EPTNewbie Mini Mafia LIII
| Forum Index > TL Mafia |
|
mtamburini
Canada506 Posts
| ||
|
mtamburini
Canada506 Posts
| ||
|
mtamburini
Canada506 Posts
| ||
|
mtamburini
Canada506 Posts
| ||
|
mtamburini
Canada506 Posts
| ||
|
mtamburini
Canada506 Posts
| ||
|
mtamburini
Canada506 Posts
| ||
|
mtamburini
Canada506 Posts
On March 06 2014 06:00 IAmRobik wrote: this logic is good....maybe a little TOO good. honestly, pretend none of us know each others' habits because most likely. Mine will be the same as my video mafia play, because I've played forum mafia for way longer and translated my forum game into my video game, whereas they're going in the opposite direction. Anyway, forgetting all that, what is your take on the interaction between Moose and me? When I first read IAmRobik and Moose interactions, I was ready to lynch both of them cause I thought there would one between them for sure just based on the fact of them attacking each other. However that view changed once sqrt posted that their opinion on the matter was it was two towns fighting. I'd like an explanation on it as maybe you see something I dont. I am more inclined to sheep Roberts read on the situation and it sounds a little too good. On March 06 2014 06:08 sqrtofneg1 wrote: As it is a new game type for me also. The interaction between Robik and Moose is, I think simply townies probing for information. Which is great. I say we probe everyone, especially those who haven't posted since the game started. But, if the interaction between you two becomes a hostility, then all the mafia need to do is to you guys fight it out, ending in a couple of free kills. I kinda like your answer here, but I'm not ready to clear them both as town just yet. On March 06 2014 06:42 mirks wrote: Moose seems his usual self from what I can translate from video to text, and something is very off with robik. I'll have to verify with his past games if he normally plays this aggro. I can agree Mirks that Moose is kinda acting like himself. But nothing has changed with IAmRobik play from Video to Text. He still be super AGRO and calling shit as it is. He is leaning more town for me then Moose just because I see more of a consistency in his play. For you not to see that seems a little fishy to me. I will say this about IAmRobik. He generally plays the same way as both allignements so I do not have a read on him, but it is leaning towards town. Cruisette when I read that you were Ride or Die with me I was ecstatic. Then you let IAmRobik change your mind so quickly! Whyyy  Feelings hurt </3I have not been able to read you correctly in video mafia, but I want to say that you flipping your Ride or Die so quickly reads a little scummy to me. Inb4 IAmRobik's 2 posts | ||
|
mtamburini
Canada506 Posts
| ||
|
mtamburini
Canada506 Posts
On March 06 2014 09:09 mtamburini wrote: When I first read IAmRobik and Moose interactions, I was ready to lynch both of them cause I thought there would one between them for sure just based on the fact of them attacking each other. However that view changed once sqrt posted that their opinion on the matter was it was two towns fighting. I'd like an explanation on it as maybe you see something I dont. I am more inclined to sheep Roberts read on the situation and it sounds a little too good. I kinda like your answer here, but I'm not ready to clear them both as town just yet. I can agree Mirks that Moose is kinda acting like himself. But nothing has changed with IAmRobik play from Video to Text. He still be super AGRO and calling shit as it is. He is leaning more town for me then Moose just because I see more of a consistency in his play. For you not to see that seems a little fishy to me. I will say this about IAmRobik. He generally plays the same way as both allignements so I do not have a read on him, but it is leaning towards town. Cruisette when I read that you were Ride or Die with me I was ecstatic. Then you let Moose change your mind so quickly! Whyyy Feelings hurt </3I have not been able to read you correctly in video mafia, but I want to say that you flipping your Ride or Die so quickly reads a little scummy to me. Inb4 IAmRobik's 2 posts EBWOP | ||
|
mtamburini
Canada506 Posts
Inb4 sqrt post | ||
|
mtamburini
Canada506 Posts
Having pointed that out Moose, I still like IAmRobik for the way he is been acting this game, I guess we are not gonna agree on Cruisette's allignemnt at this moment in time. I really liked what she had to say in her first post but then her second post made me flip my read her. It felt almost like you she was looking to get on someones good side (me) then when you called her out on there is no reason why she should like me right now (which is true I had posted only one thing), she did a 180. I can see her doing this to not look scummy and/or try to get on people's good side. She could also be a confused town looking for direction, but im more inclined to think she is scum looking to side with a townie or not be read as scum when called out for it. So for those reasons, I think Moose you might be town here and my circle is you and IAmRobik. ##Unvote: Moose_ I agree with sqrt that people who have not posted anything yet should begin to post or be replaced so we can get reads on them. | ||
|
mtamburini
Canada506 Posts
On March 06 2014 12:21 Cruisette wrote: I am confused town trying to find the way through this game safely. Though what you said here is very fishy considering you now have Moose in your town circle. You must not have considered anything Sqrt has said. So my entire quote was the following. On March 06 2014 09:42 mtamburini wrote: Apologies I was typing a whole lot of information. I like all your reads IAmRobik they align with mine at the moment. I think I am considering Cruisette my most scummy with Moose just behind her. I don't think they are together at the moment but she was easily convinced to flip her read without much questioning. I dont think you would've missed the last thing I said, you guys are probably not aligned so at one point I will have to choose between the both of you if it comes down to it. The way you guys interacted I dont think you guys could be together at the moment. Also to respond to sqrts post. On March 06 2014 10:46 sqrtofneg1 wrote: CPHoya, Thorgear, and Pretzelshop haven't posted. ##Vote Pretzelshop Because you haven't said anything, and because I don't like pretzels. Should we lynch Pretzelshop if they do not continue to post today? inb4 Moose post | ||
|
mtamburini
Canada506 Posts
With regards to Thorgear post it I feel like after 3 pages of posts they would have a lot more to give to us. My question for Thorgear, you think sqrt is town for the questions hes asking. What do you think of his reads? Inb4 robert post inb4 Moose post | ||
|
mtamburini
Canada506 Posts
On March 07 2014 09:28 sqrtofneg1 wrote: . Doesn't want to lynch the players who haven't talked yet because they could be modkilled/replaced. Says he feels like the people who want to lynch them are just picking on people who can't defend themselves, which is possible. But I have a feeling he doesn't want them to be lynched because one of the people who are inactive are his affiliation. I read soft mafia. Im sorry but I think its pro town to lynch someone who is actually participating in the game because you can actually get reads on them and make somewhat of an educated decision on what they have said and done. Lynching someone who has not said anything who could easily be replaced by someone who wants to participate and we can get a read on. | ||
|
mtamburini
Canada506 Posts
On March 07 2014 14:25 Thorgear wrote: what are peoples thought on not lynching today? With 9 people it is generally a good idea to lynch someone. When we have a odd number of people living, we are in a good position. We have mislynches that can be used to kill mafia. If we do not kill mafia and we hit a town, we still gain a lot of information. We can look at everything that they posted and treat them as honest reads meaning that they were not fabricating any of their reads. | ||
|
mtamburini
Canada506 Posts
My town totem pole goes as so. CPHoya has made one post but said a lot of things and made good analysis of what has been going on. IAmRobik | ||
|
mtamburini
Canada506 Posts
On March 08 2014 03:42 mtamburini wrote: Im very conflicted in my vote today. My town totem pole goes as so. CPHoya has made one post but said a lot of things and made good analysis of what has been going on. IAmRobik Some how it posted half of what i wanted to say. Im very conflicted in my vote today. My town totem pole goes as so. CPHoya has made one post but said a lot of things and made good analysis of what has been going on. IAmRobik I like the way he has been pressuring everyone trying to get reads of them. I dont necessarily agree with his reads but I like the way he is going about getting them. Sqrt Although I have not seen many reads come from them, but CPHoya pointed out the way they have been talking seems extremely towny so I am willing to trust him on that. Mirks Hes been acting kinda strange but like me he is new to forum mafia, might be going to get information in the wrong way. Thor His first post seemed very vague and basic post considering how many things had happened since then was expecting more from them considering everything that was going. Moose My moose read is kinda strange I didnt like the interaction between him and Cruisette so that is why he is more at the bottom of my pole Cruisette Has been very wishy washy this game flipping on her reads. I posted before she is just trying to get on everyones good side and not making any enemies. ##Vote: Cruisette | ||
|
mtamburini
Canada506 Posts
Pros to sleeping. We will live to see tomorrow and cannot lose today with a mis lynch. Also reducing out numbers can be a good thing as there were a lot of day 1 interactions that we can start to consider if another fellow townie dies in the night. Cons. Mafia kill off another townie and they can control the voting better tomorrow and can hammer with some late votes if our analysis is wrong. I find it odd that people are talking about if they were roleblocked. Maybe I don't understand what that means but I feel that everyone responding to that is bad for town as mafia could be role hunting (if we have any roles). Suggesting you were not roleblocked just hints that your not a role and mafia can jus come out and say I wasn't roleblocked. do voyageurs get told if they are roleblocked? Depending on the answer of I get from the mod I will further evaluate that read on people asking about getting roleblocked or not. More to come on my lunch break. | ||
|
mtamburini
Canada506 Posts
On March 07 2014 01:12 Moose_ wrote: So my biggest issue with, "just waiting on people to reply" and never worrying about them is currently there is 2 people who have yet to post, if we probe each other all day here and start scum hunting within us eventually one will turn scum. What if the 2 people who have yet to post are the scum so we wasted all this time reading each other to get false reads. So although i am so for only reading the people posting unless they get replaced soon i am okay lynching them. So this post here would be my biggest strike against moose right now. The fact he was willing to kill someone who hasnt posted and could potentially be replaced seems scummy to me. Although this is kinda a thing done in video mafia (lynch the quiet people), If he has perfect information he can easily push that mislynch. Reading more into his post today he was the first to post so he could quickly suggest something from the night kills as mafia generally kill people so they can set up discussion for next day. Today we will most likely be going to seep and I do not know how everyone feels about giving out their top 2 scum at this point as it could dictate who the mafia are gonna kill tonight and try and meta it but I think discussion should still happen today at the very least. | ||
| ||
