• Log InLog In
  • Register
Liquid`
Team Liquid Liquipedia
EDT 16:57
CEST 22:57
KST 05:57
  • Home
  • Forum
  • Calendar
  • Streams
  • Liquipedia
  • Features
  • Store
  • EPT
  • TL+
  • StarCraft 2
  • Brood War
  • Smash
  • Heroes
  • Counter-Strike
  • Overwatch
  • Liquibet
  • Fantasy StarCraft
  • TLPD
  • StarCraft 2
  • Brood War
  • Blogs
Forum Sidebar
Events/Features
News
Featured News
Serral wins HomeStory Cup 2915Serral wins Maestros of the Game 243ByuL, and the Limitations of Standard Play3Team Liquid Map Contest #22: Results and Winners7Code S Season 2 (2026): RO4 and Finals Preview12
Community News
RSL goes to London! 2026 Offline Finals Nov 21-2212Weekly Cups (July 27-Aug 2): SHIN's big week0SC4ALL II: Brood War - $2500 - Dec 5-69SC4ALL II announced - $10,000 prize pool, Dec 5-64PIG STY FESTIVAL 8.0! (13 - 23 August)14
StarCraft 2
General
SC4ALL: II Talent Announcement! Protoss AoE skill expression August World Ranking: Clem climbs to #2 Balance hotfix patch 5.0.16b (July 16) Serral wins HomeStory Cup 29
Tourneys
RSL goes to London! 2026 Offline Finals Nov 21-22 RSL Revival: Season 6 - Qualifiers and Main Event Sparkling Tuna Cup - Weekly Open Tournament PIG STY FESTIVAL 8.0! (13 - 23 August) Tasteless Time Warp: SC Evo Showmatch (May 25)
Strategy
[G] Having the right mentality to improve
Custom Maps
Nexus Wars 2021 GUIDE [M] (2) Industrial Park
External Content
Mutation # 538 Media Blackout The PondCast: SC2 News & Results Mutation # 537 Hostile Territory Mutation # 536 Railroad Switch
Brood War
General
BGH Auto Balance -> http://bghmmr.eu/ ASL22 General Discussion How FlaSh Nearly Forfeited MSL Finals being late Are you ready for ASL 22? NEW HYPE VIDEO BW General Discussion
Tourneys
[Megathread] Daily Proleagues 2v2v2v2 Tournament KCM Race Survival 2026 Season 3 Escore Tournament - Season 3
Strategy
Fighting Spirit mining rates Odyssey Mineral Stack Saturation Any training maps people recommend? Simple Questions, Simple Answers
Other Games
General Games
General RTS Discussion Thread Stormgate/Frost Giant Megathread Nintendo Switch Thread Diablo 2 thread ZeroSpace Early Access is Now Live!
Dota 2
Looking for a Dota Mentor Official 'what is Dota anymore' discussion
League of Legends
[TL LoL EUW IHs] Teemo shall perish TSM pausing esports and CLG Dead
Heroes of the Storm
Heroes of the Storm 2.0
Hearthstone
Deck construction bug
TL Mafia
TL Mafia Power Rank TL Mafia Community Thread NeO.D_StephenKing vs This Guy From 1 Million Dance
Community
General
US Politics Mega-thread Russo-Ukrainian War Thread Iain M Banks Says He Has Cancer And Months To Live European Politico-economics QA Mega-thread The Games Industry And ATVI
Fan Clubs
MarineLorD Fan Club The ShoWTimE Fan Club The herO Fan Club!
Media & Entertainment
Anime Discussion Thread Movie Discussion! Series you have seen recently... [Req][Books] Good Fantasy/SciFi books
Sports
Football (Soccer) Thread NBA General Discussion TeamLiquid Health and Fitness Initiative For 2023 Formula 1 Discussion MLB/Baseball 2023
World Cup 2022
Tech Support
Computer Build, Upgrade & Buying Resource Thread Simple Questions Simple Answers FPS when play League Of Legend on laptop
TL Community
The Automated Ban List Northern Ireland Global Starcraft
Blogs
Are High-Level Gamers more A…
TrAiDoS
Cathedral Of CS And NY pizza a…
FuDDx
Please support my new stand…
Peanutsc
Hello guys!
LIN1s
ASL S22 English Commentary…
namkraft
Poker (part 2)
Nebuchad
Customize Sidebar...

Website Feedback

Closed Threads



Active: 3589 users

[Story] There's rain in the sky

Blogs > hazelynut
Post a Reply
1 2 Next All
hazelynut
Profile Blog Joined December 2008
United States2196 Posts
Last Edited: 2010-04-19 19:54:24
April 19 2010 17:15 GMT
#1
Written for a creative writing class. It's vaguely related to my personal narrative (Counting Leaves, a billion pages long and also in this blog). This story was originally supposed to be a first person narrative of an event that actually happened when I visited my great grandfather's grave, but for some reason, I ended up in the third person and on the other side.

Enjoy, comments and criticisms welcome.

There's rain in the sky

+ Show Spoiler +
She lived in a field of peanuts and sesame flowers, and only came out when she smelled rain thick in the air. Today, rain closely hugged the sky, and ashes hung in mid-air. A flat grey stone stood underneath the rain, buried in green and white and grey.

“Good morning,” she said, absentmindedly.

“Good morning to you, too.”

“It’s raining.” She looked up, and held out her hands. “There’s rain in the sky.”

“Is that why you’re awake?”

The grey from above was smothering, and from time to time, it would give a little sob. Every time it sobbed, a corner of her heart crumbled and washed away in the rain.

“Maybe. I like the rain,” she said. She paused, and slowly added, “I think I like the smell of ashes, too. It means someone’s remembering me, once in a while, whenever they can. I wake up when I smell ashes. It means, ‘good morning!’ to me. Sometimes, I think that someone’s peering into my sleeping face and saying, ‘good morning, I remember you!’ as loudly and dumbly as they can.”

“I’ll remember you,” the companion said earnestly, “even when there aren’t ashes.”

“I believe you.”

Rain and silence hung in the air, until a stray breath unsettled a fragment of ash from the sky. It floated into the peanut vines, alighting on a small white flower. It made a pretty picture—grey ash on white flower on grey stone. She smiled. Someone was crying and playing in the ashes, but she couldn’t see very far in the rain. She looked very carefully at the white of the flower instead. It was very important that she look very hard, although she couldn’t remember why. It looked very white.

“Remember to come out and play once in a while,” the companion pleaded. “I miss you. Grandfather hardly comes out and plays anymore.”

“He used to come out when we were young. Remember?”

“But we were different back then. Younger, and—”

“Is that how you remember it?” she asked sharply.

“Of course I remember. I’ll remember, always—don’t you trust me? Don’t you?”

“Don’t be dramatic, it doesn’t suit you.”

“I do remember, you know!”

“I believe you,” she said, and then she smiled. “I remember, too. Don’t you remember when Grandfather used to plant cucumbers, and mint, and tomatoes? Sometimes he had winter squash.”

“He built a little white fence around it, because he couldn’t keep the rabbits out.”

“Yes, wasn’t that nice?”

“But I liked the rabbits.”

“I did, too.”

“Where do you think they are now?”

“I don’t know,” she shrugged. “Probably dead. Like—”

“Don’t say it like that.”

The ashes were grey, and the sky was grey. She could barely see the ashes, but sometimes, they would glow in an imperceptible moment of orange before darkening forever. The ashes crumbled softly against the sesame flowers, but the crumbs quickly scattered into the air like startled birds.

“They think we’re crying, did you know that?”

“What do you mean?”

“When it rains,” the companion said, holding out his hands and looking beyond the stone wall that enclosed the field, “they think that we’re sad. Sometimes they remember us when it rains, and so they burn things. Don’t you remember?”

“Yes, yes, vaguely. It’s so hard to remember now.” She frowned. “What do they burn?”

“I don’t know.”

“Rabbits, maybe?”

“No, not rabbits. Something that would make us happy. I wouldn’t be happy if they burned rabbits.”

“Me neither.”

“I think it’s paper. Maybe homework, or phone bills, or something. I never did like homework.”

“You’re still young, after all!” she laughed, and rejoiced a little, though she wasn’t sure why.

“They burn it so that we can be happy again, and then it won’t rain anymore.”

“That’s silly. I certainly don’t know how the rain works.”

“But they’re saying it now. ‘The rain stopped. He’s watching and He’s happy.’” He paused. “D—do you hear them? Do you?”

She hesitated. It had stopped raining. She suddenly thought that if she didn’t stand very, very still, she wouldn’t remember the feeling of cold water dripping down her cheek.

“You don’t, do you?”

She didn’t move. Rainwater collected at the curve of her jawbone, dripping onto the stone in large globes.

“Do you?”

Then she moved, slowly and carefully, but by then the globes were already gone.

“Well?”

“No, not anymore,” she finally admitted. She motioned towards the empty space around her, and gave a small smile. “I only smell the rain and the ashes, now. Not much more. But sometimes,” she added quickly (because he had turned towards her with such a look of anguish and fear and loss, and she couldn’t bear it, couldn’t bear it at all—), “Sometimes, I hear someone crying. I hear it in the rain.”

“Let’s listen.”

The two stood in the field of peanuts and sesame flowers, holding hands and holding their breaths as they listened to the stillness in the air. While they waited, the stone beneath their feet remembered their names, and they were grateful. It had stopped raining.

“They love us,” the companion said at last, tears unraveling down his face in ashy ribbons. “I wish I could hear them, they love us so much.”

“Why, I can hear them loving us,” she declared, “and I swear I can see them sometimes, when the rain doesn’t come and make everything fuzzy. But why,” she asked, stomping her foot, “is it getting so fuzzy again?”

“There’s rain in the sky,” the companion said. There was no rain.

Globes fell from her cheeks, and the worlds below felt the tremors of her feet.


*****
Zerg | life of lively to live to life of full life thx to shield battery | www.cstarleague.com <3
d3_crescentia
Profile Blog Joined May 2009
United States4054 Posts
April 19 2010 17:27 GMT
#2
Ah, dearest sister. Your words bring tears to my eyes and casts a weight in my heart.
once, not long ago, there was a moon here
mOnion
Profile Blog Joined August 2009
United States5657 Posts
April 19 2010 17:39 GMT
#3
very lovely ^_^

i like some of the blunt lines like "dont be dramatic, it doesnt suit you" cuz it sort of puts a dent in the 3rd wall that readers enter. it doesnt necessarily break it, but it kinda brings you back from a zone and makes you smile.

☆★☆ 7486!!! Join the Ban mOnion Anti-Trolling Initiative! - Caller | "on a scale of machine to 10, how bad is that Zerg?" - LZgamer | you are the new tl.net bonjwa monion, congrats - Rekrul | "Cheeseburgers dynamite lilacs" - Chill
goswser
Profile Blog Joined May 2009
United States3548 Posts
April 19 2010 19:07 GMT
#4
The grey from above was smothering, and from time to time, it would give a little sob. Every time it sobbed, a corner of her heart crumbled and washed away in the rain.


I really liked how this broke up the conversation that the companions were having, and then the conversation continued afterwards.
say you were born into a jungle indian tribe where food was scarce...would you run around from teepee to teepee stealing meat scraps after a day lazying around doing nothing except warming urself by a fire that you didn't even make yourself? -rekrul
love1another
Profile Blog Joined December 2009
United States1844 Posts
April 19 2010 19:17 GMT
#5
Hi OP. You write like a girl. In a good way!
"I'm learning more and more that TL isn't the place to go for advice outside of anything you need in college. It's like you guys just make up your own fantasy world shit and post it as if you've done it." - Chill
LuckyFool
Profile Blog Joined June 2007
United States9015 Posts
April 19 2010 19:18 GMT
#6
yeah OP no offense but u really write like a girl.

Nice story :D
love1another
Profile Blog Joined December 2009
United States1844 Posts
Last Edited: 2010-04-19 19:24:19
April 19 2010 19:21 GMT
#7
Hmmm. Is the 3rd person of whom you speak the girl in the story? Are you actually a girl? If this is the case I feel really bad because my comment makes your work seem so ordinary when in fact your imagery is very sharp. Ashy ribbons
Fuck. i just checked your profile. You ARE a girl and a Princetonian at that! :D I wonder if you know any of my many friends who go there?!?!?!
"I'm learning more and more that TL isn't the place to go for advice outside of anything you need in college. It's like you guys just make up your own fantasy world shit and post it as if you've done it." - Chill
condoriano
Profile Blog Joined April 2010
United States826 Posts
April 19 2010 19:30 GMT
#8
On April 20 2010 04:21 love1another wrote:
Fuck. i just checked your profile. You ARE a girl and a Princetonian at that! :D I wonder if you know any of my many friends who go there?!?!?!


Ridentem dicere verum quid vetat?
AoN.DimSum
Profile Blog Joined September 2008
United States2983 Posts
April 19 2010 19:35 GMT
#9
YAWN BORING
by my idol krokkis : "U better hope Finland wont have WCG next year and that I wont gain shitloads of skill, cause then I will wash ur mouth with soap, little man."
love1another
Profile Blog Joined December 2009
United States1844 Posts
April 19 2010 19:44 GMT
#10
On April 20 2010 04:35 AoN.DimSum wrote:
YAWN BORING

Go fuck yourself read more literature oh you who does not appreciate the art of the word!
"I'm learning more and more that TL isn't the place to go for advice outside of anything you need in college. It's like you guys just make up your own fantasy world shit and post it as if you've done it." - Chill
hazelynut
Profile Blog Joined December 2008
United States2196 Posts
April 19 2010 19:45 GMT
#11
SHUT UP DLUK

thanks for comments--i wonder what constitutes girly writing? less action more introspection and images?
Zerg | life of lively to live to life of full life thx to shield battery | www.cstarleague.com <3
azndsh
Profile Blog Joined August 2006
United States4447 Posts
April 19 2010 19:46 GMT
#12
i'm confused, it must be because girls are complicated
hazelynut
Profile Blog Joined December 2008
United States2196 Posts
April 19 2010 19:52 GMT
#13
spoiler alert- + Show Spoiler +
they're dead


does that help?
Zerg | life of lively to live to life of full life thx to shield battery | www.cstarleague.com <3
TheAntZ
Profile Blog Joined January 2009
Israel6248 Posts
April 19 2010 19:56 GMT
#14
On April 20 2010 04:45 hazelynut wrote:
SHUT UP DLUK

thanks for comments--i wonder what constitutes girly writing? less action more introspection and images?

no explosions nor descriptions of girls naughty bits
43084 | Honeybadger: "So july, you're in the GSL finals. How do you feel?!" ~ July: "HUNGRY."
love1another
Profile Blog Joined December 2009
United States1844 Posts
April 19 2010 20:05 GMT
#15
They're dead!?!?!?!?!?!! WOW that just revealed a whole new layer of depth. I thought it was a surrealist work of two lonely kids hanging in a cemetery being emo! Just goes to show how bad I am at reading literature. >.<
"I'm learning more and more that TL isn't the place to go for advice outside of anything you need in college. It's like you guys just make up your own fantasy world shit and post it as if you've done it." - Chill
7mk
Profile Blog Joined January 2009
Germany10157 Posts
Last Edited: 2010-04-19 20:25:45
April 19 2010 20:06 GMT
#16
read the story but I don't feel like I read enough literature of this sort. to properly criticise this

I smirked everytime I read the word "peanut" though, considering who wrote this.
beep boop
EchOne
Profile Blog Joined January 2008
United States2906 Posts
April 19 2010 20:40 GMT
#17
Well you asked for CC so I'll try to be helpful.

+ Show Spoiler +
She lived in a field of peanuts and sesame flowers, and only came out when she smelled rain thick in the air. Today, rain closely hugged the sky, and ashes hung in mid-air. A flat grey stone stood underneath the rain, buried in green and white and grey.

// The comma after "flowers" is unnecessary since "She" is the subject of both "lived" and "came out."
// The comma after "Today" is unnecessary, but I can see how it helps the passage read well.
// The word choice in this opening passage isn't especially colorful, which I think aligns with the kind of muddled, dreary atmosphere you may be trying to create here.

“Good morning,” she said, absentmindedly.

// Comma after "said" is unnecessary and I personally feel the line reads better without it.

“Good morning to you, too.”

“It’s raining.” She looked up, and held out her hands. “There’s rain in the sky.”

// The comma. =) I won't note these types of instances anymore.

“Is that why you’re awake?”

The grey from above was smothering, and from time to time, it would give a little sob. Every time it sobbed, a corner of her heart crumbled and washed away in the rain.

“Maybe. I like the rain,” she said. She paused, and slowly added, “I think I like the smell of ashes, too. It means someone’s remembering me, once in a while, whenever they can. I wake up when I smell ashes. It means, ‘good morning!’ to me. Sometimes, I think that someone’s peering into my sleeping face and saying, ‘good morning, I remember you!’ as loudly and dumbly as they can.”

// The imagery is an interesting extension of what's presented in the opening. I'm commenting as I read so I hope implications such as the heart being vulnerable to the elements become connected or relevant. The dialogue gives the heroine a childlike air. Good mix of enlightenment and suspense as to her emotions/motivations.

“I’ll remember you,” the companion said earnestly, “even when there aren’t ashes.”

“I believe you.”

Rain and silence hung in the air, until a stray breath unsettled a fragment of ash from the sky. It floated into the peanut vines, alighting on a small white flower. It made a pretty picture—grey ash on white flower on grey stone. She smiled. Someone was crying and playing in the ashes, but she couldn’t see very far in the rain. She looked very carefully at the white of the flower instead. It was very important that she look very hard, although she couldn’t remember why. It looked very white.

// I really like the use of alight in a situation that speaks of light substances and colors. The suspense is fascinating, and I like how plain colors are consistently emphasized. I don't know if I like the use of "fragment" as the unit for ash as it implies a more brittle, solid nature than what I've been getting from all previous descriptions of it. You might want to explore more ways to describe rain, but that's your choice. So far the style is quite consistent.

“Remember to come out and play once in a while,” the companion pleaded. “I miss you. Grandfather hardly comes out and plays anymore.”

// I'm pretty sure you need a period after "while," but most people aren't strict about grammar in dialogue.

“He used to come out when we were young. Remember?”

“But we were different back then. Younger, and—”

“Is that how you remember it?” she asked sharply.

“Of course I remember. I’ll remember, always—don’t you trust me? Don’t you?”

“Don’t be dramatic, it doesn’t suit you.”

“I do remember, you know!”

// You might want to consider using some active verbs to spice up the dialogue. At this point the "companion" is pretty much a disembodied voice, so some verbs would be totally inappropriate. Although dialogue alone is revealing, readers may still be left guessing as to speakers' tones and attitudes.

“I believe you,” she said, and then she smiled. “I remember, too. Don’t you remember when Grandfather used to plant cucumbers, and mint, and tomatoes? Sometimes he had winter squash.”

// You could probably cut it down to "she said, then smiled."

“He built a little white fence around it, because he couldn’t keep the rabbits out.”

“Yes, wasn’t that nice?”

“But I liked the rabbits.”

“I did, too.”

“Where do you think they are now?”

“I don’t know,” she shrugged. “Probably dead. Like—”

“Don’t say it like that.”

The ashes were grey, and the sky was grey. She could barely see the ashes, but sometimes, they would glow in an imperceptible moment of orange before darkening forever. The ashes crumbled softly against the sesame flowers, but the crumbs quickly scattered into the air like startled birds.

// I'm a sucker for figurative imagery. The one that closed this paragraph was great. You might want to consider avoiding "imperceptible" since it clashes with the style in word choice used elsewhere. Perhaps a blink of orange? A flicker of orange?

“They think we’re crying, did you know that?”

“What do you mean?”

“When it rains,” the companion said, holding out his hands and looking beyond the stone wall that enclosed the field, “they think that we’re sad. Sometimes they remember us when it rains, and so they burn things. Don’t you remember?”

// Here's simple, revealing imagery along with more subtle revelation that the companion is male. I don't quite see how "holding out his hands" is fitting in yet, though.

“Yes, yes, vaguely. It’s so hard to remember now.” She frowned. “What do they burn?”

“I don’t know.”

“Rabbits, maybe?”

“No, not rabbits. Something that would make us happy. I wouldn’t be happy if they burned rabbits.”

“Me neither.”

// That made me grin.

“I think it’s paper. Maybe homework, or phone bills, or something. I never did like homework.”

“You’re still young, after all!” she laughed, and rejoiced a little, though she wasn’t sure why.

“They burn it so that we can be happy again, and then it won’t rain anymore.”

“That’s silly. I certainly don’t know how the rain works.”

// Not quite sure what the heroine is implying by talking about her lack of knowledge of the rain.

“But they’re saying it now. ‘The rain stopped. He’s watching and He’s happy.’” He paused. “D—do you hear them? Do you?”

She hesitated. It had stopped raining. She suddenly thought that if she didn’t stand very, very still, she wouldn’t remember the feeling of cold water dripping down her cheek.

“You don’t, do you?”

She didn’t move. Rainwater collected at the curve of her jawbone, dripping onto the stone in large globes.

“Do you?”

Then she moved, slowly and carefully, but by then the globes were already gone.

“Well?”

// The juxtaposition of his worried questioning and her concentration on the memory of rain was very exciting. This passage definitely didn't need verbs from the speaker to get the job done.

“No, not anymore,” she finally admitted. She motioned towards the empty space around her, and gave a small smile. “I only smell the rain and the ashes, now. Not much more. But sometimes,” she added quickly (because he had turned towards her with such a look of anguish and fear and loss, and she couldn’t bear it, couldn’t bear it at all—), “Sometimes, I hear someone crying. I hear it in the rain.”

// His response seems awkward crammed into parentheses like that. I'm guessing he responded after "Not much more." Putting the response there may read more naturally. Also it's a bit jarring for the reader to be given intense, nonverbal emotion from him since he's offered mainly dialogue so far.

“Let’s listen.”

// I'm still a bit mystified as to whether his distress has been assuaged.

The two stood in the field of peanuts and sesame flowers, holding hands and holding their breaths as they listened to the stillness in the air. While they waited, the stone beneath their feet remembered their names, and they were grateful. It had stopped raining.

// I'm guessing you repeat that the raining is over in order to add finality. I feel that the rain was already shown off stage beautifully, so a reminder shouldn't be necessary.

“They love us,” the companion said at last, tears unraveling down his face in ashy ribbons. “I wish I could hear them, they love us so much.”

// I love the word choice here.

“Why, I can hear them loving us,” she declared, “and I swear I can see them sometimes, when the rain doesn’t come and make everything fuzzy. But why,” she asked, stomping her foot, “is it getting so fuzzy again?”

// I'm unsure if her first "Why" is actually inquisitive or merely an interjection. If it's inquisitive it's probably better off as a one word question. Also, you might not want her to be stomping her foot. I'm guessing she's either stomping or stomping with her foot.

“There’s rain in the sky,” the companion said. There was no rain.

Globes fell from her cheeks, and the worlds below felt the tremors of her feet.

// I like globes and worlds together. With globes already well-used to describe tears, you extrapolate a larger scale out of smaller details. It's unclear whether the tremors of her feet are actually her feet trembling or the shock waves caused by her aforesaid stomping.

// Good work. I'm still left with many questions but it's taken me so long to read and comment, and since I need to go now, by the time I look at this thread again my questions will probably be answered.
面白くない世の中, 面白くすればいいさ
DreaM)XeRO
Profile Blog Joined December 2008
Korea (South)4667 Posts
April 19 2010 20:43 GMT
#18
i liked it :D

oh.. they're dead

that clears up my question
cw)minsean(ru
d3_crescentia
Profile Blog Joined May 2009
United States4054 Posts
April 19 2010 20:44 GMT
#19
rain closely hugged the sky


Men never write about hugs, except for man-hugs, and only then to describe how manly the hugs are.

“They love us,” the companion said at last, tears unraveling down his face in ashy ribbons. “I wish I could hear them, they love us so much.”


And when men cry, they cry only manly tears of passion.
once, not long ago, there was a moon here
hazelynut
Profile Blog Joined December 2008
United States2196 Posts
April 19 2010 22:05 GMT
#20
On April 20 2010 05:40 EchOne wrote:
Well you asked for CC so I'll try to be helpful.

+ Show Spoiler +
She lived in a field of peanuts and sesame flowers, and only came out when she smelled rain thick in the air. Today, rain closely hugged the sky, and ashes hung in mid-air. A flat grey stone stood underneath the rain, buried in green and white and grey.

// The comma after "flowers" is unnecessary since "She" is the subject of both "lived" and "came out."
// The comma after "Today" is unnecessary, but I can see how it helps the passage read well.
// The word choice in this opening passage isn't especially colorful, which I think aligns with the kind of muddled, dreary atmosphere you may be trying to create here.

“Good morning,” she said, absentmindedly.

// Comma after "said" is unnecessary and I personally feel the line reads better without it.

“Good morning to you, too.”

“It’s raining.” She looked up, and held out her hands. “There’s rain in the sky.”

// The comma. =) I won't note these types of instances anymore.

“Is that why you’re awake?”

The grey from above was smothering, and from time to time, it would give a little sob. Every time it sobbed, a corner of her heart crumbled and washed away in the rain.

“Maybe. I like the rain,” she said. She paused, and slowly added, “I think I like the smell of ashes, too. It means someone’s remembering me, once in a while, whenever they can. I wake up when I smell ashes. It means, ‘good morning!’ to me. Sometimes, I think that someone’s peering into my sleeping face and saying, ‘good morning, I remember you!’ as loudly and dumbly as they can.”

// The imagery is an interesting extension of what's presented in the opening. I'm commenting as I read so I hope implications such as the heart being vulnerable to the elements become connected or relevant. The dialogue gives the heroine a childlike air. Good mix of enlightenment and suspense as to her emotions/motivations.

“I’ll remember you,” the companion said earnestly, “even when there aren’t ashes.”

“I believe you.”

Rain and silence hung in the air, until a stray breath unsettled a fragment of ash from the sky. It floated into the peanut vines, alighting on a small white flower. It made a pretty picture—grey ash on white flower on grey stone. She smiled. Someone was crying and playing in the ashes, but she couldn’t see very far in the rain. She looked very carefully at the white of the flower instead. It was very important that she look very hard, although she couldn’t remember why. It looked very white.

// I really like the use of alight in a situation that speaks of light substances and colors. The suspense is fascinating, and I like how plain colors are consistently emphasized. I don't know if I like the use of "fragment" as the unit for ash as it implies a more brittle, solid nature than what I've been getting from all previous descriptions of it. You might want to explore more ways to describe rain, but that's your choice. So far the style is quite consistent.

“Remember to come out and play once in a while,” the companion pleaded. “I miss you. Grandfather hardly comes out and plays anymore.”

// I'm pretty sure you need a period after "while," but most people aren't strict about grammar in dialogue.

“He used to come out when we were young. Remember?”

“But we were different back then. Younger, and—”

“Is that how you remember it?” she asked sharply.

“Of course I remember. I’ll remember, always—don’t you trust me? Don’t you?”

“Don’t be dramatic, it doesn’t suit you.”

“I do remember, you know!”

// You might want to consider using some active verbs to spice up the dialogue. At this point the "companion" is pretty much a disembodied voice, so some verbs would be totally inappropriate. Although dialogue alone is revealing, readers may still be left guessing as to speakers' tones and attitudes.

“I believe you,” she said, and then she smiled. “I remember, too. Don’t you remember when Grandfather used to plant cucumbers, and mint, and tomatoes? Sometimes he had winter squash.”

// You could probably cut it down to "she said, then smiled."

“He built a little white fence around it, because he couldn’t keep the rabbits out.”

“Yes, wasn’t that nice?”

“But I liked the rabbits.”

“I did, too.”

“Where do you think they are now?”

“I don’t know,” she shrugged. “Probably dead. Like—”

“Don’t say it like that.”

The ashes were grey, and the sky was grey. She could barely see the ashes, but sometimes, they would glow in an imperceptible moment of orange before darkening forever. The ashes crumbled softly against the sesame flowers, but the crumbs quickly scattered into the air like startled birds.

// I'm a sucker for figurative imagery. The one that closed this paragraph was great. You might want to consider avoiding "imperceptible" since it clashes with the style in word choice used elsewhere. Perhaps a blink of orange? A flicker of orange?

“They think we’re crying, did you know that?”

“What do you mean?”

“When it rains,” the companion said, holding out his hands and looking beyond the stone wall that enclosed the field, “they think that we’re sad. Sometimes they remember us when it rains, and so they burn things. Don’t you remember?”

// Here's simple, revealing imagery along with more subtle revelation that the companion is male. I don't quite see how "holding out his hands" is fitting in yet, though.

“Yes, yes, vaguely. It’s so hard to remember now.” She frowned. “What do they burn?”

“I don’t know.”

“Rabbits, maybe?”

“No, not rabbits. Something that would make us happy. I wouldn’t be happy if they burned rabbits.”

“Me neither.”

// That made me grin.

“I think it’s paper. Maybe homework, or phone bills, or something. I never did like homework.”

“You’re still young, after all!” she laughed, and rejoiced a little, though she wasn’t sure why.

“They burn it so that we can be happy again, and then it won’t rain anymore.”

“That’s silly. I certainly don’t know how the rain works.”

// Not quite sure what the heroine is implying by talking about her lack of knowledge of the rain.

“But they’re saying it now. ‘The rain stopped. He’s watching and He’s happy.’” He paused. “D—do you hear them? Do you?”

She hesitated. It had stopped raining. She suddenly thought that if she didn’t stand very, very still, she wouldn’t remember the feeling of cold water dripping down her cheek.

“You don’t, do you?”

She didn’t move. Rainwater collected at the curve of her jawbone, dripping onto the stone in large globes.

“Do you?”

Then she moved, slowly and carefully, but by then the globes were already gone.

“Well?”

// The juxtaposition of his worried questioning and her concentration on the memory of rain was very exciting. This passage definitely didn't need verbs from the speaker to get the job done.

“No, not anymore,” she finally admitted. She motioned towards the empty space around her, and gave a small smile. “I only smell the rain and the ashes, now. Not much more. But sometimes,” she added quickly (because he had turned towards her with such a look of anguish and fear and loss, and she couldn’t bear it, couldn’t bear it at all—), “Sometimes, I hear someone crying. I hear it in the rain.”

// His response seems awkward crammed into parentheses like that. I'm guessing he responded after "Not much more." Putting the response there may read more naturally. Also it's a bit jarring for the reader to be given intense, nonverbal emotion from him since he's offered mainly dialogue so far.

“Let’s listen.”

// I'm still a bit mystified as to whether his distress has been assuaged.

The two stood in the field of peanuts and sesame flowers, holding hands and holding their breaths as they listened to the stillness in the air. While they waited, the stone beneath their feet remembered their names, and they were grateful. It had stopped raining.

// I'm guessing you repeat that the raining is over in order to add finality. I feel that the rain was already shown off stage beautifully, so a reminder shouldn't be necessary.

“They love us,” the companion said at last, tears unraveling down his face in ashy ribbons. “I wish I could hear them, they love us so much.”

// I love the word choice here.

“Why, I can hear them loving us,” she declared, “and I swear I can see them sometimes, when the rain doesn’t come and make everything fuzzy. But why,” she asked, stomping her foot, “is it getting so fuzzy again?”

// I'm unsure if her first "Why" is actually inquisitive or merely an interjection. If it's inquisitive it's probably better off as a one word question. Also, you might not want her to be stomping her foot. I'm guessing she's either stomping or stomping with her foot.

“There’s rain in the sky,” the companion said. There was no rain.

Globes fell from her cheeks, and the worlds below felt the tremors of her feet.

// I like globes and worlds together. With globes already well-used to describe tears, you extrapolate a larger scale out of smaller details. It's unclear whether the tremors of her feet are actually her feet trembling or the shock waves caused by her aforesaid stomping.

// Good work. I'm still left with many questions but it's taken me so long to read and comment, and since I need to go now, by the time I look at this thread again my questions will probably be answered.


Thanks for the C&C. For the comma usage, I usually intentionally shove commas in to make the sentence read differently and throw regular grammar to the winds, but I'll definitely play around with how the sentences read with and without the commas.

// Not quite sure what the heroine is implying by talking about her lack of knowledge of the rain.


This is a world where it gets harder and harder to remember--if they were still alive, in the world where their descendants burn money/food/cigarettes/wine, they would probably understand their earthly superstitions about rain and spirits (aka it's raining and it stopped, it means your great grandfather is happy). Instead, in this world, they forget their past beliefs and memories until rain is no longer a memory or symbol, but an imprint.

// I'm guessing you repeat that the raining is over in order to add finality. I feel that the rain was already shown off stage beautifully, so a reminder shouldn't be necessary.


I think this was a case of throwing in another hint for the readers, to make sure they understood that it wasn't raining. There are a few cases of over-hinting, I think, to say "OMG THEY'RE DEAD," but I'm not sure if it was quite enough.

Not sure what I, personally, think of the companion having hands and the girl having feet. It kind of ruins the tone for me, but then again, I don't want them to be completely disembodied.
Zerg | life of lively to live to life of full life thx to shield battery | www.cstarleague.com <3
1 2 Next All
Please log in or register to reply.
Live Events Refresh
The Patches Monday
16:00
#2
Clem vs MaxPaxLIVE!
RotterdaM1315
TaKeTV 412
TKL 393
IndyStarCraft 232
SteadfastSC175
ZombieGrub132
Liquipedia
[ Submit Event ]
Live Streams
Refresh
StarCraft 2
RotterdaM 1315
TKL 370
IndyStarCraft 232
MaxPax 209
SteadfastSC 175
ZombieGrub132
ProTech75
StarCraft: Brood War
Hm[arnc] 106
HiyA 24
Dota 2
NeuroSwarm0
Counter-Strike
Fnx 1225
Super Smash Bros
C9.Mang0220
Heroes of the Storm
Liquid`Hasu459
Other Games
Grubby2674
Beastyqt889
shahzam672
FrodaN533
ToD224
ArmadaUGS152
QueenE60
[ Show 15 non-featured ]
StarCraft 2
• kabyraGe 222
• Hupsaiya 52
• AfreecaTV YouTube
• intothetv
• Kozan
• IndyKCrew
• Migwel
StarCraft: Brood War
• BSLYoutube
• STPLYoutube
• ZZZeroYoutube
Dota 2
• masondota2588
League of Legends
• imaqtpie3342
• TFBlade1045
• Shiphtur477
Other Games
• Scarra682
Upcoming Events
Sparkling Tuna Cup
13h 3m
PiG Sty Festival
15h 3m
PiGosaur Cup
1d 3h
Replay Cast
1d 12h
Kung Fu Cup
1d 14h
Replay Cast
2 days
The PondCast
2 days
Replay Cast
3 days
CranKy Ducklings
4 days
Sparkling Tuna Cup
5 days
[ Show More ]
Afreeca Starleague
6 days
Rush vs Hm
Bisu vs Shuttle
WardiTV Weekly
6 days
The Patches Monday
6 days
Liquipedia Results

Completed

Proleague 2026-08-09
CranK Gathers Season 4: BW vs SC2 Team League
Eternal Conflict S2 Finale

Ongoing

KCM Race Survival 2026 Season 3
K-JUNGMAN
Acropolis #5
Proleague 2026-08-10
RSL Revival: Season 6
Esports World Cup 2026: LCQ
BLAST Bounty Summer 2026
BLAST Bounty Summer Qual
Stake Ranked Episode 3
XSE Pro League 2026
IEM Cologne Major 2026
Stake Ranked Episode 2

Upcoming

Escore Tournament S3: W7
CSLAN 4
ASL Season 22
Escore Tournament S3: W8
Acropolis #5 - TRS
Blizzard Classic Cup 2026
Acropolis #5 - GSA
HSC XXX
SC4ALL II: StarCraft II
Kung Fu Cup 2026 Grand Finals
RSL Offline Finals
PiG Sty Festival 8.0
Big Dog Cup 2026 Div 1
META DYMY #4
Thunderpick World Champ.
ESL Pro League Season 24
Stake Ranked Episode 4
Logitech G Connect 2026
SL StarSeries Fall 2026
FISSURE Playground #5
BLAST Open Fall 2026
Esports World Cup 2026
TLPD

1. ByuN
2. TY
3. Dark
4. Solar
5. Stats
6. Nerchio
7. sOs
8. soO
9. INnoVation
10. Elazer
1. Rain
2. Flash
3. EffOrt
4. Last
5. Bisu
6. Soulkey
7. Mini
8. Sharp
Sidebar Settings...

Advertising | Privacy Policy | Terms Of Use | Contact Us

Original banner artwork: Jim Warren
The contents of this webpage are copyright © 2026 TLnet. All Rights Reserved.