climb etc. The heaviest part of the equipment was the mail shirt underneath the plate armor which I am not sure Jaime even wears. However seeing as Jaime only has one hand left to swim, he might need to be saved by Bronn =) | ||
|
Dazed.
Canada3301 Posts
On August 08 2017 07:26 Gorsameth wrote: No...armoured spears, or pikes, regardless, will massacre unarmoured horses. Hell, horses dont even charge at things, they're animals. They have survival instinct. Horses were used to charge inbetween lines and cut down retreating men, or alternately, you had to blind a horse to get it to a charge an actual fixed position. In reality they would be slaughtered whole sale, and the horses would stop mid charge and try to turn around. It was stupid.Its not a pike line tho, they are short spears. By the time a horse hits the spear its momentum will carry it strait through the shieldwall. The first wave will die but completely shatter the formation after which the soldiers are doomed. 'Chaos is a ladder' means he heard the conversation in the throne room between Varys and Littlefinger. On August 08 2017 06:54 Logo wrote: Its not reasonable to tell someone your going to let an entire kingdom die to an unstoppable zombie army unless they bow before you and regard you as an absolute monarch, sorry.It seems pretty reasonable for me that Dany wants a united 7 kingdoms to face the white walkers rather than fight two wars at once. | ||
|
Erasme
Bahamas15899 Posts
On August 08 2017 04:00 Acrofales wrote: And because Qyburn knows everything about everything, he has dragon poison lying around! I'm sure a small bottle of the Long Fairwell will do the trick, because dragon and human anatomy are basically the same  Coated in shit anything dies when they get shit in their bloodstream | ||
|
Manit0u
Poland17795 Posts
On August 08 2017 08:12 REDBLUEGREEN wrote: You can swim in plate armor. Maybe due to RPG games balancing issues and "heavy armor" and "light armor" skills a lot of people have wrong impressions about plate armor. They typically only weighed something around 25kgs (modern soldiers carry a lot more) and knights were still very mobile in them being able to swim, jump, climb etc. The heaviest part of the equipment was the mail shirt underneath the plate armor which I am not sure Jaime even wears. However seeing as Jaime only has one hand left to swim, he might need to be saved by Bronn =) That's pretty far-fetched: https://vimeo.com/13634653 I mean, if you're in perfect shape (including not being tired or anything) you can probably make it a very short distance, but that's it. | ||
|
KwarK
United States44195 Posts
On August 08 2017 09:57 Erasme wrote: Coated in shit anything dies when they get shit in their bloodstream Things also tend to die when their insides are full of fire and yet here we are. | ||
|
B.I.G.
3251 Posts
I think Stark reunion was nice and cold just as expected. Tearjerk moments would've been totally out of place. These people have completely lost their innocence. Sansa must be like holy shit im the 6 year abuse and rape victim and I'm the most normal one here. Uber Arya vs Brienne wasn't so bad either. Clearly B was holding back and totally surprised. In the end you saw she stopped playing and the fight went quite different. Perhaps a foreshadowing of how B will end up having to fight A for real to protect Sansa or something? Curious where their stories will go. | ||
|
MassHysteria
United States3678 Posts
| ||
|
MassHysteria
United States3678 Posts
He has the best response to LF's "chaos is a ladder" pitch in this scene btw. "You say that as if you were the first man to ever think it." | ||
|
aseq
Netherlands4009 Posts
Also, why didn't Dany ride her dragon along the front line of spearmen (or pikemen, whatever), instead of perpendicular to? She could have done way more epic Firebat damage to the marines that way. And I think it's most acceptable to assume Bran is still downloading a lot of data, and can see bits here and there, but the history folder isn't RAM. | ||
|
REDBLUEGREEN
Germany1904 Posts
On August 08 2017 10:25 Manit0u wrote: That's pretty far-fetched: https://vimeo.com/13634653 I mean, if you're in perfect shape (including not being tired or anything) you can probably make it a very short distance, but that's it. Well the guy himself says that is is feasible that someone with more training could properly swim in it. While I don't know any European source, swimming in plate armor was part of normal samurai training. While Japanese plate armor weights slightly less than European ones, they have worse weight distribution. Notice the technique is very different to the crawl the guy in the vimeo video tried, and he doesn't even have to use his hands so he could continue fighting in the water. | ||
|
Makro
France16890 Posts
On August 08 2017 05:44 {CC}StealthBlue wrote: Just waiting some major plot armor to rescue to Bronn and Jaime. jaime would be better alive than dead, for obvious reasons it would be a great leverage for daenerys | ||
| ||
