On August 15 2011 07:21 TheAwesomeAll wrote:
all the talk about rival claiming is rubbish btw, its not in the interest of rivals to claim, so its not going to happen. for example:
Riv1: im rival with riv2
riv2 : no he isnt.
riv1 dies a horrible dead and riv 2 wins. Also if the become confirmed town there is no way they can lynch the other, wether its best for the town or not, there is no way in hell rivals are going to claim. Any 2 rivals that do claim are probably scum covering each other.

This very much makes and overall rivals shouldn't be important for all of the non-rivals (keep an eye out for any claims that seem like it just comes from another rival) but other than that we should really ignore the matter.

As for role-claiming I'm against it for now as all it does at this point is help the mafia pick targets.
If anyone disagrees I'd be glad to hear why.

DroneAllDay

United States140 Posts

August 16 2011 19:21 GMT

#372

Ok so from what I've seen I'm going to vote for Nisani off of what is a pretty bug scumslip. Which means that if Nisani is scum Greymist is definitely scum too. But first we need to lynch Nisani.

DroneAllDay

United States140 Posts

August 16 2011 19:21 GMT

#373

Ack I meant scum not bug sorry iPods are really bad with auto correct.

DroneAllDay

United States140 Posts

August 17 2011 19:48 GMT

#491

On August 17 2011 11:18 Varpulis wrote:
i'm going to sleep.

droneallday, why the stealth vote?

I believe that I covered the idea that Greymist was pretty scummy in the post where I voted for Nisani, and just from the influx of information I figured that changing votes was a good idea, sorry if it's standard to announce it, it's my first game of mafia.

Also Curu, I believe that if I have nothing unique to contribute then I shouldn't because all I give is more spam for the town to gather information from.

DroneAllDay

United States140 Posts

August 17 2011 22:06 GMT

#496

Looking back into the thread I don't know why we forgot the whole old batch of suspects in the thread, because to me Forumite, (I might have spelled that wrong if so sorry otherwise please ignore this statement) but from what I've seen he was hesitant to lynch Greymist and he was gunning for JeeJee the late detective to me this seems fairly scummy and I don't like the fact that he has slipped off the lynching table.

DroneAllDay

United States140 Posts

August 17 2011 22:08 GMT

#497

On August 17 2011 10:41 Navillus wrote:
I'm voting forumite until he comes out and gives us a more recent opinion than that jump on the nisani wagon and FoS of jeejee.

##Vote: Forumite

I almost forgot to mention this too, the late Navillus was also gunning for him some.

DroneAllDay

United States140 Posts

August 18 2011 23:19 GMT

#566

Yeah from what I've seen I personally believe that whether or not the rival thing is true I don't care but I'm gonna attribute the whole pm thing to Trotske being a newbie for the time being but I'm putting him on my radar. But it does seem that Jackal is hiding something and overall I still do not trust Forumite.

DroneAllDay

United States140 Posts

August 19 2011 00:28 GMT

#572

On August 19 2011 08:36 Jackal58 wrote:

Show nested quote +

What am I hiding? Why the fuck would I hide anything. If DropBear thought I was scummy do you really think he would include it in PMs to me? Is there any thing any where in the PMs where roles are discussed? Either his or mine? Or traits? Or anything like that? No. Because we never discussed roles or traits. He asked me if I was a rival with ON because of my first post in the game. That was the extent of it. The person the he claimed to is Nisani. Not me. Nisani makes a scum slip day 1. Then claims DT. Then claims DB told him he was medic. Then claims he checked a dead guy. Are you guys so fucking stupid that you're going to buy this shit??????? If Nisani is a DT I'm fucking Mother Theresa.

I'm saying the pms you showed does not make me think dropbear gave you information to make him think that if he died you were scummy, but obviously he did, otherwise he would not have said as such, which means you are hiding something, which means you are acting scummy. but to be honest I'm not giving any of Nisani's check worth too for those same reasons all in all my opinion at least one of the three of you are scum, if not multiple of them (that and there are 2 DT types and each only detects a certain kind of scum. so I don't find the detectors too useful in this game).

DroneAllDay

United States140 Posts

August 19 2011 01:04 GMT

#575

On August 19 2011 09:31 Jackal58 wrote:

Show nested quote +

Of corse he didn't PM somebody and call them scum. See how long the conversation lasts.

What I said was that there was a pm with information that would make dropbear think that if he died, you were probably scum, not that you had a scum slip or something, and we don't see that information in any of your pms with him, and seeing how dropbear is/was rational, that leads me to believe that there are more pms to read.

DroneAllDay

United States140 Posts

August 19 2011 01:12 GMT

#576

with that said, I'm more confidant that Forumite is mafia so i'm voting for him due to the fact that the others i belive to be scum voted for greymist, that those who voted for him are dead (even if 1 of those was done by a vigilante hit, the other is still a scum hit) and his hight post count but a fair amount of them are just hello, good night, and other such no-content posts that feigns lurking.

##vote: Forumite

DroneAllDay

United States140 Posts

August 21 2011 06:32 GMT

#673

I sorta agree with syvern, just one thing that we need to be careful of is that Dropbear was very clearly town so that while I do think Nisani is pretty scummy, we must also remember that Dropbear might have died without the mafia knowing he was the protector just because Greymist, who was to become confirmed scum on lynch was advocating to kill bear. But that being said I'll say it again Nisani seems like scum, so I'm voting for him.

##Vote: Nisani201

DroneAllDay

United States140 Posts

August 22 2011 17:39 GMT

#705

I've said it before and I'll say it again, I find forumite to be scummy and I'm voting for him, especially now that we have a chance to lynch him. (and this time I'm gonna remember to post in the voting thread lol.

##Vote: Forumite