Race statistics at NeoGame-i - Page 3
| Forum Index > BW General |
|
suxN
Finland1167 Posts
| ||
|
Energies
Australia3225 Posts
On July 17 2004 23:08 sv14 wrote: Z>P 54.1% *GASP* O_O. Zerg > protoss? NO WAY! And on LT? Woha this was unexpected. | ||
|
Shauni
4077 Posts
| ||
|
STIMEY d okgm fish
Canada6140 Posts
T>Z 50.2% (i.e. Terrans took a victory over Zergs in 50.2% of all TvZ matches) P>T 51.6% Z>P 54.1% The portion of LT-matches is 89.5% i'd like to see what those win % would be on LT-only ... u have 10.5% non-LT effecting those percentages, watering it down or rigging it up somewhat? another thing some of u seem to have trouble with is really seeing these numbers as is. allow me to do a calculation that will enlighten some of you. T>Z 50.2% THEREFORE ZvT 49.8% P>T 51.6% THEREFORE TvP 48.4% Z>P 54.1% THEREFORE PvZ 45.1% also, remember: 10.5% of those games were not LT, and we really don't even know how they break down. | ||
|
Pomozite
Croatia647 Posts
On July 17 2004 23:44 tfeign wrote: That's why in the professional level p = z, because pro protosses can play at almost-perfect games but in the semi-pro or amateur level, Z >>> P If that was true there would be equal number of toss players in top20, but last time I checked best toss was 22nd. | ||
|
Liquid`Daaman
Sweden1225 Posts
it's obvious that there are more than one toss pro-gamer at the top top level. whine! | ||
|
Liquid`Jinro
Sweden33723 Posts
On July 17 2004 23:44 tfeign wrote: Zerg needs to be weakened vs P. 54.1% is ALOT when 200000 are taken into account. 54.1% would be a great % if it was spread over 500 or 1000 games. But 54.1% spread over 200000 games is very significant. Zerg winning 54.1% of the time vs toss is a considerable difference. Also my neogamei statistics (estimated): PvT: 75% PvZ: 33% PvP: 50% I'm 1151 high =/ Yeah pvz is a bitch. One small mistake in pvz can many times cost you the game (which alot of times involves the lurker). P has to play almost perfect to win. That's why in the professional level p = z, because pro protosses can play at almost-perfect games but in the semi-pro or amateur level, Z >>> P -_- 54.1 isn't that big considering it's fucking ALL LT... Btw, roughyl estimated my neogamei statistics vs race: PvT: 35% win TvP: 50% win PvZ: 75% win So stop whining ;( If you know PvZ you can win vs equally skilled zergs a lot ![]() | ||
|
Liquid`Jinro
Sweden33723 Posts
On July 18 2004 00:13 tfeign wrote: Examples: P successfully corsair-rushed Z: p kills off a few ovies, get to watch Z's tech. Game is still up for grabs. Z successfully muta-rushed P: Game over. A successful muta rush would be gg 90% of the time. A corsair rush isn't meant to kill zerg.. You can contain him if done properly. However 1 gate sucks at LT ^_^ "Succsessfully muta-rushed". What the hell does that mean? That the P sucked a lot and got raped losing all his probes because he had no defence? Or the zerg did adequate damage not to be behind..? Even if zerg does a really, really fast muta rush and catch you off guard you can come back no fucking problems -_- Their eco is weak-_- P successfully high templar drop Z's mineral line and killed off a bunch of drones. Z is slowed down momentarily while he makes another bunch of drones from his hatches. Game still up for grabs. Z successfully lurker dropped P's mineral line and killed off a bunch of probes (note that since toss don't have many expansions, MANY more probes are gathered in the mineral lines). 20+ probes dies. No way off toss coming back into the game now. High templar drops are HIGHLY effective vs a low drone style. Vs a sauron zerg it can still be worth it as they are making DRONES not units. After templar dropping, pressure since their larvae is used for making drones / or they made units which means it's a win/win situation. They either defend vs your attack with units and lose eco, or lose position while replacing eco. If P doesn't have defence it's his own god damn fault, full stop. Besides, if 20+ probes dies you suck.. If you have no god damn defence there you are dumb! P successfully killed off one of Z's expasion. Z is slowed down a bit. Z successfully killed off one of P's expansion. Game over. Toss cannot afford to lose any exp vs zerg unless he is way ahead in the game. Yeah it's the same as in PvT... Toss usually has the better eco and so can afford to lose an expo here and there. Second statement = WRONG. Just wrong, wrong wrong wrong. P catches Z offguard with fast DT. Zerg just has to pull back and wait until his ovies come along with his army and attack again. Z catches P offguard with fast lurkers. Now protoss will be contained in his base while Z expands and MASS. In pvz, a contained toss will lose most of the time. Depends, if zerg has made any mistakes in ol placement you sometimes can run in and kill their drones/stop mining. The zerg would have to be just about as stupid as a toss losing 20 probes to a lurker drop would be. Um, no? You need good timing and good goon+obs control with some nice storming. Work on your push break ffs-- | ||
|
BigBalls
United States5354 Posts
54.1% is pretty significant. 54.1 - 45.9...zerg is winning about 17% more than toss.... p is winning 9 out of 20 games. thats kinda bad. however, what possible balance could fix that and would leave tvz balanced. the only balance issue that ever bothered me was reducing storm enough so that 1 shot didnt kill a lurker. | ||
|
Pomozite
Croatia647 Posts
On July 18 2004 06:16 [pG]Liquid`Daaman wrote: what craptacular top20 list is that.. that pro-gaming rank is not entirely functional. (plus there are tosses at the top20 btw) Neogamei top20. http://www.neogamei.net/ranking.php edit: I just checked and best toss is 20th. | ||
|
Liquid`Jinro
Sweden33723 Posts
On July 18 2004 05:59 STIMEY d okgm fish wrote: i'd like to see what those win % would be on LT-only ... u have 10.5% non-LT effecting those percentages, watering it down or rigging it up somewhat? another thing some of u seem to have trouble with is really seeing these numbers as is. allow me to do a calculation that will enlighten some of you. T>Z 50.2% THEREFORE ZvT 49.8% P>T 51.6% THEREFORE TvP 48.4% Z>P 54.1% THEREFORE PvZ 45.1% also, remember: 10.5% of those games were not LT, and we really don't even know how they break down. My guess is this: 10% of those were WCG Maps (worse than LT for PvZ) and the other 0.5 were nostalgia (the only other map I've seen koreans ask for on neogamei ) | ||
|
Liquid`Jinro
Sweden33723 Posts
On July 18 2004 06:06 Pomozite wrote: If that was true there would be equal number of toss players in top20, but last time I checked best toss was 22nd. Nal_ra is fucking ranked 2ND @ the ESPA ranking lol :D He'll be 1st soon.. Zeus is ranked well as well (top 10 possibly), garimto was ranked in the top 10 way after his retirement-_- Kingdom will be top 10 soon, reach is top 10 I think.. Oh and you people have to consider this: There are more zerg players than toss ~ slightly bigger talent pool -_-~ About the same differance as the differance in winning percentages..+_+ | ||
|
GroT
Belgium3003 Posts
if people would have asked guys like you in advance what the pvz % was gonna be, i bet you would have estimated it to be much worse this game is so balanced that in the three matchups where balance is an issue, you get 50,50,54. jesus, let the balance issue go | ||
|
smalltoss
Canada31 Posts
personally, i think bw is one of the most amazingly balanced rts games of all time. think about what blizzard accomplished, 3 completely different races with all different units, different build times resource costs and play styles. no matter what unit combination or strategy you might use on any given map, it is possible for your opponent to counter almost everything you do, and vice versa. given that the win% are all within 7% of each other, and taking into account its not JUST balance, but map, player ability, amount of people that play that race, bad games for a certain player, good games for a certain player, lag spikes etc.. there are so many other things to factor into this, and when you think about it 50 50 54 is pretty damn good. | ||
|
Liquid`Jinro
Sweden33723 Posts
On July 18 2004 06:57 smalltoss wrote: i fail to see how toss would lose vs z if they both have armies within 20~ control of each other, imo a few well placed storms can almost level an entire zerg army. A generic toss army (one designed for middle game) would probably get leveled (unless like 3-3-3 grades) vs ultra ling in such a situation. A archon/dt/zealot/ht army probably wouldn't ~_~ Insane amounts of goons can work well vs ultra too Provided you have sup advantage etcetcet | ||
|
[G]Max_Power
Slovakia304 Posts
just exp,gates,upgrade = gg ![]() | ||
|
smalltoss
Canada31 Posts
On July 18 2004 07:00 FrozenArbiter wrote: A generic toss army (one designed for middle game) would probably get leveled (unless like 3-3-3 grades) vs ultra ling in such a situation. A archon/dt/zealot/ht army probably wouldn't ~_~ Insane amounts of goons can work well vs ultra too Provided you have sup advantage etcetcetsay you have 5 ht with 150 energy each, thats 10 storms... say (this is a low estimate too) you get 8 lings with each storm, thats 80 lings, or 40 control of their army gone. as for ultras, i know most people dont do this but maelstrom = godly. i dont know why more people dont use it. sure you might say too much of a hassle to get the required upgrades etc. but you shouldnt be making darchons just for ultraling, on lt 2 darchons could immobilize those 12 harassing muts, and 1 storm and 2~ goons would easily clean up before it wears off. theorycraft in its purest form, but i dont see an imba issue here, if you use your race properly theres always a counter to everything. | ||
|
8882
2737 Posts
IMO protoss is the most popular race among nonkoreans and usually the skill level of average nonkorean players is lower, so they lose. | ||
|
Liquid`Jinro
Sweden33723 Posts
No.2 ÀÓ¿äȯ - Boxer 6979 371½Â 233ÆÐ T No.3 È«ÁøÈ£ - Yellow 6828 328½Â 199ÆÐ Z No.4 ±èÁ¤¹Î - Themarine 5237 293½Â 209ÆÐ T No.5 ¹ÚÁ¤¼® - Reach 4745 236½Â 181ÆÐ P No.6 °µµ°æ - Hot 4730 244½Â 194ÆÐ Z No.7 ÃÖÀÎ±Ô - ChRh 4309 241½Â 200ÆÐ T/R No.8 Á¶¿ëÈ£ - Chojja 4270 201½Â 144ÆÐ Z No.9 º¯±æ¼· - Sync 4047 209½Â 151ÆÐ T No.10 ¼ÁöÈÆ - Xellos 3756 167½Â 99 T (6T 3Z 1P) That's the PGR21.com top 10, how many of those would you say are dominating right now? Reach is the only one (he's also the only P with that amount of games played!). ;D Lets look at top 20~ No.11 °¹Î - Nal_ra 3491 242Àü 145½Â 97ÆÐ 59.9 % P No.12 ÀüÅÂ±Ô - Zeus 3473 348Àü 179½Â 169ÆÐ 51.4 % P No.13 ÁÖÁøÃ¶ - Side 3456 316Àü 171½Â 145ÆÐ 54.1 % Z No.14 ÀåÁø³² - Jinnam3417 423Àü 206½Â 217ÆÐ 48.7 % Z No.15 ¹Ú°æ¶ô - Junwi3394 287Àü 161½Â 126ÆÐ 56.1 % Z No.16 ±â¿èÆÐÆ®¸® - Grrr 3309 366Àü 182½Â 184ÆÐ 49.7 % P No.17 ÀÓ¼ºÃá 3254 - intotherain 348Àü 171½Â 177ÆÐ 49.1 % P No.18 ±èµ¿¼ö 3245 - Garimto 235Àü 135½Â 100ÆÐ 57.4 % P No.19 ±è¼ºÁ¦ 3219 - Intotherainbow 225Àü 133½Â 92ÆÐ 59.1 % P No.20 ÃÖ¿¬¼º 3120 - IloveOOv 143Àü 105½Â 38ÆÐ 73.4 % T (6P 1T 3Z) A lot of P's yes? No.21 ÀÌÀçÈÆ - Foru 3079 296Àü 151½Â 145ÆÐ 51.0 % P No.22 ¹Ú¿ë¿í - Kingdom 3078 204Àü 120½Â 84ÆÐ 58.8 % P No.23 ¼ºÇн - Mumyung 3025 291Àü 150½Â 141ÆÐ 51.5 % Z No.24 ÇÑ¿õ·Ä - Oddysay 2976 225Àü 132½Â 93ÆÐ 58.7 % T No.25 Á¤¿µÁÖ - NiZa 2762 206Àü 115½Â 91ÆÐ 55.8 % Z (2P 2Z 1T) Total: 8 T's 8 Z's 9 P's HOW ABOUT A BIG FUCK YOU TO ALL THE WHINERS!? Courtsey of http://www.pgr21.com | ||
|
Liquid`Jinro
Sweden33723 Posts
On July 18 2004 07:10 smalltoss wrote: say you have 5 ht with 150 energy each, thats 10 storms... say (this is a low estimate too) you get 8 lings with each storm, thats 80 lings, or 40 control of their army gone. as for ultras, i know most people dont do this but maelstrom = godly. i dont know why more people dont use it. sure you might say too much of a hassle to get the required upgrades etc. but you shouldnt be making darchons just for ultraling, on lt 2 darchons could immobilize those 12 harassing muts, and 1 storm and 2~ goons would easily clean up before it wears off. theorycraft in its purest form, but i dont see an imba issue here, if you use your race properly theres always a counter to everything. 5 HT's casting 10 storms = aint gonna happen, sorry Also I never said I think it's imbalanced, because you should be able to prepare your army for ultraling in time unless you've already lost the game But a NORMAL, standard army is not going to win a fight where they are out supplied ~20 supply.And yes, DA's rule and I should use them a lot more than I do (haven't used them for ages, I like sair/dt vs ult - or DT archon). It's great though and I should use it ~_~ | ||
| ||

)