Newbie Mini Mafia XLIX

On October 14 2013 16:28 OdinOfPergo wrote:



Makes a good point, but would it really be all that smart for scum to play risky?
I don't necessarily agree with his post but I don't see it as scummy.

On October 14 2013 17:19 E00e wrote:
Hello everyone, my first post!

I think the discussion about a semi random lynch or an afk lynch was somewhat pointless because the day is still early and we might find something else to lynch on. In the rare (?) case that we dont get any information we can argue about that again.
On that topic I dont think it is reasonable to immediately vote for SagaZ (who suggested afk lynch first) like istandwithmitt did.

I like that GGTeMpLaR started giving thoughts about the players in this game, because ultimately we need to do that to find our lynch target.

Something else we could and maybe should discuss is when the Cop should come out. Should they come out after checking X Mafia or Y Town or when they are about to be lynched, etc...
We dont need to do that on the first day and I dont want to sidetrack the discussion but it is something to keep in mind for the next day or if we run out of things to talk about.

On October 16 2013 10:32 OdinOfPergo wrote:
So why don't you?
You complain about a lack of details.
Yet you don't ask any questions.





Here were my reads and reasoning, I voted for mitt because of the fact that he was written off day one with his own post's; yes admittedly they had more stronger of a case then myself but they were still bad IMO. As the day went on I started seeing the voltin votes going through, but i chose mitt in the end because he was IMO a bad town, he was playing like it and although now it's night one and he's still the same. Save us all the headaches and deal with it like we should of night

SagaZ what do you think about Templar as of now ? Do you agree with his reasoning on pg 18 of why we should vote for mitt? I was assumed to be attempting to fly under the radar with the voltin votes what if i asked you the same thing, do you think you flew under the radar of suspicion, the only one here 100% town is seus, I know we'd all like to develop a town circle but it's always best to stay on your toes don't you think ?

I'd also like to here from the rest of the town on SagaZ and your reads on him.

Expanding my thought's later I'd like to hear the answer's first .





So you actually do think that wasting a vote on Istand is a worthless vote.
You're pretty much admitting to just taking the easy vote?
The Nyx statement at the end was just a very brief rehashing mixed with a "Oh look, I'm helping"
Nyx's one liners are the same use of Instands at this point to me.
The only thing he hasn't done is post anything but them.



Everything short of reading what you seriously already posted?
Did you read the two and a half pages before it?
"Oh his post are worse than mine" If this is true why are you still around?
Why is Nyx getting the nice crumble of a supposed tip?
Why do you choose mitt over Vontin?
Are you trying to pull the weight off your scum buddy?
I don't like this.
Vonthin is a strong lynch for the town right now.
You could of gone from one no poster to another.
I only remember a few post that got brought up.

##vote July617

On October 17 2013 06:57 OdinOfPergo wrote:
+ Show Spoiler +

The main problem I have with Nyx is the fact that his post lack any content.
If you glance back over right before the end of day 1, I mention that I'm also not willing to lynch him for that fact.
If I'm not going to assume Istand is for sure scum for the same style of posting, how can I assume it for sure on Nyx?
This stops me from voting for him but I'm still going to try to get some pressure on him to step it up.
I'm sure you remember the flurry of crap Istand got for this.
His latest post are actually attempting to remedy this to an extent. Why can't I pressure Nyx and hope for the same?
Right now especially, since people are pairing me with his lack of content.
I've spent this whole game being fairly open about how and why I view players the way I do.
If he had posted any sort of thoughts on why he was following me maby I wouldn't mind this as much.
What else, other than probe for answers, can I do?


(This doesn't mean I think very highly of either of them.
Simply that I can't really deem either as for sure mafia.)





+ Show Spoiler +

Ok July,

I'm going to change my perspective on this and look at it from yours.
You're pushing into this from a point of "Well, I don't have any 100% scum reads, and nothing else has been posted to fully convince me of any. This being the case, I'm going to vote Istand because even if he's town he's just dead weight."

I only understand this off the basis that you don't find anyone else's arguments for lynches worth following.
I don't really understand why you would just ignore them then.
Why not try to post critisism on them if you questioned their reasoning?
Wouldn't that be better for the town anyway?

On October 19 2013 07:33 Balla24 wrote:


Hahaha. You turned me to pissed off to laughing and smiling fast. But still. Fuck you! ^_^

Let's look at July: this guy has less than a page of filter, with a lot of one liners. I'm reading over it now. The only hard stance he has taken was against istandwithmitt, as soon as that vote didn't go through, he backed off. After that he hasn't taken any more. All he's done is tentatively marked people as town.

Remember this fishy post that Bereft originally pointed out (he completely ignored it so far):



And what I pointed out before:



Since then, he hasn't posted at all. It's hard to get a read on him, I know, but at least pressure him instead of me (with your vote, feel free to continue pressuring me without your vote as I'm quite sure i've made it clear I will respond to your pressure).