1. WeWinMafia - he's either mafia or very very stupid. I don't know which right now. Like Artanis just said, he could well be a mafia vigilante.
2. ObviousOne - didn't give a shit about anything day 1.
3. Coagulation - same as OO. Says grush and risk are mafia for resisting the lynch, but coag fucking came into the game not long before the end, said "lol" and fucked off again. Left his vote on some outside candidate. What the fuck. What scares and depresses me is that he could still be town.
4. Mattchew - sandroba said it, he never mentioned yamato. his post after the lynch ("I would have lynched grush, hopeless, or artanis") just seems fucking weird. Don't get it.
5. marvellosity
6. syllogism sandroba thinks he's town, which is already kinda enough. It was syllo's post right at the death that snapped me out of my reverie and made me do the right thing, which from a personal point of view made me feel good about syllo.
7. HiroPro - solidly pushed yamato. And yet I'm not sure he's town. Odd suspicions of me... meh. The colour is how I feel about him.
8. Vivax - really less aggressive and loud than when he's town. It shouldn't be right to hold someone being rational against them. And yet also was pushing Zess right at the death. Meh.
9. Zessionar - so, he should be town because of Day 1. Yet if Toad is town, I somehow think Zess might be mafia. I know it's not overly rational, but we've seen wagons on two mafia before (hello Bureaucracy). This is just a conspiracy theory for now. His pushes on grush, risk, me are frankly terrible. If it's LYLO and he's alive, kill it with fire.
10. Hopeless1der - came up with a defence that was totally unexpected to me when I made a case on him, which made me give him massive townie points. And yet has been totally uninvolved since. Watch dis guy.
11. Artanis[Xp] - has never really been on my radar as mafia. hammered yamato. he did defend yamato before, but then so did I. One curious thing is that he was proactive about finding grush's meta tonight, and yet for the whole of day 1, didn't go and find yamato's meta. Why not? This niggles me.
12. risk.nuke - again hammered mafia. less lurky than i expected for him to be mafia i guess. I kinda like his reactions to the yamato lynch actually. Think he's town.
13. yamato77
14. grush57 - I give a very high confidence that grush is green. If this comes to lylo, don't let him be the mislynch, or i will kill you post-game.
15. layabout - lurkier than i'd like, but decent logical pushes when he's been around. don't see why he should be mafia right now.
16. sandroba syllo has made no mention that he thinks he could be red, which is heartwarming (like the other way round). He also posts all the posts I agree with. For example who he thinks should be vigid/DT checked. And what he said about Matt. In Chrono Trigger, he seemed kinda subservient to syllo, here it's not like that at all.

Artanis[Xp]

Netherlands12968 Posts

February 16 2013 22:49 GMT

#1083

Oh okay nevermind

marvellosity

United Kingdom36161 Posts

February 16 2013 22:52 GMT

#1084

This reminds me very much of a game on omgus.net

bugs was smurfing there, I was playing, VE was playing, possibly coag too. There was some really pointless suspicion being shovelled at me for stupid things (like here - for hammering mafia. WHAT THE FUCK). The night-kill mechanics were weird, and bugs, as mafia vigilante, shot me on the pretense that I had been acting suspicious. But it was a load of shit and he was mafia.

marvellosity

United Kingdom36161 Posts

February 16 2013 22:52 GMT

#1085

P.S. he got away with it. don't let toad.

WeWinMafia

Bahamas102 Posts

February 16 2013 22:53 GMT

#1086

btw I lied to see if marv has a spreadsheet.

Good thing I didn't shoot Marv I guess.

marvellosity

United Kingdom36161 Posts

February 16 2013 22:55 GMT

#1087

either you or super are scum, I think.

Artanis[Xp]

Netherlands12968 Posts

February 16 2013 22:55 GMT

#1088

On February 17 2013 07:53 WeWinMafia wrote:
btw I lied to see if marv has a spreadsheet.

Good thing I didn't shoot Marv I guess.

On February 17 2013 07:22 Artanis[Xp] wrote:
I really hope Toad's just making a play here because I don't see Marv flipping red.

Called it.

Artanis[Xp]

Netherlands12968 Posts

February 16 2013 22:57 GMT

#1089

Also I didn't look into Yamato's meta because I never really looked into Yamato as I found the case on him bad to begin with. I looked into Grush because someone asked for my opinion on him so I checked his filter and it was bad. I only checked his other games when you mentioned this is how he usually played.

marvellosity

United Kingdom36161 Posts

February 16 2013 22:57 GMT

#1090

On February 17 2013 07:57 Artanis[Xp] wrote:
Also I didn't look into Yamato's meta because I never really looked into Yamato as I found the case on him bad to begin with. I looked into Grush because someone asked for my opinion on him so I checked his filter and it was bad. I only checked his other games when you mentioned this is how he usually played.

you found yamato's filter acceptable and good then, a few hours before the lynch?

Artanis[Xp]

Netherlands12968 Posts

February 16 2013 22:58 GMT

#1091

No, a few hours before the lynch I was at a gig and I didn't have time to check it 20 minutes before the lynch.

marvellosity

United Kingdom36161 Posts

February 16 2013 22:58 GMT

#1092

ok. i can buy that.

HiroPro

United States2624 Posts

February 16 2013 23:00 GMT

#1093

sigh, I don't know what's worse. The fact that Toad actually thought faking a shot would clear or incriminate marvellosity or the fact that Artanis wouldn't play along and speculated about it being fake. doesn't mean that they're mafia. just irritates me that people do stuff like this for no good reason. Like if you can think of the idea to fake a shot, you have to realize that almost everyone else in the game will consider the fact that you are faking, they may play along or not, but it's just dumb and wastes time.

wherebugsgo

Japan10647 Posts

February 16 2013 23:02 GMT

#1094

Day 2

In Dreamville, everyone went to sleep, as serendipity would have it; no one was harmed.

Something smells funny, though.

The creator was disappointed that he did not get to squish anything that night.

Nothing happened!

48 hours to get in your votes. 15 alive: 8 to lynch.

Vivax

21972 Posts

February 16 2013 23:02 GMT

#1095

So, Toad, you pulled off your stunt. And what do you make with marv's post?

marvellosity

United Kingdom36161 Posts

February 16 2013 23:02 GMT

#1096

niiiiiiiiiiiiice

Vivax

21972 Posts

February 16 2013 23:03 GMT

#1097

Wtf

Artanis[Xp]

Netherlands12968 Posts

February 16 2013 23:03 GMT

#1098

Hiro: I figure marv to be town, and I figure town marv will try to do what's best for town for which a fake shot doesn't help.
Also, this is interesting.