Some Mafia Game

On September 08 2011 00:56 sandroba wrote:


Yo iGrok, if you are going to start a RVS why do you go out of your way to make it neat and make it seem justifiable? You ought to know that's no valid reason to vote, why make it seem so?

On September 08 2011 08:04 sandroba wrote:
Sup I don't think GGQ is scum. Suspcious people to me so far are iGrok and xfttfc whose behaviour day1 is 100% different than mafia xliv. xftc is being too absurdly confindent about his reads and even basing an entire scum team out of them when the game was only one page long (LOL). The whole notion is so ridiculous that to me it seems he is over compensating for his behaviour in the last game where he was townie and was found scummy by a lot of others. Makes no sense for a townie to throw acusations into 4 players this early with so little info, but it makes a lot of sense for scum to try to create this sort of confusion. I'd like you gather your thoughts and post in a more coherent manner until I decide if you are scum or not.

On September 08 2011 10:45 sandroba wrote:

You pretty much started the shit fest day1 with your arbitrary vote and then tryed to make it seem it had some thought behind it, when it was clearly a random vote. Your response seem to be trying too hard to justify it, instead of just admiting it was shitty reasoning and you were only trying to get discussion going. In sumary your first post didn't sit well with me and your response did not help either.
I'd actually like your opinion on someone that has posted in this thread.

On September 08 2011 02:59 iGrok wrote:

I consider that a valid reason to vote. With no setup knowledge other than my own role, I'm a little on edge anyways.

On September 08 2011 11:52 sandroba wrote:

Man iGrok, why so dodgy? Is it wrong of me to interrogate you to try to determine your aligment? You sure don't like the heat do you?

On September 08 2011 12:19 wherebugsgo wrote:


Oh sheet

iGrok: "I vote this guy for random reason X"

bunch of other people: "I vote this other guy for random other reason y/z/a/b/c"

sandroba: "iGrok why you so scummy why you gotta start shit bro"

iGrok: "I not scummy just look at this guy and this guy they started it! don't blame me bro its their fault"

sandroba:

""

me:

Wtf this guy's scum. He's dodging "responsibility" on a supposed random vote.

If it was a random vote and you didn't start the shitfest then why you so dodgy, iBro? Why you gotta shift the blame to other people instead of manning up and defending your actions? We aren't responsible for you!

##unvote bumatlarge

##vote iGrok

for me its because you put so much effort in defending yourself, if iGrok sends sublimal messages hes afraid of the pressure you are literally screaming it. Also in a very interesting game like this you go after the lurkers...

On September 09 2011 07:11 BayonnetAnderson wrote:
Nice summary, shame it fails to contribute anything. Are you going to defend yourself? Or should we just lynch you? As far as to my true identity, you can *guess* at what it is, but I think you'll be surprised later. Either way, its a moot point, you are scum, and you are not getting anywhere fast by posting a "summary", that as wonderful as posting "lurker lists", a great way for scum to blend in.

Seriously people, can we kill him already?

On September 09 2011 07:33 BayonnetAnderson wrote:
I'm not going to enter a yelling contest with you. Nice OMGUS however, quite classy. Oh and you failed to address any of the major points in my analysis, but hey, if you can't beat an argument, ignore it, right?

I'm out for the next 5 or so hours. I will attempt to make it back before the deadline, no promises however. Calling all day1 posting "fluff" is hardly going to help us find scum. You are better than this, step it up.

Either way, the town should know who to vote for.

On September 09 2011 09:06 Palmar wrote:


Did you roll scum again?

Just explain to me, if you were scum, what's the mentality behind doing exactly what iGrok is doing? Why would any scum ever do what he did? He's drawing attention to himself, he's putting his neck out there with an opinion. I'd much rather look at people who are trying to skirt by with little posting and just calling out people for policies.

iGrok is a bad lynch, that's an opinion, you say I don't explain it enough, that's not actually an opinion on me being scum, it's a policy. If I wrote an analysis would I cease to be scummy? You're actually playing right to your scum meta of looking for "scumtells" and trying to lynch people on them instead of thinking about it.

Mig is probably our best lynch tonight, he's not this bad as town. Pushing bad lynches is mig's favourite shit to do as scum. Remember this if you have a gun tonight.

I'll be voting Mig.

##Vote Mig

I'm gonna re-read ggq's posts, iGrok is almost definitely town, so if it comes to it I'll rather support a ggq lynch

On September 12 2011 02:12 chaos13 wrote:


You died.