Race statistics at NeoGame-i - Page 6
| Forum Index > BW General |
|
rhesusabe
77 Posts
| ||
|
tfeign
United States2980 Posts
On July 18 2004 17:40 STIMEY d okgm fish wrote: which map is it balanced on then? one that 2% of all games are played on? oh that's a good point. and are those maps as interesting and as balanced for all matchups? how many major tournies do you think would be won by toss if they were held on LT? HAHAH exactly. This guy wants the game to be balanced on the maps that no one plays on rather than be balanced on the map that everyone plays on. Smart. | ||
|
OgerDaniel
273 Posts
| ||
|
NoName
United States1558 Posts
Let's try another way to examine this: OK OK... For those who have access to ngi records, can you break down the ratings? Main races by the top 100 players, 101-200, 201-300, what races do they play? And how often do they play PvZ, and the win/loss record. IMO if P is clearly handicapped, you will see less and less P as the ratings get higher compared to the general player pool as players play closer to "perfect". Or, if there are more P at highest level, it could be that non-perfect P play is more easily punished at lower level because ZvP is more forgiving to Z, like some have said. If so, it is not a problem with imbalance, it is a problem with skill level of the player. These things are not so simple as first glance. Just like life. | ||
|
Kacas
Brazil3143 Posts
lt not that much =D | ||
|
Liquid`Jinro
Sweden33723 Posts
On July 18 2004 17:25 tfeign wrote: NoName read what I posted on the first page. 54.1% is CONSIDERABLE when 200000 games are taken into account. And TheBiShOp as I posted on the first page: There are probably less than .0001% of the Starcraft population who can play at an almost perfect level. Should Blizzard balance the game for the .0001% of the Starcraft population or for the 99.999% of the Starcraft population? Definitely not saying that pvz is impossible, but it is not balanced for 99.999% of the players No. Every single player here could beat zergs by just playing better than the zerg. That holds true until the very highest pro levels were you can beat zergs anyways because you don't make stupid mistakes and have good timing. THE END! | ||
|
Liquid`Jinro
Sweden33723 Posts
On July 18 2004 17:39 tfeign wrote: Yes, protoss cannot make mistakes in pvz. Small mistakes can cost them the game. Zerg can make mistakes and be nowhere near the kind of disadvantage that protoss would be in in similar situations. And making people stop playing LT is not going to happen. That "campaign" has been going on for years. The reality is it's not going to happen. Balance change is something that CAN happen. Making people stop playing LT as the most popular map will NOT happen. Which is better to fix? LT is not a pro map. LT is not used in important games. What more do you want? You are at a level where you lose because your opponent is BETTER than you, not because of imbalance. And besides, if zerg under/overestimates the toss forces and makes too many lings/drones they are very much prone to dying ~ Delicate balance -_- | ||
|
Liquid`Jinro
Sweden33723 Posts
On July 18 2004 18:24 NoName wrote: I was wrong. I realized my analysis of P winning 50% showing balance and fairness is bogus. If all the P are lower rated, your rating will still naturally stabalize at the point and level where you will win 50% of ALL your games. So the conclusions could be wrong, it could be PvZ may be perfectly balanced (for arguments sake, though I know it is not)... but it is just that P player rating stop going up when PvT INBALANCE cause their rating to inflate until they play and lose against more skilled Zs to compensate. Of course you can argue the other way, ZvP is so difficult that P ratings are depressed, so more skilled P beat up on weaker T's to compensate for their PvZ losses. Let's try another way to examine this: OK OK... For those who have access to ngi records, can you break down the ratings? Main races by the top 100 players, 101-200, 201-300, what races do they play? And how often do they play PvZ, and the win/loss record. IMO if P is clearly handicapped, you will see less and less P as the ratings get higher compared to the general player pool as players play closer to "perfect". Or, if there are more P at highest level, it could be that non-perfect P play is more easily punished at lower level because ZvP is more forgiving to Z, like some have said. If so, it is not a problem with imbalance, it is a problem with skill level of the player. These things are not so simple as first glance. Just like life. I think LT PvZ is only slightly imbalanced at the VERY highest levels -.- which means tfeign and the rest can shut up since skill can compensate for that until you are the top -_- at which point you won't play as much LT! | ||
|
STIMEY d okgm fish
Canada6140 Posts
but where is the balance the pros have that is so delicate? they fucking play some gay fucking maps. if balance changes improved overall games on LT it wouldn't do shit to pros they would just play some more gay maps. | ||
|
Refrain[FriZ]
Canada4337 Posts
| ||
|
Liquid`Jinro
Sweden33723 Posts
On July 18 2004 19:40 STIMEY d okgm fish wrote: well FA is right: LT can be imbalanced and we can still not care since it's not a pro map anyways and non-pros have fine games on it and we shouldn't ruin the balance of a game just to fix a non-competitive map like LT. but where is the balance the pros have that is so delicate? they fucking play some gay fucking maps. if balance changes improved overall games on LT it wouldn't do shit to pros they would just play some more gay maps. Ya but WHAT can you do without fucking other stuff up? Scarab upgrade being 26+ instead of 25+ = good since it's 1 hit kill (or as I originally suggested +28 so it only does 2 hit kill @ 3+ carapace). Make DA's regenerate energy faster? Make them start with more energy? I am opposed to any decrease in mana cost though -_-; I dunno, what else can you touch? Cannons possibly-.- Something like them having 1+ shield? Hm.. dunno :O | ||
|
Splinter
United States188 Posts
| ||
|
NormalGeek
United States81 Posts
On July 18 2004 20:28 Splinter wrote: All I've got from these 6 pages is tfeign sucks at PvZ. According to the ngi statistics he isn't alone. | ||
|
tfeign
United States2980 Posts
On July 18 2004 20:28 Splinter wrote: All I've got from these 6 pages is tfeign sucks at PvZ. Read the thread before you post next time. FA, Stats do not lie. Don't "theorycraft" AKA "you can beat zerg by playing better than the zerg" or "don't make mistakes." Well of course you can beat anyone by playing better than them. WTF is the point of saying that? The point is that PvZ is imbalanced. Statistics don't lie. 54.1% PvZ over 200000 games is significant if you know anything about statistics. Look at the stats. Don't theorycraft. Ask any toss player what their worst matchup is. If the majority doesn't say zerg I would never post in this thread again. | ||
|
SoL.Origin
Argentina2400 Posts
On July 18 2004 20:54 tfeign wrote: Read the thread before you post next time. FA, Stats do not lie. Don't "theorycraft" AKA "you can beat zerg by playing better than the zerg" or "don't make mistakes." Well of course you can beat anyone by playing better than them. WTF is the point of saying that? The point is that PvZ is imbalanced. Statistics don't lie. 54.1% PvZ over 200000 games is significant if you know anything about statistics. Look at the stats. Don't theorycraft. Ask any toss player what their worst matchup is. If the majority doesn't say zerg I would never post in this thread again. The point is that statistics would be useful when 2 people who are exactly equally skilled face each other. Such case is almost impossible to ever happen, given the nature of human experience and the strategical variety the game allows. | ||
|
STIMEY d okgm fish
Canada6140 Posts
On July 18 2004 19:48 FrozenArbiter wrote: what can u cahnge that wont fuk other stuff up? depends on which matchup u concede can be changed and then by how much. i guarnatee you its possible to help any race in any matchup without hurting other matchups. noname makes a great point u are mostly likely to miss just like half a dozen other good points already made that no one responded to: the ladder brings people to a ranking where they should win/lose 50%. so just taking wins/losses of whatever doesnt accurately reflect a race's strength -- it gets watered down basically when u look at it that way. | ||
|
Hoops
417 Posts
So blizzard should base all of their balance changes on LT? That's simply mind bogglingly retarted. Don't play tos if you don't like pvz on temple because blizzard isn't going to make balance changes, and it seems to be that it would be a LOT easier to get people to stop playing temple. Most top players are playing a LOT more non temple lately. Tournies played are more and more becoming completely void of temple. Once there are enough replays on non temple for people to copy I think it will become possible for people to slowly move away from temple only. | ||
|
Hot_Bid
Braavos36402 Posts
| ||
|
tfeign
United States2980 Posts
On July 18 2004 22:29 Hoops wrote: LT 2.3 is used in pro games right now stimy, so it is a pro map. So blizzard should base all of their balance changes on LT? That's simply mind bogglingly retarted. Don't play tos if you don't like pvz on temple because blizzard isn't going to make balance changes, and it seems to be that it would be a LOT easier to get people to stop playing temple. Most top players are playing a LOT more non temple lately. Tournies played are more and more becoming completely void of temple. Once there are enough replays on non temple for people to copy I think it will become possible for people to slowly move away from temple only. Oh right. The majority will eventually stop playing Temple? If what you say ever comes true I'll give you $500 through Paypal ASAP. Mark my words. I'm a man of truth. This post will be here as long as TL lives so you can always refer back to it. | ||
|
radiaL
Andorra2690 Posts
heh | ||
| ||
