EPTI'm such a good poster i don't even have to type anything
cheat in gosugamers tournament - Page 4
| Forum Index > Closed |
|
BESTPOSTER
Canada31 Posts
I'm such a good poster i don't even have to type anything | ||
|
SainT
Chile1067 Posts
 On December 30 2006 16:48 bburn wrote: 1. Idra is bm we all know this. The BW community generally allows bm, the question is should it? 'bm' actions like this are not put up with in the real world and there are consequences for them should this not be true for bw as well? 2. Idra did not have to pay anything to get into the tournment so he does not really have much to complain about in my opinion. 3. This could have easily been avoided by Idra simply answering the admin with some respect. While I admit this probably wasn't the greatest reason to kick him from the tournment I think we can all agree it is much nicer to play when everyone is mannered. I'm unable to download some reps if someone could take some pics of the fist Discussion plz | ||
|
DarK]N[exuS
China1441 Posts
| ||
|
davidgurt
United States1355 Posts
On December 30 2006 16:59 DarK]N[exuS wrote: Ok first of all when an opponent is a complete douchebag why should the competition have to suffer through it? Just tell the guy he can't compete. Secondly, insulting the referees is almost ALWAYS punished in any other sport, and SC is no exception; if you're a complete asshole to the referee you deserve to be removed from the game. Add to that having everyone in the tournament hate you, as well as documented douchebaggery within the very evidence you try to save yourself with, and you have someone who should not have a chance at $50 that was submitted for a friendly, nice tournament. I thought about this too. Insulting an admin for a tournament can be thought of as being equivalent to insulting a referee during a game, which does warrant disciplinary action. However, even with this taken into account along with my experience with IdrA's bm directed towards me, I would have to say that there needs to be some sort of agreement made with Osiris (perhaps an apology on both sides would be appropriate, or something to that nature?) | ||
|
Myxomatosis
United States2392 Posts
On December 30 2006 16:48 bburn wrote: 1. Idra is bm we all know this. The BW community generally allows bm, the question is should it? 'bm' actions like this are not put up with in the real world and there are consequences for them should this not be true for bw as well? 2. Idra did not have to pay anything to get into the tournment so he does not really have much to complain about in my opinion. 3. This could have easily been avoided by Idra simply answering the admin with some respect. While I admit this probably wasn't the greatest reason to kick him from the tournment I think we can all agree it is much nicer to play when everyone is mannered. I'll respond to these point by point. 1. Neither impaling women on spikes, shooting up tanks or launching nukes are allowed in real life. Don't try and apply real life standards to a fucking computer game. I highly doubt that any of these "e-thugs" have as much of an ego IRL as they do on bnet. 2. Time is money. Also, there is a 50 dollar prize awarded to the winner which is a fair sum of money for a small tournament like this one. I'd be pissed if I were someone like Idra with a good chance of winning the tournament. 3. This could have been easily avoided if the admin had any knowledge of how to run a fair tourney and ignore his personal feelings towards a player. "While I admit this probably wasn't the greatest reason to kick him from the tournment I think we can all agree it is much nicer to play when everyone is mannered." If all the raindrops were lemondrops and gumdrops oh, what a rain that would be! Wishful thinking, bud. BUT Teh InTErNeTz is Seriouszs business! | ||
GrandInquisitor
New York City13113 Posts
| ||
|
LeJe
Romania65 Posts
| ||
|
XDawn
Canada4040 Posts
On December 30 2006 16:59 DarK]N[exuS wrote: Ok first of all when an opponent is a complete douchebag why should the competition have to suffer through it? Just tell the guy he can't compete. Secondly, insulting the referees is almost ALWAYS punished in any other sport, and SC is no exception; if you're a complete asshole to the referee you deserve to be removed from the game. Add to that having everyone in the tournament hate you, as well as documented douchebaggery within the very evidence you try to save yourself with, and you have someone who should not have a chance at $50 that was submitted for a friendly, nice tournament. | ||
|
TT1_banned
Canada1206 Posts
| ||
|
~rOyAL~
New Zealand175 Posts
 | ||
|
~rOyAL~
New Zealand175 Posts
from gg.net | ||
|
SainT
Chile1067 Posts
On December 30 2006 17:12 LeJe wrote: u guys should see the wgt admins what is that supposed to mean | ||
|
Blind
United States2528 Posts
If this is true, then the admin didn't disqualify Idra for his bad manners. Idra was disqualified for supposedly not playing his match. This could be disproven by showing the replays. The end. | ||
|
nArAnjO
Peru2571 Posts
| ||
Manifesto7
Osaka27154 Posts
You won the games, congrats. You should be able to move on in this tournament. However, if I were organizing any other tournaments in the BW community, I would be sure not to invite you. You are an arrogant fag who thinks that bw skill = all. Your lack of manner is embarassing, and was only made worse by your opponents class in this situation. Enjoy your 50 bucks, because you just traded another chunk of your already inferior image for it. | ||
|
StRyKeR
United States1739 Posts
Otherwise, it's not fair if BM caused idra to be kicked out. There's a reason there are rules. A lot of you have been speaking as if common sense should prevail here. But the rules are what should prevail. If the rules said BM is not allowed, idra should have been kicked out plain and simple. Otherwise, (which I think is the case) maybe next time the rules can be changed. | ||
|
-_-
United States7081 Posts
On December 30 2006 17:13 XDawn wrote: Unfortunately, your analogy is flawed. In a team sport, if one person insults a ref, that person is punished (usually not by throwing him out of a game, but by a technical foul or something, which serves as a warning). The team isn't DQed for one person insulting a ref. However, if in a big boxing match (a 1v1 sport... actually make that a UFC MATCH!!!) a ref DQed a boxer because the boxer insulted him the ref would immediately lose his job and would never be allowed to participate in the sport ever again. If you made a rule saying GM was required... it would a retarded rule and your tournament would suck. Idra, you got screwed. | ||
|
-_-
United States7081 Posts
| ||
|
Manifesto7
Osaka27154 Posts
On December 30 2006 17:37 -_- wrote: Oh yeah, who else saw this post and said "awesome, some BW drama?" Something to get riled up about, something to feel righteously indignant about... oh what fun. Ex-fucking-actly | ||
|
IdrA
United States11541 Posts
On December 30 2006 17:32 Manifesto7 wrote: i posted on gg.net after i posted here, this site gets more traffic and so suited my purpose better. i posted on gg.net as it was more likely to get gg.net admins attention, which was also necessary. You already posted this on GG.net, and it is their tourny. Why do you post it here other than to find support to comfort yourself? You won the games, congrats. You should be able to move on in this tournament. However, if I were organizing any other tournaments in the BW community, I would be sure not to invite you. You are an arrogant fag who thinks that bw skill = all. Your lack of manner is embarassing, and was only made worse by your opponents class in this situation. Enjoy your 50 bucks, because you just traded another chunk of your already inferior image for it. | ||
| ||
