EPTOn May 30 2007 14:33 Superiorwolf wrote:
MYLOSTTEMPLE IS TASTELESS?!?!? AHH!!!! *spasm*
MYLOSTTEMPLE IS TASTELESS?!?!? AHH!!!! *spasm*
rofl, i actually almost fell off my chair hahaha
TL Commentary Contest 2007 - Page 4
| Forum Index > News |
|
Kennigit
Canada19447 Posts
rofl, i actually almost fell off my chair hahaha | ||
|
yoinkity
Korea (South)43 Posts
| ||
Manifesto7
Osaka27154 Posts
| ||
|
intotherainx
United States504 Posts
On May 30 2007 13:36 Sosha wrote: ya, most ppl just do a play-by-play analysis of the game.. which any one can do. "ok purple is attacking now.." "oh man, he's getting killed by blues tanks, he'll have to retreat or he'll lose his units" Thats about what most commentaries will consist of. Sure, that's part of the commentary, but it's not all! Every commentator makes good use of what's happening live and past history and experiences. Like in wrestling, they'll call the moves as they happen, but they will also talk about what the wrestler did in the previous match, what they did last week and what they're talking about doing in the future. Likewise in competitive BW - u should annouce whats going on in the match, but also what each player has in mind, what they've done in similar situations (if they're being contained by lurker/scourge/ling) and what the upperhand-player can do to finish the game etc.. The Korean commentators are always talking - it's hard to believe that they're just calling play-by-play, when theres 3 of them there talking. Surely they're talking about aspects of the map, the different players who just played in similar matchups, previous experiences of the player who's playing at the moment and what will happen for this player if he succeeds in that game. That kid, I guesss who is SuperiorWolf, ONLY did play-by-play.. and was very bad at that.. I swear hes so bad at commentating. Situation: P makes robo fac commentary: Oh we might see some reaver drops The Korean commentators, after early game discussion (usually about history, match importance, pressure, styles) are usually talking about what both players need to do to win the match or swing it in their favor. It's actually amazing how accurate they are-- usually, the pro gamers end up doing exactly what the commentators say they should, or they make a mistake and lose the game. A lot of it has to do with the timing of pushes or attacks, and since I'm spoiled by the Korean commentators, I'm going to look for really good English ones ;P. | ||
|
Klaz
Ireland334 Posts
Also please note, I tried to do these in 'live,' style in that I haven't seen these vods in a while, so I tried to not watch them b4 doing the commentary to add to the freshness/excitement of it. Which also means mistakes are more likely. Savior vs Iris OSL Season 3 Semi - game 1 - Neo Araknoid This is my first attempt and it's pretty noob. The commentary starts about 1 minute into the video. Again this one is just a basic play by play with some analysis and is not that good so you might wanna skip it entirely. Savior vs Iris OSL Season 3 Game 2 - Reverse Temple This one is more decent and the game is pretty exciting too. Savior vs Iris OSL Season 3 Game 3 - Longinus II Longish game but fun nevertheless. Commentary a little less focussed here also. Savior vs Iris OSL Season 3 Game 4 - Hitch Hiker A good fast game. I'd prolly pick this or game 2 as the 'best,' quick ones. Savior vs Iris OSL S3 Semi Game 5 - Neo Araknoid A great game and since this is my fifth commentary hopefully the quality is better than earlier tries also. I really had fun doing these and if anyone is intersted i'd be happy to do more. I'd appreciate any advice/comments about style/content etc. but would prefer positive criticism that will help me to improve! Hope you guys have fun watching em. Klaz | ||
|
orionClan
Canada188 Posts
On May 31 2007 08:08 Klaz wrote: Savior vs Iris OSL S3 Semi Game 5 - Neo Araknoid i only quoted that one because i havent listened to anyone of them but I really found you to be great^^ i listened to the first.. i lied. great improvement in no time was nice. on another note, Van Wilder: The Rise of Taj | ||
|
Klaz
Ireland334 Posts
 | ||
|
CharlieMurphy
United States22895 Posts
Can me and a friend both comment on a video at the same time? | ||
|
Superiorwolf
United States5509 Posts
 edit: Wow, the last one was really good. I think you are good in incorporating midlevel strategy and enthusiasm as well. If anyone was to win this, I would say it is you, and I'm not joking. edit edit: this is the only thing I have to offer  Sea.Leta vs StOrk edit edit edit: + Show Spoiler + why did stork go get another expo when he had like 0 probes and was constantly being dropped? | ||
|
mnm
United States4493 Posts
| ||
|
yubee
United States3826 Posts
On May 31 2007 11:27 CharlieMurphy wrote: next friday, not sure yet, and yes you can both do one, it says in the OPIf I didn't have other shit to do I might make one of these. When is the deadline? What is the prize? Can me and a friend both comment on a video at the same time? | ||
|
Superiorwolf
United States5509 Posts
yubee, I was wondering, since this contest will spawn ~10-30 commentaries, maybe we should compile them at the end and put them all in a huge package for people to download. It would be organized, fun to have a record of and also helpful for anyone who wanted to have commentaries  | ||
mikeymoo
Canada7170 Posts
I was gonna just improv - sing about everything that happened. I guess it wouldn't win, so I'll do it another time when I'm free. lolol just gave this a shot with a random VOD on my hard drive. "Probe from 2 keeps movin' along Commentator talks as I sing my song. Found the SCV, Terran's in shit. His proxy's screwed if he can't defend it. Thanks to proxy, P goes 10/12 gate. micromanagement determines fate..." Then I stopped rhyming because it was becoming too difficult =P | ||
|
Klaz
Ireland334 Posts
Has anyone else entered? just curious as there haven't been any updates on it | ||
|
micronesia
United States24713 Posts
On May 31 2007 22:03 Superiorwolf wrote: Making a new VOD for the contest tomorrow. yubee, I was wondering, since this contest will spawn ~10-30 commentaries, maybe we should compile them at the end and put them all in a huge package for people to download. It would be organized, fun to have a record of and also helpful for anyone who wanted to have commentaries It would be cool if a respected player did a few moments introduction and a few minutes of commentary for each of the individual commentaries. | ||
|
Superiorwolf
United States5509 Posts
| ||
|
yubee
United States3826 Posts
| ||
|
Klaz
Ireland334 Posts
| ||
|
Zalfor
United States1035 Posts
if i was entered, i would choose my pusan vs. flash video. go go iraq | ||
|
Klaz
Ireland334 Posts
| ||
| ||
