On July 18 2010 12:29 tree.hugger wrote:
Also, I'd like to once again push the plan of creating a list of FIVE or FOUR inactive players, and then using a random number generator to determine the lynch target. There are many ways we can do this, whether by using the amount of games SKT manages to take off of CJ tonight (well, we'd have to assign 0 to somebody) or some other random metric. Hell, someone could even stream it on their livestream.

One could argue about the likeliness of certain outcomes, so I think using an RNG would be alot better

bumatlarge

United States4567 Posts

July 18 2010 20:27 GMT

#462

The "not lynching 1st day" has been discussed to death in other games. It is 99% of the time a disadvantageous plan, even with a small number of people. In the overall scheme of things we need to get rid of someone by town decision, and we have alot of posts to base it on. We have an ok shot at hitting a mafia right here so I suggest we do it.

-Don't hit an EXTREMELY active person. They could be mafia, but they are putting themselves out there and will eventually be weeded out.
-Don't hit those in danger of modkills. If they do some last minute stunt, well massive FoS on them for it.

The above list looks ok, but I'm going to shy away from Darth, because I called him out another game for being way too helpful (weird, but he was red that game) and hes trying something different. I'm going to give him the benefit of the doubt that he's just changing up his playstyle to avoid getting killed again, and I'm not implying that it seems scummy at all for him. Please reconsider as of this moment. Darth WOULD lift a finger to defend himself the same way no matter his role. I think he knows this so he's gonna try his luck. In fact I think hes blue, because I havent seen him play it, and it's a different style, so Im going to take some heat for him right now and ask that if you really are bent on voting for darth, vote for me instead

Young seems green imo and Ketomai is still in DANGERZONE.

Hyperbola seems like a viable candidate from what I read, BUT SO DOES DIVINEK (DIEDIEDIE)
... ok I'll let him slide today

unvote
##Vote Hyperbola

bumatlarge

United States4567 Posts

July 20 2010 01:30 GMT

#582

On July 20 2010 08:45 Pandain wrote:
BumatLarge's post:Look! I can change the text! is far more long and detailed than BB's. Finally, his post seems more pro town than mafia(of course he could be lying. Dang this game is hard.) Compare this with BB's post, which as others have noted is very suscipious and fallible.

MUHAHAHAHA- Ahem...

*vigorous nodding*

I've never played in a game where the Godfather's role cant be disclosed and there are no clues (that I remember), so that seems like an issue to me, at least later on if he plays quiet and doesnt hesitate to throw a scummer under the bus every once in awhile. And I can't really pin my finger on whate he would pick as his mask, as a smart one could safely assume towny, or deviously take a DT role and waste town a few days. The only comfort I have is that they are sticking with one role, so we base our info on that later on when some DT checks come along and we can really do some soul searching

Darth you are weird. But some DT is gong to check you so BEWARE. Unless you are GF. Boy wouldnt that lead to fun times.

bumatlarge

United States4567 Posts

July 20 2010 13:59 GMT

#692

Poor brownbear, suprised only one person is calling out darth for his posting

youd think mafia would jump on the chance of a towny greenclaiming Godfather. Unless hes mafia, then it all makes sense. You may argue that D3 could be scum, but would you really run head first into a vote as mafia without trying to at least convince someone that certain posting is detrimental. And if darth is red, then divinek is an easy pick after. I mean, hell why not lynch everyone darth has accused after. I think he might be trying to get caught. I see no traitor role. If you agree with me I suggest ignoring everything darth says after this.

##Vote DarthThienAn

bumatlarge

United States4567 Posts

July 20 2010 19:37 GMT

#725

Eh, it just seems typical of him to do this. I think too many people are accusing him that there isnt a single red between them. You may argue that lynching BB is beneficial either way, but we dont really get much info from that death. Although it isnt really RNG at this point, we can still choose the person who would give us the best results. I can't really think of a better candidate then DTA.

I know it may put FoS on me, but what would it benefit me to go out and protect him if we were both scum? Pray everyone blindly follows us and hope DTs dont check either of us? The votes on day1 dont help my point but lol,,, Hope to god he isnt red.

Subversion looks scummy though you can lynch him all the way

bumatlarge

United States4567 Posts

July 20 2010 20:17 GMT

#729

Maybe if you and BB switched places Id believe you. Time to switch into the darth I know buddy

While DTA is my top concern, the more I read into subversion, the more obvious it seems, and as treehugger mentioned, that mafia mistake quote day1 is really wtf. I dont think anyone has the balls to say that. Ill have to make sure to say that next game XD

bumatlarge

United States4567 Posts

July 20 2010 20:25 GMT

#731

Ive heard of shoving your foot in your mouth, but sub basically ate a scuba flipper whole, shat it out, took pictures and posted it on the internet, then assumes no one will find that outrageously gross. You would have to be a freak, and in this case scum.

Unvote
##Vote Subversion

bumatlarge

United States4567 Posts

July 21 2010 14:34 GMT

#850

Would incriminating yourself be FoS?

bumatlarge

United States4567 Posts

July 22 2010 04:35 GMT

#1312

You're credible when you're dead. Sorry darth

bumatlarge

United States4567 Posts

July 22 2010 04:58 GMT

#1338

On July 22 2010 13:43 Pyrrhuloxia wrote:

Show nested quote +

and bumatlarge

And what woodwork would I have come out of? I was satisfied with my vote on subversion and explained why, and I wasn't against darth or chaoser being lynched either, not one over the other, so really I had no reason to post and waited for night. Its a shame darth was green, as his posts are now just random vanilla towny actions with barely rhyme or reason, but we have a good number of votes to analyze now, so that should lead to alot of posting I'll need to catch up on tomorrow. Hopefully night will give us even more. I would protect subversion tonight as he's either blue or red, even though mafia might pass over him based off day 2. Hope I get shot tonight >:D

bumatlarge

United States4567 Posts

July 22 2010 23:10 GMT

#1424

We could just WIFOM the hell out of the reds by bomber logic!

Alright so let's say subversion s blue of an unknown type. Scum would sacrifice they're bomber on the offchance that a blue is vsiting him. Sub has already proved to be disadvantageous to the town along wth being one of the chief suspects town has, so they would be relyng that another blue is visiting him, which imo is worth the bombers life if one is at least a DT or med. Now, multiple townies are recognizing that the bomber has a strong chance of hitting sub, and any cautous blue (which is most) wont touch that guy anyway. And if hes just green trying to save himself? And no one visits him? HAHA losers. And ifs hes truly red, DTs wont worry. Honestly blowing the bomber on a less then subpar person with a crasphoot chance that a blue feels the need to act on sub s an awful lay for scum so early nto the game. And you would rsk a ht on someone who clamed blue, hasnt done much and is already under the magnifying glass.

So blues will do whatever they think best leaning against not acting on sub, and scum can consder wastng a memeber when there are 22 other townes around

WIFOM brought to you by mentos, the freshmaker. /ts allowed when used against them, right?

bumatlarge

United States4567 Posts

July 23 2010 00:37 GMT

#1438

Thats because you could then see what the night people were doing if you had your head up. This isnt 5th grade mafia. (Im only saying that because in 5th grade, that's exactly what we would do

)

bumatlarge

United States4567 Posts

July 23 2010 05:07 GMT

#1545

yawn is the post gonna be up soon i need to get my beauty sleep

bumatlarge

United States4567 Posts

July 23 2010 18:00 GMT

#1704

I think we should hold off lynching tricode and iniaite double lynch tommorrow. A DT should check either of them, i wont say which because of the bomber, and then PM someone (i have no idea who it depends on DTs checks, but id suggest a random vanilla he checked previously that is unlikely to be GF) to give results. If BC is mafia, he was forced to come forward or else the medic would call him out, but I also thinks he could be a lucky godfather who can get the max use out of his disguose by this (hes a sure fire candidate depending on the red team). Either way, i think tricode being red would be giving it away if hes checked, so in my opinions hes 95% vig. If I was DT I would consider PMing him, but then FoS on me for suggesting who the DT should PM

Also reds hit inactives right? What about other inequally inactive players who did not get hit. Southrawrea ive never played with but ill assume hes new. If it was my firtish game, id stay quieter then normal. Laxer and xelin also, but i cant really check (id feel stupid if they actually have been posting more then me -_-) on my phone properly. Just suggesting to look at those who scum didnt hit.

tldr - hold off the BC/tricode vote and gun for a lesslikely blue inactive

##vote southrawrea
vote doublelynch