|
On July 18 2004 06:36 BigBalls wrote: however, what possible balance could fix that and would leave tvz balanced. the only balance issue that ever bothered me was reducing storm enough so that 1 shot didnt kill a lurker.
another few clicks less needed to be a decent protoss >_<
but seriously, 60% z vs p would be a huge disadvantage, 54% isn't that far. It doesn't mean that pvz is unplayable, but that zvp is much easier than pvz, assuming that hundreds of people who played are equally tallented. Kinda like playing 1on1 basketball in tight jeans and sandals, still a skill game, but...
|
Braavos36402 Posts
race statistics in basketball:
bvw 98.6%
|
remember what they did a while back? tweaked zealot health and shields so that zealots are stronger vs hydras but doesnt effect much else (sieged kills them in same amount of shots, doesnt effect marines, vultures, zerglings. etc.).
another thing to consider would be photons. it's possible to change photons slightly without it really effecting tvp isn't it? the same with high templar or storm?
there may also be small changes you could make to terran that would effect tvp more than they would tvz. that would allow you to strengthen protoss slightly because they would be balanced out by terran's changes, overall only changing pvz. should be pretty easy to think of ways to make tvp stronger (so that you can make p stronger so tvp remains same and pvz is changed) since it's so different from tvz.
On July 18 2004 07:32 STIMEY d okgm fish wrote: another thing to remember about those stats are positions. that 54+% advanced z>p includes games from 12/3 3/12 where p obviously has the advantage. so what must toss's chances be when it's not 12/3 or 3/12? well i dunno lets see.
toss wins 45.1% of the time vs zerg. let's just assume this is all LT for now, maybe we'll get better numbers later. a toss has a 25% chance to get 12 and a 25% chance to get 3. zerg then has a 33% chance to get the nearby spot. 25% * 33% = 8.25% of it being advantageous to toss. and then 91.75% of the games are "normal balance" games (not 12/3 or 3/12).
if all the stats were from LT, then toss, winning 45.1% of the time vs zerg, actually has a huge advantage 8.25% of the time. so when u arent 12/3 3/12, ur chances must be somewhere below 45.1%.
also don't forget this. protoss won vs zerg 45.1% of the time including 8.25% of the time (if it was all LT, which are the numbers we really need) where toss was 12/3 or 3/12 (p>z). therefore, toss wins less than 45.1% of the time vs zerg when the spots are not close. for example, if toss wins 50% of the time in 12/3 3/12 positions that would be 50% of 8.25% or 4.125% less win outside of those positions, then toss actually is winning 40.975% of the time outside of 12/3 3/12 vs zerg. and if toss wins 60% of 12/3 3/12 then it's 45.1% - (60% * 8.25%) = toss only wins 40.15% vs zerg outiside of 12/3 3/12. or what if it's 70%? 45.1% - (70% * 8.25%) = 39.325%!. so just keep that in mind: LT's win percentage includes 12/3 3/12 making up 8.25% of all results.
|
Russian Federation4447 Posts
On July 18 2004 09:43 tfeign wrote: Give lurker more armor and less life would be the best fix IMO.
Would not disrupt tvz balance -- lurk still take about the same time to kill.
Only big difference will be storm being more effective vs lurk
ummm no, they thought increasing sunken armor and decreasing health would help vs terran. How wrong, tanks plow through sunks even faster, also bunker rushes are more successful because they only have to deal around 300 damage to a morphing sunk before it finishes morphing and is left with 1 health. I think the morphing sunk should be given 2 plus armor and start morphing at 300 health instead of 400. Same with quick expoes vs toss.
Tanks would plow through lurks even faster if you decrease the health. Dragoons would be even more effective vs lurks. Lurk contain would be nearly useless.
But yeah, I have adopted the most cheap strategy vs protoss on gamei. Just turtle like mad off 2 or 3 gas and mass ultra/ling. It never fails me.
|
Sweden33723 Posts
On July 18 2004 11:26 STIMEY d okgm fish wrote: remember what they did a while back? tweaked zealot health and shields so that zealots are stronger vs hydras but doesnt effect much else (sieged kills them in same amount of shots, doesnt effect marines, vultures, zerglings. etc.). another thing to consider would be photons. it's possible to change photons slightly without it really effecting tvp isn't it? the same with high templar or storm? there may also be small changes you could make to terran that would effect tvp more than they would tvz. that would allow you to strengthen protoss slightly because they would be balanced out by terran's changes, overall only changing pvz. should be pretty easy to think of ways to make tvp stronger (so that you can make p stronger so tvp remains same and pvz is changed) since it's so different from tvz. Show nested quote +On July 18 2004 07:32 STIMEY d okgm fish wrote: another thing to remember about those stats are positions. that 54+% advanced z>p includes games from 12/3 3/12 where p obviously has the advantage. so what must toss's chances be when it's not 12/3 or 3/12? well i dunno lets see.
toss wins 45.1% of the time vs zerg. let's just assume this is all LT for now, maybe we'll get better numbers later. a toss has a 25% chance to get 12 and a 25% chance to get 3. zerg then has a 33% chance to get the nearby spot. 25% * 33% = 8.25% of it being advantageous to toss. and then 91.75% of the games are "normal balance" games (not 12/3 or 3/12).
if all the stats were from LT, then toss, winning 45.1% of the time vs zerg, actually has a huge advantage 8.25% of the time. so when u arent 12/3 3/12, ur chances must be somewhere below 45.1%. also don't forget this. protoss won vs zerg 45.1% of the time including 8.25% of the time (if it was all LT, which are the numbers we really need) where toss was 12/3 or 3/12 (p>z). therefore, toss wins less than 45.1% of the time vs zerg when the spots are not close. for example, if toss wins 50% of the time in 12/3 3/12 positions that would be 50% of 8.25% or 4.125% less win outside of those positions, then toss actually is winning 40.975% of the time outside of 12/3 3/12 vs zerg. and if toss wins 60% of 12/3 3/12 then it's 45.1% - (60% * 8.25%) = toss only wins 40.15% vs zerg outiside of 12/3 3/12. or what if it's 70%? 45.1% - (70% * 8.25%) = 39.325%!. so just keep that in mind: LT's win percentage includes 12/3 3/12 making up 8.25% of all results. 6 vs 12, 9 vs 6/6vs 9 = pretty much as difficult as 12 vs 3 is for Z~?
|
bah toss sucks, we are a dying breed
|
hehe remember in the good days when zerg pool was 150 and ppl would 6 pool rush and it wouldnt even hurt their economy too much...
sweet sweet zerg...
|
mm, 12v3 is not _that_ easy for protoss. 3v12 is a gimme. But it is a big advantage when the zerg can pool before 2nd ovie.
As for the balance issues, i really think storm killing lurks in 1 shot would fix the balance. If storm damage was increased to say 121 (or whatever it needs to be so that 1 shot killed an unupgraded (carapace) lurker, but not an upgraded one!) then the matchup would be great.
|
|
|
they should tweak reavers to do 126 damage (with the scrab damage upg) so that they can kill lurks in 1 hit 
|
So LT isn't balanced, and way to many people play terran. Shocking...
|
IMO 54% is not significant. If you beat someone at tennis (or any other 1 vs 1 game) 54% of the time you would be pretty evenly matched.
And even if you think 54% means something, the P's make up for their 'bad' record against Z by beating up on the more numerous T's.
For example... A theoretical P (representing all P players) plays 100000 games. His results would be: 42% or 42000 games vs terran = 21672 wins (51.6% win rate). 28% or 28000 vs protoss = 14000 wins (50% win rate). 30% or 30000 games vs Z = 13770 wins (45.9% win rate). So he wins 49442 games, or 49.44%. Good enough to say things even out for him, and it isn't a handicap playing P, because more T's in the world than Z's.
Play whatever race you enjoy. You are not at a disadvantage once you look at the whole forest, beyond the individual big tree.
|
On July 18 2004 13:13 BigBalls wrote: mm, 12v3 is not _that_ easy for protoss. 3v12 is a gimme. But it is a big advantage when the zerg can pool before 2nd ovie.
As for the balance issues, i really think storm killing lurks in 1 shot would fix the balance. If storm damage was increased to say 121 (or whatever it needs to be so that 1 shot killed an unupgraded (carapace) lurker, but not an upgraded one!) then the matchup would be great.
storm ignores armor anyway but they could just make it a special case for lurkers but that'd be weird, storm does 112 damage now it did 128 before i believe.
|
NoName read what I posted on the first page. 54.1% is CONSIDERABLE when 200000 games are taken into account.
And TheBiShOp as I posted on the first page:
P has to play almost perfect to win. That's why in the professional level p = z, because pro protosses can play at almost-perfect games but in the semi-pro or amateur level, Z >>> P
There are probably less than .0001% of the Starcraft population who can play at an almost perfect level. Should Blizzard balance the game for the .0001% of the Starcraft population or for the 99.999% of the Starcraft population?
Definitely not saying that pvz is impossible, but it is not balanced for 99.999% of the players
|
|
|
Yes, protoss cannot make mistakes in pvz. Small mistakes can cost them the game. Zerg can make mistakes and be nowhere near the kind of disadvantage that protoss would be in in similar situations.
And making people stop playing LT is not going to happen. That "campaign" has been going on for years. The reality is it's not going to happen.
Balance change is something that CAN happen.
Making people stop playing LT as the most popular map will NOT happen.
Which is better to fix?
|
|
|
On July 18 2004 17:38 rhesusabe wrote: seriously, you need to stop whining  protosses need to play PERFECT vs zerg, or else the mu is imbalanced? thats just fucking bullshit and pisses me off that people can actually say that t.t THE REASON WHY ZERGS BEAT TOSSES 54% ON NGI IS BECAUSE THE GAMES ARE PLAYED ON LT, AND NOT BECAUSE THE MU IS IMBALANCED.
which map is it balanced on then? one that 2% of all games are played on? oh that's a good point. and are those maps as interesting and as balanced for all matchups?
how many major tournies do you think would be won by toss if they were held on LT?
|
|
|
rhesusabe let me ask you what is your IQ high?
|
|
|
|
|
|