EPTEU-Ranking - Page 6
| Blogs > DiaBoLuS |
|
zeru
8156 Posts
| ||
|
DiaBoLuS
Germany1638 Posts
Xlord * --> ** Nerchio *** --> **** Insolence ** --> * (unsure yet) | ||
|
s4life
Peru1519 Posts
happy, beastyqt and nerchio too low.. | ||
|
Zeon0
Austria2995 Posts
And Jinro is hard to assess, because we dont see many games of him. Why isnt he owning GSL like a few months before? :/ I support Nerchio up to 4 and Xlord up to 2 (might even be 3?). cant rate Inso, saw like zero +/- 1 game of him in the past weeks. Beasty is not a the same level as Goody and Tarson imho | ||
|
teekesselchen
Germany886 Posts
I think Mondragon is at least on a level with Haypro, Ciara, Kubas, Grubby, Insolence and Goody, but obviously it's hard to rate a player with that low appearance. As for Goody, he's really shaky. Not that he was bad, but inconsistent in his results. Not sure if he's too high or rated just right. Delphi at least has the potential to be higher imo. Just introduced to LAN events -and didn't perform poorly there, either- and takes quite some maps and matches off players rated better than him. He played really well against ClouD and Hasu (though it was probably easy for him to prepare as theyre all EPS players, too). Further: Unsure about Nightend. Is he really that high? Last time I saw him was him losing against an uplayable-ping-boxer. Also about Happy, I don't see his 3-rating justified so far. | ||
|
DiaBoLuS
Germany1638 Posts
On May 01 2011 19:15 teekesselchen wrote: Really good ranking overall. I think Mondragon is at least on a level with Haypro, Ciara, Kubas, Grubby, Insolence and Goody, but obviously it's hard to rate a player with that low appearance. As for Goody, he's really shaky. Not that he was bad, but inconsistent in his results. Not sure if he's too high or rated just right. Delphi at least has the potential to be higher imo. Just introduced to LAN events -and didn't perform poorly there, either- and takes quite some maps and matches off players rated better than him. He played really well against ClouD and Hasu (though it was probably easy for him to prepare as theyre all EPS players, too). Further: Unsure about Nightend. Is he really that high? Last time I saw him was him losing against an uplayable-ping-boxer. Also about Happy, I don't see his 3-rating justified so far. well, 1-2 vs socke and 2-0 vs tarson aint bad - or? honestly hes nearer to 4 stars then to 2 stars. another chance next week: stephano ** --> *** Jinro ***** --> **** | ||
|
teekesselchen
Germany886 Posts
On May 01 2011 23:54 DiaBoLuS wrote: well, 1-2 vs socke and 2-0 vs tarson aint bad - or? honestly hes nearer to 4 stars then to 2 stars. another chance next week: stephano ** --> *** Jinro ***** --> **** I think there are many ** rated players able to get a single map off Socke (even some one star: xlord, mondragon, delphi imo), and Tarson is only 3 stars, too. But to be honest I don't see much off Nightend, so you probably got the better image of him. Changes on Stephano and Jinro are definitly deserved. | ||
PhiLtheFisH
Germany442 Posts
GoOdy *** -> ** (hasn't won a public game for like 3 weeks?) | ||
|
Finrod1
Germany3997 Posts
T: Jinro * less. Sadly he just performs in the gsl and so its hard to jugde but either way around he needs to be jugded on only this results then.  ThorZaIN * up. I truly think he is really really top class player on a level with Kas. He just plays lesser open tournaments. ClouD * less. Performed not so well against delphi in the german eps and in the last tournaments he participated in (today against stehpano) P: HasuObs * up. Just truly mad results the last weeks. At those french lan, the eps, the nasl, the tsl.,.. I would switch Mana and Grubby just based on the last results. Z: Morrow * up. Just maybe. Not so sure but i think he is getting on the same lvl as dimaga. ret * down maybe? Performed not so well on the las events. Stephano deserves * more for sure.  | ||
|
Velr
Switzerland10990 Posts
On May 02 2011 06:13 Finrod1 wrote: Solid ranking overall. My suggestions: ClouD * less. Performed not so well against delphi in the german eps and in the last tournaments he participated in (today against stehpano) Ahm, he went to the final in a pretty tuff field? Yes, his play in the final wasn't the best but alone to get there has to count . | ||
|
teekesselchen
Germany886 Posts
On May 02 2011 06:13 Finrod1 wrote: Solid ranking overall. My suggestions: T: Jinro * less. Sadly he just performs in the gsl and so its hard to jugde but either way around he needs to be jugded on only this results then. ThorZaIN * up. I truly think he is really really top class player on a level with Kas. He just plays lesser open tournaments. ClouD * less. Performed not so well against delphi in the german eps and in the last tournaments he participated in (today against stehpano) P: HasuObs * up. Just truly mad results the last weeks. At those french lan, the eps, the nasl, the tsl.,.. I would switch Mana and Grubby just based on the last results. Z: Morrow * up. Just maybe. Not so sure but i think he is getting on the same lvl as dimaga. ret * down maybe? Performed not so well on the las events. Stephano deserves * more for sure. Jinro: definitly deserved, as Diabolus already said it himself, too. Thorzain: Perhaps wait a little longer? I think he really exclusively produced good results in GSL so far, but nowhere else. ClouD: Hmm, borderline. He is really weak against Zerg lately I think,but apart from that still a force to be reckoned with and easily bashes lower rated players, with a supremacy that definitly justifies the gap. It's pretty much the same as Idra imo: Not that good results against the players above him, but absolutely constantly perfect results against players below him. Hasu: Really close one. 5* is really somewhat of an exclusive top class so far, Hasu might be like 4.5*. Grubby 3*? No, I don't see that happen quite yet, his results weren't that good either. And by no means I see him beeing stronger than ToD already. Mana ** perhaps, but I don't really have him on screen to have a valid image. Morrow up? I thought him to be rather disappointing lately and by no means having an upward tendendy. Even losing to Grubby 3:0 iirc? That hurts. No way he has the consistency and raw skill of a 5* imo. Ret on the other hand I find really well rated like that, maybe with a verry slight downward tendency, but he usually should have the skill to claim a 4*. | ||
|
kix
Germany20 Posts
XlorD ** Stephano *** Bischu? Cloud *** | ||
|
DiaBoLuS
Germany1638 Posts
he is still a top class player imo. Ciara... well you just dont get to see too much of him. i think ** are still ok. Same goes for Bischu, dont know i could * him i guess. Xlord/Stephano get upgraded as i said, just like Nerchio. Hasu is indeed close to ***** - the thing is that im a huge fanboy of him and dont wanna overrate him too fast xd | ||
|
bgx
Poland6595 Posts
tbh some players would be inbeetwen some ranks :p have u ever considered adding 1 more star and spreading it more ? :D | ||
|
DiaBoLuS
Germany1638 Posts
Added some changes, you can pretty much call it Version 2 of StarRanking! + Show Spoiler + Changes: - a bit bigger for more space to put names in - added skillgaps - 2 categorys for each Star-Rank Example: A lower *** can be count as ~2.8 (DarKFoRcE), a high *** can be count as ~3.2 (Happy) In the race distribution i count the full Stars though. €: Forgot Bischu as higher * - well, mistakes happen i guess^^ If you like this list, plz spread the link anywhere! Would appreciate it pretty much | ||
|
teekesselchen
Germany886 Posts
About Goody as 3+: Let's say I "hope" you're right, because I'm a big goody fanboy :D He might be the most inconsistent player of all of these, but yeah, I guess a 3-rating is fine. | ||
|
DiaBoLuS
Germany1638 Posts
Deleting the 1* category. that means, 2** will be the new 1*, 4**** will be the new 5***** some changes between players as well ofc. | ||
|
DiaBoLuS
Germany1638 Posts
as i mentioned before, there is only 1*, 1*+, 2*, 2*+, 3*, 3*+, 4*, 4*+ left - that means, the list of players got a lot smaller. | ||
Noam
Israel2209 Posts
I do totally support this project and often link people to it | ||
|
DiaBoLuS
Germany1638 Posts
well, its hard to make graphics that look good but are dark enough or bright enough to make names easy to read^^ €: Added a Replaypack of me, just for fun whoever wants to watch some games^^  *click* | ||
| ||
