On June 08 2011 03:53 LunarDestiny wrote:
Goddamn misleading title. This is a highlight video with funky music. The lack of screaming by Korean commentators make this not as epic.

Yeah seriously. I was hoping it'd be on the revamped SC:BW that's being made. Complete with new graphics.

qdenser

Canada133 Posts

June 07 2011 20:07 GMT

#42

those noises are not music

SluGGer

Canada50 Posts

June 07 2011 20:11 GMT

#43

Just reading what other people are saying I'm actually too terrified to watch.

Itachii

Poland12466 Posts

June 07 2011 20:22 GMT

#44

On June 08 2011 05:11 SluGGer wrote:
Just reading what other people are saying I'm actually too terrified to watch.

Thats why you always watch contest first, to have your own opinion to share with us.Skipping comments completely is also good way to survivre (applies to YT).

To OP, can't say that i enjoyed whole clip, but some parts were really funny and creative.Overall, decent video with high caliber of originality, good job

Z3kk

4099 Posts

June 07 2011 20:27 GMT

#45

This was pretty terrible...not gonna lie lol. [insert joke about comparing this to human centipede] would qualify as torture on repeat

norsK

United States131 Posts

June 07 2011 21:35 GMT

#46

I commend your efforts - video editing takes time - and a 30 mintue 'movie' takes forever..... so gj

That said, you need to enlist a third party to act as director and musical producer - because no one in their right mind can watch more than 3 mins of this without a headache.

Pippah

Denmark353 Posts

June 07 2011 22:01 GMT

#47

I feel like I need to speak my mind a second time. Music is ok for me, not my fav electro music, but ok.
But I feel that if you want to present a video to the entire BW community it needs to be in english - not perfect english, so your are OK - however having the russian in it to just makes your english stand out even worse and is confusing to everyone else. Please remove the russian in a vid for the non russian understanding, would make it 10 better imo.

theleo_ua

Ukraine150 Posts

June 08 2011 22:09 GMT

#48

On June 08 2011 03:53 LunarDestiny wrote:
Goddamn misleading title. This is a highlight video with funky music.

If you really think that the title has to be changed to "BW forever (my BW movie)" or something another - I can change it, but when I press "edit" link - it doesnt allow me to change the title.

On June 08 2011 03:53 LunarDestiny wrote:
The lack of screaming by Korean commentators make this not as epic.

Korean commentators are epic, but:

1) the style of this movie is "do not change the music"
2) I watched a lot of movies with music and korean commentators at the same time - and didnt like what I heard: I dont hear both - music and commentators

On June 08 2011 05:27 Z3kk wrote:
This was pretty terrible...not gonna lie lol. [insert joke about comparing this to human centipede] would qualify as torture on repeat

Thank you for the constructive criticism and saying the truth

On June 08 2011 06:35 norsK wrote:
I commend your efforts - video editing takes time - and a 30 mintue 'movie' takes forever..... so gj

That said, you need to enlist a third party to act as director and musical producer - because no one in their right mind can watch more than 3 mins of this without a headache.

Interesting opinion. The advantage - better quality, the main disadvantage - different opinions of the team members can stop producing the movie.

I'm very sorry that you had headache watching this movie, but I watched this at least 30 times and hadn't any headaches or eye-destroying.

For me the headache and eye destroying is this (Warning - you can have headache or eye-destroying watching this!):

+ Show Spoiler +

So if you compare this video to my movie - maybe you will change your opinion about headaches

On June 08 2011 07:01 Pippah wrote:
I feel like I need to speak my mind a second time. Music is ok for me, not my fav electro music, but ok.
But I feel that if you want to present a video to the entire BW community it needs to be in english - not perfect english, so your are OK - however having the russian in it to just makes your english stand out even worse and is confusing to everyone else. Please remove the russian in a vid for the non russian understanding, would make it 10 better imo.

I thought about this. I watched German demos (kewlers, farb-rausch, haujobb) with both English and German/Finnish text. I tried to imagine that I watching French or Danish movie with both English and Danish text. And I had no reasons to say that this text need to be removed - I just will not understand the German/Danish part, not the whole demo/movie.

But I dont think that you are not right, so maybe I will made "English only version" in future (because this take a lot of time and some parts of the movie are too hard for translating to English).

Anyway - thanks for the constructive criticism.

edc

United States666 Posts

June 08 2011 23:33 GMT

#49

WTF did I just watch...

zobz

Canada2175 Posts

June 09 2011 00:22 GMT

#50

I can tell alot of work went into this and it's fairly creative and thoughtful, but it doesn't actually seem to convey a whole lot. Largely a meaningless sequence of images. The images were fine, but the sequence seemed somewhat random. If you find randomness amusing I suppose it's good for you.

therockmanxx

Peru1174 Posts

June 09 2011 03:19 GMT

#51

You only need an awesome match and an epic music
An the 2 combine make an good video
This is version 1.00 so I guess you can make another one xD

This is my make epic video:
+ Show Spoiler +

zappa372

Chile365 Posts

June 09 2011 03:34 GMT

#52

I loved it. I loled at the Blizzard has left the game part hehehe

Iplaythings

Denmark9110 Posts

June 09 2011 07:05 GMT

#53

I didnt mind the music all that much. But I did mind the first fade out, god that was long and hurt my eyes. The rest were better. I really liked how you synched the music with action, thats allways nice to watch =)

Darth Vader

United States50 Posts

June 09 2011 08:02 GMT

#54

OMF. I can't believe I didnt listen to all those who said it is bad!
IT IS GOD AWFUL BAD! There is a gap in my life now!
Please don't make another video again, EVAR.

Requisition

United States97 Posts

June 10 2011 06:06 GMT

#55

Wow, this is your brain on Brood War.

theleo_ua

Ukraine150 Posts

June 21 2011 19:18 GMT

#56

On June 09 2011 09:22 zobz wrote:
I can tell alot of work went into this and it's fairly creative and thoughtful, but it doesn't actually seem to convey a whole lot. Largely a meaningless sequence of images. The images were fine, but the sequence seemed somewhat random. If you find randomness amusing I suppose it's good for you.

You mean sequence of scenes or of "pictures" in some of the scenes?

On June 09 2011 12:19 therockmanxx wrote:
You only need an awesome match and an epic music
An the 2 combine make an good video
This is version 1.00 so I guess you can make another one xD

This is my make epic video:
+ Show Spoiler +

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dMXaVo3CMzk

Good idea, but not for this movie, because the main concept of it is mixing.

Nice video, btw

On June 09 2011 12:34 zappa372 wrote:
I loved it. I loled at the Blizzard has left the game part hehehe

"Blizzard has left the game" was the most epic news for all BW fans imho

On June 09 2011 16:05 Iplaythings wrote:
I didnt mind the music all that much. But I did mind the first fade out, god that was long and hurt my eyes. The rest were better. I really liked how you synched the music with action, thats allways nice to watch =)

Imho not all music is mixable, but this mix has been chosen because of some special reasons, for example "iloooov, hiya forever, shine" sounds. Also I like most of the tracks in this mix.

I agree with you about syncing action with the music - it always fun to watch good syncing between video and the music (not only in BW - also in demoscene for example). But I didnt know a lot of "synced" BW videos - most of the movie makers just making high quality epic moments, but without good syncing (or even without any syncing) and this is sad.

On June 09 2011 17:02 Darth Vader wrote:
OMF. I can't believe I didnt listen to all those who said it is bad!
IT IS GOD AWFUL BAD! There is a gap in my life now!
Please don't make another video again, EVAR.

Thanks

On June 10 2011 15:06 Requisition wrote:
Wow, this is your brain on Brood War.

Demoscene killed my brain

epikAnglory

United States1120 Posts

June 21 2011 21:16 GMT

#57

There needs to be a WHAT THE FK option in the poll lol. I thought it was going to be a godly trailer or something, turned out to just be a troll video lol.

Zedders

Canada450 Posts

June 21 2011 21:26 GMT

#58

It's as if /b/ took a shit on broodwar

EDIT:
ok there was maybe 2 seconds in the movie twice that made me at least...feel something...so it's not all bad.

hellbound

United Kingdom2242 Posts

June 21 2011 22:12 GMT

#59

Don't regret taking time to watch this at all. You people are just too used to the high production values of OGN/MBC, lighten up. The humour and content might be a bit questionable at times but the sync of music and video (what they were focussing on) was pretty well done. Thanks for sharing.

EchelonTee

United States5245 Posts

June 21 2011 22:14 GMT

#60

i was hoping that this was a joke... the first 2 minutes were just a prelude to the shitstorm to ensue. I don't know why u felt the need to have random non sequitors by inserting images everywhere... but to each his own i guess.