EPTunless full obviously
Assassination Mafia!
| Forum Index > TL Mafia |
|
KelsierSC
United Kingdom10443 Posts
unless full obviously | ||
|
KelsierSC
United Kingdom10443 Posts
On May 09 2015 03:00 Blazinghand wrote: pregame excuses, expect like, 1 post from me tops on mother's day, i'm gonna be hanging out with my mom get in line | ||
|
KelsierSC
United Kingdom10443 Posts
what time? | ||
|
KelsierSC
United Kingdom10443 Posts
On May 10 2015 09:04 rsoultin wrote: 1! hay naku o.0 necesito usar los numeros como prp, ja? es mejor lol hi ^^ yay for game finally starting lol so much hype! \o/ towniest town who ever towned por supuesto, who is the next towniest?  you only know if you're town, you don't know how towny you are yet | ||
|
KelsierSC
United Kingdom10443 Posts
On May 10 2015 09:30 LightningStrike wrote: So with a 10 post limit I might resort to like a Geript Student V style for this phase. 1st person to use post limit excuse 1 mafia down | ||
|
KelsierSC
United Kingdom10443 Posts
On May 10 2015 09:36 LightningStrike wrote: I not mafia it just it going to be hard for me to post with only 10 posts allowed this phase. you have used 3/10 already 1 to say hello and then 2 more to say you are going to play like someone else and that you will have a hard time posting seems like you are trying to cover potential inactivity/shit posts already, not looking good. for you. | ||
|
KelsierSC
United Kingdom10443 Posts
On May 10 2015 09:57 Onegu wrote: Man I really hope I get the traitor just realized I can get that. Then I can be scum!!! No if you were traitor you would know by now. rsoul you got a mafia yet? | ||
|
KelsierSC
United Kingdom10443 Posts
On May 10 2015 10:26 Trfel wrote: Hello. I was going to make some huge entrance post for this game, which I figured that approximately zero people would read. But then I didn't have enough time, so I didn't.My name is Trfel. So instead, I'll just cut to the point. I had this great toneread on Half the Sky, and then I realized that rsoultin already commented on the same thing. I agree that Half the Sky's "happiness" does feel very forced. I'm also somewhat suspicious of LightningStrike. Not for wasting posts, but for justifying a lower posting (and higher content) style by saying he will play like someone else did in a game isn't necessary at all. If LightningStrike wanted to use a low post count style because of the post limit, I would expect him to just go ahead and do that (and quite possibly announce what he would be doing). But I really don't understand why he would justify this by comparing it to someone else in a different game. I would be inclined to think that KelsierSC is town, but this post gives me pause.Rsoultin already expressed that she is suspicious of Half the Sky, so I'm really not sure why KelsierSC is asking this. KelsierSC has no reason to say this, so it feels like buddying to me. she made a post with a lot of words in it but I had no idea who was mafia. | ||
|
KelsierSC
United Kingdom10443 Posts
On May 10 2015 10:43 Trfel wrote: Which shows that you did not read the post very carefully at all. You seem willing to be present in the thread and to talk with people, but you aren't reading carefully. Suspicious. + Show Spoiler [Explanation] + On May 10 2015 09:43 rsoultin wrote: First, there aren't actually that many words. It's just a post with a lot of quotes and white space.2! ay! but don't you want to be the same alignment as me? since you think i can suss you out 100% of the time? lolmmmm happy dance doesn't seem too happy  town here. stop. again. stop. then happy dance? i dunnae hts we may be on opposing sides again :/lol yeah? oh damn, you caught me xP shoulda read my pm! (the role changes how towny i am, does it? xP such odd ideas you have, ksc) hmmm try hard right from the start, ja? pero i don't know why you'd want to waste a post on saying my role pm changes my level of towniness, any more than why ls would waste a post saying hi before commenting on a geript student V style posting strategy one post and i'm already your favorite person, net hubby? lol >< that's awfully quick, no? what makes you think so? (besides me saying so )Yamato-kun! how happy are you today? lol...finally ending that scum streak maybe? I colored rsoultin's post as indicated by her statements. She's pushing at least the same level of suspicion on multiple people as you are with you own accusation (that rsoultin's made a wordy post with no scumreads). pushing suspicion isn't calling someone mafia, hence the question. | ||
|
KelsierSC
United Kingdom10443 Posts
On May 10 2015 11:11 Bill Murray wrote: Hey guys. This is going to be tremendous fun. With a group of players this good, I know that I will be improving my play. I don't care to give some general questions for everyone as well. 1) How do you rate yourself in terms of your play? 2) How do you rate others in terms of their play? 3) What would you change about your play? no one got time for that, just look at the game so far and give your thoughts or just make a better post. | ||
|
KelsierSC
United Kingdom10443 Posts
On May 10 2015 11:20 Damdred wrote: This is almost as bad a read as me saying GB is town just saying. However at this point I have a couple of preliminary town reads I believe just by tone and posting style and somewhat on content. Rsoultin seems to be genuinely using the posts to press good ideas while pressing issues that are important in the thread. HTS and Trfel both seem to have a good tone about them and it seems it is easy to follow what they mean while it somewhat mirrors what RS says I think it is a good sign of things to come and both are good leans. KSC... is a bit harder for me to get a handle on at this point, I have a slight town lean on him. His tone and general demeanor remind me of Void Mafia at this point. However his style is also reminiscent of mini mafia to an extent, but the content is different. I'm pretty ok with him at this point. LS is interesting, he always wastes posts but we'll see what his other posts do. I'm a bit confused damdred Rs is pressing good ideas and important issues , but the only "good" idea she has really pushed is that HTS has a forced tone and is mafia. | ||
|
KelsierSC
United Kingdom10443 Posts
On May 10 2015 11:27 Damdred wrote: The most impressive part is that you ignored the trutly contradicting things I put into the post but key'd in on something that I actually believe. (3) you believe HTS has a forced tone and is mafia? but you just wrote she has a good tone about her. that is what is confusing me, how can rs have good ideas about hts but hts have a good tone to you? | ||
|
KelsierSC
United Kingdom10443 Posts
On May 10 2015 11:29 Trfel wrote: What do you currently think about rsoultin, then? Oh hush, you... Anyway, I didn't repost the player list... I originally added the filters, the official player list is a copy-paste of the player list that I posted I'm obviously biased about myself... but Half the Sky only made one post, with nothing of actual value.Do tell me how you managed to arrive at your conclusion from this post? I don't really understand why people are so quick to call rsoul town. Nothing jumps out at me as being particularly townie. A lot of people seem quick to call her town and sort of buddy up. She is bringing up the points she things are important but I don't agree with all of it. i don't agree with the HTS read and the rest of what she says is pretty lacklustre | ||
|
KelsierSC
United Kingdom10443 Posts
On May 10 2015 11:35 Damdred wrote: I'm glad that Trfel and KSC seem to be thinking critically now. Your original question kel was a little lacking but the follow up was much better I think. Firstly I don't necessarily have to agree with someones read on them to like the direction that they are going in the way that they are posting or the ideas they are pushing. I think that HTS tone is decent in the post and I just kind of tacked it on to see who would call me out on it while they were reading. Plus it got some more conversation going (5) sorry but this feels like a planned play to get yourself townread rather than actually trying to accomplish anything. | ||
|
KelsierSC
United Kingdom10443 Posts
Damdred - probably the person i've been struggling with the most. I didn't like his early rsoul read but he has defended it pretty well, I also didn't like his prepared play, to be honest it didn't look like it achieved much, but I guess Damdred decided Trfel and I were town from it and got called scummy for it. It seems a strange thing to do as scum, so i'm not going to wide eyed over it. I think his GB reads were actually quite strong post (8), they seemed to come from a town perspective. following on from that he has been active this phase and generated a lot of discussion so overall I think he is town for now. Talkingdead - I liked the initial thoughts on GB, about how he gives a magic read then gives crappy explanations, but I don't know where this town-town and mafia-mafia business came from , absolutely no reason for this to be the case. I think his top town read is yamato which. no offence intended, is a bit of a stretch. He makes the point about rsoul being townread for bad reasons, already did it, easy thing to say. Then the end of his post is a desire to policy lynch BM. It's a on balance feels scummy to me. GB - Never really know what GB is doing, if it was a battle between GB and damdred then damdred wins but I don't know if it makes GB completely mafia. the points GB made were that GB has inconsistent reads and that "you townread X for this but not Y" well the point is people read others on different criteria my town tell isn't the same as others. if you take out this aspect against GB then there isn't a lot left. He has gone back and looked over his reads and made some alterations which is a towny thing to do. overall I think he is town but this isn't a strong read VE Just a tone thing so far that feels town , when I see more substantial reads then I will make more of a commitment. rsoul - Lot of people call her town but I don't really know her style, her posts give me brain cancer. If you break down what she has said so far the only real commitment is HTS is scum, everyone else is "leaning town" or "town" trfel - initial post was a buddy to rsoul and was trying to twist my actions into being scummy, didn't really like this but then his cross examination of myself and damdred could be a town trying to figure out the game. I really can't figure him out Lightningstrike - called him scum because his first 3 posts were terrible and he has run away like a scaredy cat. pretty weak response overall No one else has stood out to me or been significant, probably makes you null so far , I will take questions if you want | ||
|
KelsierSC
United Kingdom10443 Posts
On May 10 2015 20:17 marvellosity wrote: hey Kels. Why does anything you say about TalkingDead make him mafia, deary? This postcount thing making people just list reads feels really weird :p I have Damdred as towny and GB as he has done a few things I don't like so it's giving me a bad vibe. | ||
|
KelsierSC
United Kingdom10443 Posts
I don't think you have said anything particularly controversial in your post, things are sort of "odd" "pretty bad" "we shall see", can you go against the wall of text style and maybe give some towns and some scum? if you don't have any then just say that | ||
|
KelsierSC
United Kingdom10443 Posts
On May 10 2015 23:30 Xatalos wrote: Not really except the really strict post restriction. I can't read the LS post TLDR / conclusions, if any?KSC: I can sort of agree with the fact that making weird plays (Damdred) more often comes from town. It's just that this assumes that it *was* in fact a prepared play and not to cover up questionable reads. In any case, how exactly did LS's post make you change your read? I at least couldn't really extract anything from it. well, my initial scum read on him was because the first few posts were terrible and didn't say anything. He said he was going to post in a specific, albeit terrible, way and now he has actually made a contribution to the game I don't have any reason to scumread him anymore. I'll reevaluate him when he gives more as his post didn't break any new ground, null for now | ||
|
KelsierSC
United Kingdom10443 Posts
On May 11 2015 01:34 Half the Sky wrote: 2/10 I'm back. Catching up. Though this jumped at me and I see others are saying it. It's generally a scum tendency to not want to draw attention to themselves. Why are you afraid to lean one way or another on someone? Generally when you meta read someone or compare points on meta you're a bit more confident. In Newbie LX I was scum, but here if my entrance is not great, I only "could" be scum? I'm a bit confused by this HTS, i;m reading through the Newbie LX game and in that LS seems to not be calling you scum at the beginning but you are claiming he strongly meta read you as scum that game? On January 05 2015 09:28 LightningStrike wrote: Are you implying that HTS is scum for her post? I don't see it scream scum. Also I don't got a How To Find Scum Guide ready just yet. On January 06 2015 11:46 LightningStrike wrote: Guys I just got back and I will fully explain my thought process on the stuff. #1 @Exo I had some reads that I said I needed more posts to figure out their alignment so I should of just said Null instead of the comments I said and I know I don't have any real scum reads just yet and I still trying to figure out who is scum and who is not atm #2 @JarJarbinks I'm a guy not a girl gosh you and Robik keep calling me a girl -.- But thanks for the defense but that HTS post that everyone over analyzed not mine. #3 @HTS After reading some posts I decided to just read as Null but leaning town after people told me his post was a drive by post and left a lot to be desired but now I starting to town read him #4 @Everyone here I now going to full explanation of my reads 1. rsoultin: Town: she been trying hunt for scum like her normal self in Student Mafia IV and Carol of the Bells Mafia where she was Vanilla Town in both games. 2. Half the Sky: Town: She made some silly posts at the start yes but everyone over analyzed them but not unusual from her type of entrance since she did similar entrances in Student Mafia IV and Carol of the Bells Mafia and she been asking some good questions towards The Shining and been following through her questioning and also defended her posts in a manor I feel townie from her. 3. ExO_ Town: He actively been scum hunting throughout today and trying to pressure people and normally this type of behavior comes from town players and honestly I not really confident in my scum reads unless it's based on meta on players I played with in other games. 4.Tubesock: Null leaning town: His posts seem to lack any content but his posting style seem to be the same as he did on Carol where I mislynch him like a dumbass in that game but I looking foward to solidify my town read on him. 5. -Celestial-: Town: He been trying to scum himself but he seem to lack confidence on his end on his reads which is something I notice on newer players on forum mafia coming from SC2 Mafia but he doing some decent questioning too. 6.JarJarBinks: Null: His posts seem to lack content but he said he is sick and I hope he feels much better soon but he also needs to step it up if he's town and help us find scum. 7.Grumdrop: Null: He not posted since his entrance post and hope he posts more but for now I need to place him somewhere so Null is the best place for him atm due to the lack of posts from him. 8.Tfrel: Null leaning town: He seem to be inactive but it due to irl so I hoping he post more tomorrow but he had some good questions on his few posts since the game started but we shall see. 9. Silverate: Null: I need more posts to get a clear read on her since she posted so little and I hope she post more tonight and tomorrow! #5 @Tubesock I will give context to that post you said was worthless. HTS earlier in the thread asked me for my reads on the newer players at the time so that why I posted those reads. | ||
|
KelsierSC
United Kingdom10443 Posts
On May 11 2015 02:00 Half the Sky wrote: 3/10 Kelsier - Through the course of the game yes - particularly when I was pushing him D2 and after I died, he was calling me scum hardcore (the only one to do so) in that game. You'd have to read either in the obs qt or the post-game but he was particularly noted for being the only one to scumread me all game, that's how he stuck out that game. Also Kels, I find it interesting you pulled that up because in this game he's saying He's saying that because I was scum in Newbie LX, that my opening this game could be alignment indicative. Though that still raises an interesting point. Why does he say "alignment indicative" instead of straight up calling me scummy or leaning scum on me? ah ok I get what you're saying now. you're saying he should very much be calling you scum or town because of the previous game in which you were scum. I thought you were saying at the beginning of that game he called you scum which isn't how I read it. LS has been pretty all over the place so far , kind of looks like floundering scum, pressured into a read and shows a bit of push back calling HTS scum, then instantly retracting and now calling her town. On May 11 2015 03:25 LightningStrike wrote: Town she had some good large posts on analyzing stuff about GlowingBear and is thinking critically. so LS do you agree with the analysis that HTS did ? HTS I also don't like TD , but i don't agree with your reasons. point 1 is kind of meh, if you don't like someone you can give your read and a reason without asking them a question. Point 2 is ok , I sort of think at first glance the argument damdred puts forward looks strong and it certainly comes from a townie place, but is actually weak in retrospect, I definitely think not explaining why the argument is weak is a negative for him. for point 3 I don't know if he blows it out of proportion, he hasn't really pushed any agenda as far as i'm aware. As i said, he did some stuff I didn't like but nothing like concrete I guess. Your GB points are interesting but I don't think they make him mafia. You don't have to respond every time someone calls you scum or if someone else doesn't share a scumread with you. I think GB is town for some reason But I like the effort your putting in and you have pushed some interesting stuff so I like you so far. | ||
| ||
