|
On July 18 2004 01:48 green-tea. wrote: Personally, I've made peace with pvz, I know it's arguably imbalanced, and I know they can't change it too drastically in fear of pvt and tvz becoming imbalanced, nor would they, blizz doesn't do anymore balance patches to this gmae. That's why I go gats on 9/10 in most of my games, and later do some crazy kind of cannon contain just to piss them off. then you die LOZLOZl
|
the most important figures are the matchup %'s T>Z 50.2% (i.e. Terrans took a victory over Zergs in 50.2% of all TvZ matches) P>T 51.6% Z>P 54.1%
as these numbers are an indication of game balance. The other #'s are just an indication of what race is popular at the time.
Looks like ZvP needs some balance fixing. 4% is significant when u consider how many games are played every day
|
ZvP doesnt need any balance fixing
|
the only reason pvz sucks is because toss's use normal bo's. learn different bos besides 10/12, 9/10, and temp expo and you should stop sucking.
|
Also don't do anything involving corsairs, or reaver/goon, and don't nexus before gate. And don't cannon cheese for god's sake. Not to mention drops of any kind
|
assuming that the races are balanced (16,666 wins each per matchup) the chance of getting these ratios are pretty low, assuming a normal distrebution the liklyhood of getting a win/loss ratio of 50.2% or better is 76.7%, for the other 2 the value is so high that it just calls it 100%,
ie these matchups are very very unlikly to be balanced. (starting a maths degree in 2 months)
|
Sweden1225 Posts
I agree it's so out of time saying PvZ is imbalanced. These statistics are only LT. For more competitive purposes I think it's more important to make balanced maps, which sometimes succeeds, sometimes doesn't.
Also I'd say the balance is alot different in different skillevels so it's hard to do something about it.
|
On July 18 2004 00:21 tfeign wrote: Yeah that's what I did too, until I took statistic classes in college. So many ways in which statistics aren't what they seem to be  Like, I am very capable of getting 100% winning % over 10 games on ng-i, but there is no way that I can get 100% winning % over 100 games on ng-i. Not even the best koreans can do that. Basically, the higher the number of experiments (games) are conducted, the closer and closer the % should merge to 50%. Try flipping a coin and record the number of heads & tails in 100 throws. The head-tail percentage probably won't be 50% -- May vary 55%-45%. Flipping the coin 1000 times may still vary, but probably no worse than 51%-49%. And if you try flipping a coin 200000 times and record heads-tail ratio. I can guarantee to you the percentage will be 50%-50% or something extremely close to it (like 50.01%-50.99%) If you flip a coin 200000 times and 54.1% heads came up, then the coin or experiment must have been rigged. it's possible for me to flip a coin 2000000000 times and get heads 100% of the time without me rigging it
|
I think 54% (8%! difference) is quite a bit actually, but nothing more than expected
this is LT we're talking about one of the better land maps for PvZ out there (Nostalgia, Jungle Story, Char, and all the new WCG maps are all worse)
|
Sweden1225 Posts
SoMuchBetter,
highly unlikely tho =O as highly unlikely as the travels of the "heart of gold" in the hitch-hiker's guide to the galaxy!
|
Russian Federation798 Posts
I would think that it used to be way more, than 54% for Zerg back in days. Even in 1.08 patch. Not even mentioning 1.07 =) Quite hard to balance it more than it is now.
|
On July 18 2004 03:44 SoMuchBetter wrote: it's possible for me to flip a coin 2000000000 times and get heads 100% of the time without me rigging it the way statistics works.. this chance is 0 and thus impossible :/
|
On July 18 2004 03:44 SoMuchBetter wrote: it's possible for me to flip a coin 2000000000 times and get heads 100% of the time without me rigging it But if that *actually happened*, then I would know that you rigged it or something else went wrong. There's a difference between theoretical possibilities and what actually happens.
|
why does any1 waste their time playing protoss?
It's so obviously imbalanced. And zvt is obvioiusly balanced.
We should just make this game 2 races.
or stop bitching.
|
|
|
This should mean that unfair balance decides every 1 out of 10 pvz games, yet I think some players like to blame balance problems a lot more often.
|
Sweden1225 Posts
zvt balance is really different analyzing different levels of skill i think... (as are they all more or less so this statistics isn't universal!=O)
|
Among lower skill levels, I'd say Zerg is far superior to Terran.
|
Netherlands4540 Posts
i think z vs p is balanced on LT, just all depends on positions
|
I think people whine entirely too much, skills > Imbalance, so stop whining and go practice T_T
|
|
|
|
|
|